The Success and Failure of Ayn Rand: Shikha Dalmia Considers Where She Went Wrong
Nov 8, 2009
Alisa Zinovyevna Rosenbaum was born to a Russian-Jewish family living in Saint Petersburg in the early 20th century. Growing up, she witnessed the Russian Revolution of 1917 and the confiscation of her father's business by the victorious Soviet government. The Rosenbaums fled Russia and eventually wound up in America, where Alisa finished her schooling and changed her name to Ayn Rand. She became the celebrated author of novels such as Atlas Shrugged, The Fountainhead, and Anthem, in which Rand illustrated entire (fictional) societies in which the basic principles of market economics were developed within tales of human drama and transformed from a dry description of a socio-economic system into an entire world-view and philosophy of living. Objectivism - the name Rand gave to her system of thought - primarily valued self-concern over self-sacrifice, depicting altruism as a false humanism that actually implied greater harm to humanity than benefit. Yet, Shikha Dalmia, senior analyst at the Reason Foundation, hits the proverbial nail on its head in her insightful explanation of the ultimate failure of Rand's ideology to gain the popular appeal she sought - and how her ideas can succeed if they can evolve past her own personal biases:
The fact is that Rand gets harder to take as one grows older and concerns about those around us become more important than our own personal project of self development. The relentless, single-minded dedication to one's passions that Rand seems to favor requires a coldness of the soul, a narrowing of one's humanity--the natural interest in the fortune of others that Smith alludes to--that most people find is not exactly conducive to their happiness.
This has profound and unfortunate political consequences. On the practical level, it makes it difficult to build a strong and growing anti-government movement based solely on Rand's philosophy, because the older cohort of her followers is falling off on a regular basis. On the theoretical level, Rand's ideas offer no real possibility of developing robust civil society responses to address the needs of those down on their luck. It is difficult to imagine a Randian qua Randian, say, volunteering in a soup kitchen to feed the hungry, or even founding the Fraternal Order of Fellow Randians to provide free health coverage and housing to jobless and homeless Randians. Since misfortune and distress are a normal part of the human condition, a philosophy that offers no positive, private solutions to deal with them will just have a harder time making the case against government intervention stick.
Rand's resurgence is certainly a welcome antidote to the Big Government onslaught that the country is experiencing right now. In the age of bailouts, the world certainly needs to hear--loud and clear--her message of personal freedom as well as its corollary, personal responsibility. But if Rand is going to play a starring role in the long-term battle to defeat statist ideologies, rather than making episodic, cameo appearances, her work will require a radical overhaul. Ultimately, the best way to honor her is by making her cause succeed--even if that means jettisoning some of her intellectual baggage.
We at Derusha recognize the interdependence of all human beings across the planet and feel that social activism is not only a pressing responsibility to be shouldered by individuals and corporations alike, but a natural course of action that is reasonable within the context of pursuing that which is truly beneficial for one's self and for humanity together. As the Jewish sage and elder, Hillel, asked so eloquently:
In a world of negativity
where it seems that it
becomes easy to fall
under the shade of war
and hostility, there is
always peace to brighten
up our paths. When we
have peace in ourselves,
it spreads through our
actions and thoughts onto
others and th...
In his bestselling book
The Garden of Emuna,
Shalom Arush discusses
the overarching Divine
providence governing the
sale of any item:
A merchant with emuna
needs to know that every
article in his or her
inventory is under the
influence of absolute ...
As we see in the grand
scheme of things there
are many out to offer the
best solution in regards
to assistance in our
personal health. With
different options for our
health, we have the
choice for responsibility
or dependence on an
outside entity, w...
Continuing our series on
Lin Yutang's masterpiece
on American culture,
Yutang's thoughts on the
American philosophy of
life are presented:
The only important
problem of philosophy,
the only problem which
concerns us and our
fellow men, is the pro...
The Care 2 code of
conduct states "
You agree to not use the
Service to: ...upload,
post, email, transmit or
otherwise make available
any Content that
infringes any patent,
trademark, trade secret,
copyright or other
proprietary rights
("Right...
Here we are, children of
the night
Come in from the wind and
rain,
Wagons circled against
the foe
Fighting of the grief and
pain.
We are courageous, we are
afraid,
We move on but we have
stayed.
Here the prison walls are
crumbled,
Our rebellio...
They huddled in the
abandoned house that
night
United against the cold;
two fifteen, one twelve.
Met at a subway station,
lunch time at the trash
bin.
Reminisced about dad, two
six packs a night and the
back of his hand.
Teachers never noticed
th...
ALL I HAVE
All I have to offer you
Is this sip of wine,
A few drops of blood
An unknown grape
Gladly shed for me
All I have to offer you
Is this wilted flower
petal,
Bouquets that lined the
wall,
All gone now
The fra...
Blog: Administration plans new efforts on foreclosures by HM S.
(0 comments
|
discussions
)
— WASHINGTON -- The Obama
administration, battling
a foreclosure crisis that
shows no signs of
relenting, will step up
pressure on mortgage
companies to do more to
help people remain in
their homes, officials
said Saturday. more
Blog: Leaders say momentum building on climate change
(AP)
by mark s.
(0 comments
|
discussions
)
—
AP - Leaders of the
Commonwealth countries
called Saturday for a
legally binding
international agreement
on climate change and a
global fund with billions
of dollars to help poor
countries meet its
mandates.
more
Blog: Climate battle bill to top $300 billion: Guyana
(AFP)
by mark s.
(0 comments
|
0 discussions
)
—
AFP - The true cost of
fighting climate change
will top 300 billion
dollars and developed
countries may balk at
footing the bill,
Guyana's Prime Minister
Bharrat Jagdeo said
Saturday.
more
Content and comments expressed here are the opinions of Care2 users and not necessarily that of Care2.com or its affiliates.