my care2
make a difference

community & fun

shares

share your passions, stories, inspirations, and more

May 14, 2009

Focus:Endangered Species
Action Request:Petition
Location:United States

It is difficult to believe in this day in age, with all that we know about sharks' plummeting populations, their critical role in ocean ecosystems, and the minimal risk they pose to humans, that the archaic and destructive practice of installing shark nets for "bather protection" still exists. But in KwaZulu-Natal (KZN), South Africa, a province ironically known around the world as one of the few places left where sharks and the ecosystems they keep healthy still thrive, untold numbers of harmless sharks, turtles, dolphins, and rays meet an untimely and senseless death each year by entanglement in the approximately 28 km of nets that are installed just off the beaches.

What are shark nets? Shark nets are essentially gill nets: long rectangular nylon mesh nets, 200-300 meters in length, that are positioned near the surface of the water and kept afloat with buoys. Sharks swim into these nets and are caught by their gills. The squares of mesh are designed to be just large enough for sharks to become entangled, but not escape. The more a shark or any other animal struggles in these nets, the more hopeless their situation becomes, and the more impossible their chances of escape and survival. The vast majority of these animals die an agonizing death by suffocation. Gill nets are widely considered to be one of the greatest threats to the survival of many species of marine animals.

 

In South Africa, the shark nets are installed in tiered patterns by the KwaZulu-Natal Sharks Board (KZNS. Just beneath the surface, they do not fully extend to either the top or the bottom and do not even come close to fully enclosing the beach areas. The result is that sharks can easily swim around or under the nets and into the shallow waters in which humans swim and surf. In fact, the KZNSB acknowledges on its own website that at least 33% of the sharks killed in these nets were actually on their way OUT from the beaches, rather than on their way in, and other sources estimate that this number is closer to 70%.

You see, the goal is not to provide a physical barrier to keep sharks away from the beaches, but rather to control shark populations by culling them. In many cases, the KZNSB places baited drumlines just outside the shark nets, which are designed to attract sharks in towards the beaches and kill them, either by biting the baited hooks on the drumlines or by entanglement in the nearby gill nets.

The process is entirely unselective, with nets installed all along the coast, including in Marine Protected Areas! The sole purpose of these nets is to kill all sharks in the area, including highly endangered species that would otherwise enjoy stringent legal protection, such as whale sharks and the great white shark. According to the KZNSB's own website, "The Marine Living Resources Act (Act 18 of 1998) controls the exploitation of marine plants and animals in South African waters. . . . The great white shark is totally protected; in 1991 South Africa being the first country in the world to do so." And yet, the KZNSB, which is governed by the KZN Department of Arts, Culture and Tourism, is exempted from these important conservation regulations in the interest of making tourists feel safe.

Sea Shepherd's Director of Shark Conservation, Kim McCoy, a founding member of the Shark Angels alliance, was outraged to witness first-hand the carnage caused by South African shark nets. "Sharks and other animals don't stand a chance against these nets," said McCoy. "They are brutal, indiscriminate killers designed to systematically cull a species for no other reason than to boost tourism by giving beachgoers a false sense of security against a severely sensationalized threat."

Shark Angels co-founder, Julie Andersen, who frequently leads groups of people on diving trips with the tiger sharks of Aliwal Shoal, clearly illustrates the irony of using shark nets to increase tourism, noting the number of tourists who come to South Africa each year specifically to dive with sharks. "Sharks in South Africa contribute a significant amount of revenue to the South African economy and provide countless jobs," said Andersen. "Live sharks mean tourists, jobs, and money. And that is recurring income-not the one-time income generated when a shark is killed."

Over the last three decades, more than 33,000 sharks have been killed in the KZNSB shark nets. And if that's not alarming enough, consider the 2,000+ turtles, 8,000+ rays, and 2,000+ dolphins who were also ensnared and killed.

In addition to the countless deaths of sharks and other species caused directly by the shark nets, their impact on our collective psyches is damaging to shark conservation efforts worldwide. The very existence of shark nets perpetuates the myth that sharks are bloodthirsty man-eaters, and that humans require some form of protection from them. The installation of shark nets reinforces our misguided and often irrational fears of sharks by legitimizing these concerns as valid. This in turn fuels the biggest issue faced in shark conservation: the public's apathy, or even loathing, towards sharks.

It could be said there was once a time and a place for shark nets. Perhaps decades ago, when the public knew little about sharks, the fear of shark attacks was running high, and shark populations were far healthier than they are today. The practice of installing shark nets in South Africa began in 1952, when little was known about sharks, and humans had yet to spend the next 50+ years ravaging our oceans, causing irreparable damage and the collapse of species after species. The public wanted "protection" from sharks, and shark nets served this purpose.

But since then, shark fishing has skyrocketed, eliminating a large percentage of the world's shark populations, and the public has been exposed to much information about the importance of biodiversity conservation and the true nature of shark behavior towards humans. In recent years, it has been proven that a variety of non-lethal shark deterrents, such as the Shark Spotters program funded by private donations and the City of Cape Town, can be equally effective, and that animals need not be killed to allow for peaceful coexistence in their domain. The need for shark conservation is now a well-established fact, as is the fact these animals are significantly misunderstood, with the actual risk of an unpleasant shark encounter infinitesimal.

Shark nets are an unnecessary and outdated practice designed to address an issue that could easily be tackled in a non-lethal way, and they blemish South Africa's image as a world leader in conservation. It is time for a change. It is time to get these shark nets out of the water, once and for all.

• Join the campaign to remove the nets! Make your voice heard. Please sign our petition against the nets and encourage everyone you know to do the same. http://www.removethenets.com/sign-the-petition

Click here to watch the latest Shark Angels production on the deadly shark nets of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa.

 

article_separator_480x1

Visibility: Everyone
Posted: Thursday May 14, 2009, 12:12 pm
Tags: shepherd shark angelspetitionsharksnetskilledsea [add/edit tags]

Group Discussions start a discussion
Comments
Or, log in with your
Facebook account:
Compose your comment and submit:




Author

Claudia Peters
Author Tools:
Compose New Share
female, age 33, married, 1 child
Maastricht, LB, Netherlands
CLAUDIA'S SHARES
Sep
9
(2 comments  |  discussions )
An eco-shitstorm is coming...everything rests upon whether or not we come to terms with the politics of earth and sky, evolution and transformation. Otherwise, in our lifetimes, we shall suffer......the fall of nature itself."    ; - Bob...
Jul
27
(0 comments  |  discussions )
http://www.oceansentry.or g/lang-en/home.html  The Ocean Sentry organisation supports the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society as well as it works as a wide awareness program, dialogue and respect for marine environment and those who inhabit it. O...
Jun
30
(1 comments  |  discussions )
When we first heard the rumors that Sea Shepherd might add the sleek, biodiesel-fueled powerboat called Earthrace to their efforts — we wanted to believe. But seriously, would it be possible? Could an anti-whaling organization land something ou...


SHARES FROM CLAUDIA'S NETWORK
Nov
30
(0 comments  |  discussions )
Ingestion of avocado - Persea americana has been associated with:--Myocardial Necrosis .....in mammals and birds and --Sterile Mastitis ............in lactating mammals. .Dogs, cattle, goats, horses, mice, rabbits, guinea pigs, rats, sheep, budge...
(0 comments  |  discussions )
I just ordered the coolest polar bear calendar for 2010. WOOT! David M. Booth, my good friend and partner on Cartoons: Polar Bear News has created an incredible set of calendars that includes some of his wonderful cartoons. I wanted to post a cover ph...
(0 comments  |  discussions )
Call for an international day of action for the release of animal rights activists imprisoned in the Netherlands - Wednesday, 02   Since 29 October 2009 Rieke S., an activist from Germany accused of releasing mink from a mink farm in Gelders...
(1 comments  |  discussions )
Ayurvedic Healing Foodsfrom Yoga Journal By Miriam Kasin Hospodar . Lemons are both purifying and nourishing, and they stimulate digestion. For reducing toxins, drink unsweetened lemonade as many times during the day as desired. Ghee (clarified...
(0 comments  |  discussions )
Here are three mini-meditations, moments to just stop and breathe and remember why you are here. A moment to check yourself out, to look within, and to find what is really meaningful to you. You can get it together even when you think it is all fallin...


MORE ALERT
Nov 30
Alert: BURNS FLAT, OKLA...THIS ANGERS ME MORE THAN I CAN SAY URGENT HELP NEEDED by Kathy C.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — From: CathyCross-PostingOKLA~EM ERGENCY~DYING LAB IN DIRE NEED OF HELP!!!!I know each state has its own animal problems, but I am sending this to adjacent states because, frankly, I haven't found that there is much in Oklahoma. Contact Terry Lynn if y... more
Alert: Hopeless Escalation....... by NotSilent S.
(1 comments  |  discussions ) — There are news reports that on Decembers 1st, Obama will be at West Point to announce that he is sending tens of thousands more troops to Afghanistan, this despite our rallies, vigils, petitions, phone calls and e-mails saying NO to MORE WAR. We ... more
Alert: Shame on Michael Vick by Metta H.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Michael Vick was arrested for illegal dogfighting.  He did unspeakable things to pit bulls.  Have you ever seen pit bulls play?  They're adorable.  Many of the Vick dogs are forever traumatized. Dogtown , a no-kill shelter in U... more
Alert: Restore Equality in California in 2010 by Gina C.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Seeking Equality minded people. We need volunteers in California to collect signatures to get our initiative to Repeal Prop 8 on the November 2010 ballot. Go to our website to sign up and download petitions www.SignForEquality.com We need to get 1 mi... more
Alert: Restore Equality in California in 2010 by Gina C.
(0 comments  |  0 discussions ) — Seeking Equality minded people. We need volunteers in California to collect signatures to get our initiative to Repeal Prop 8 on the November 2010 ballot. Go to our website to sign up and download petitions www.SignForEquality.com We need to get 1 mi... more
 
Content and comments expressed here are the opinions of Care2 users and not necessarily that of Care2.com or its affiliates.
Copyright © 2009 Care2.com, inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved