19,336,745 members doing good!

shares

share your passions, stories, inspirations, and more

Jul 25, 2010

Date: 19 July 2010 р. 22:55
Subject: The OPEN letter to the senior 12 International Organizations for Animal Protection
To: soschats@soschats.org, wspa@wspa-international.org, clarissa.baldwin@dogstrust.org.uk, refugedethiernay@free.fr, sts@tierschutz.com, info@naturewatch.org, thw@tierhilfswerk.at, bg@tierschutzbund.de, stop.animals.genocid@gmail.com, vgt2@vgt-ch.org, press@rspca.org.uk

Copy: aktiontier@aktiontier.org

Dear representatives of international societies for animal protection! I am appealing to you, so as you are for 12 years interested in events on Ukraine and, and also attend them proper attention on your informational resources as far as it's possible.

I turn to you because during last year and a half information is given tendentiously and with substantial divergences in comparing to the actual situation concerning  homeless  animals in Kyiv, Ukraine and shelter of the Communal enterprise "Shelter for animals" in particular.

Killing animals is forbidden according to the Law "On the Protection of Animals from Cruelty" and from 2006 year such act consider as a crime.

Our people for 12 years have been fought for that killing was replaced with sterilization. For this purpose SPA SOS also was fighting throughout all its existence, as can be seen from it's numerous interviews and position together with other participants of conference 2009.04.06 (journalists and public organizations - http://www.forumspaskiev.org.ua/databox/2008/07/17518.php) against intentions of Kyiv municipal administration to introduce "euthanasia" for regulation of number of homeless animals in Kiev, that is contrary to Article 16 of Law "On the Protection of Animals from Cruelty":

"Control of the population of wild animals and animals not kept by man but existing in conditions wholly or  partly caused by human activity is carried out by surgical sterilization or biologically based methods and, where these cannot be used, by euthanasia".

and Kiev Program regulation number of homeless animals with humane methods (Decision of the Kiev City Council № 1080/3913 from October, 25, 2007):

 "1. To forbid the catсhing of animals with the aim of their elimination  on territory of Kyiv".

http://www.kreschatic.kiev.ua/ua/2990/doc/1212528559.html

Despite the fact that City authorities didn’t appropriate the declared funds for the program -"by the state on a 2008.12.12 financing of  the Program measures did  not come... project of decision of  Kiev City Council "About the Kyiv municipal program of regulation number of homeless animals with humane methods" for  consideration to Main Financial Administration did not come. Ratified decision 25.10.2007 № 1080/3913 also... did not come officially. Therefore funds on realization of the program was not  appropriated "(letter of Main financial administration № 048-2-1-04/73 -  http://dogicat.org/forum/download/file.php?id=2604 ),- publicity - animal carers, volunteers and animal protection organizations undertook a program to perform on their own costs.

Because of changes in directorship of Borodyanka shelter in September 2007, 10-years-old practice of murder ("euthanasia") was substituted by compulsory sterilization and release under care by volunteers. The new workers – volonters were arranged on work which start to adopt frightened and aggressive "prisoners" were caught at the past regime. In addition, they had  to nurture an  old shelter staff, which got used to slipshod attitude toward observing their duties, that quite often resulted in conflicts. - http://h.ua/story/157805/

Certainly, it was difficult, but better than permanent murder, which lasted 80 years and lead no result.

But this situation - that the animal were sterilized despite the lack of funding obviously irritates those people very much who during 10 years of endless "catch-and-kill" became rich due to permanent renewal of animal population (Borodyanka have for long time cooperated with the National Agrarian University, that is why mechanisms of regulating population are well known to them). It was the probable cause whysomeone did not want Kiev city program, performed by citizens themselves, produced the results.

New director was dismissed by fraudulent prosecutions (it was the following reason: the previous director Mr. M. Kuchinski killed animals, then he escaped with all official documents in July 2007 when he learned that he will be dismissed. Those killed animals were attributed to director Mr. T. Smurnuy on the ground that his signature is on the documents - http://mmr.net.ua/news/newsid/13817/), despite it being known to everyone that on 2007.09.28 – the day of presentation of the new director to animal protection organizations -(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7qR5x3UFZug) Mr. T. Smurnuy firstly officially entered "Borodyanka" and began his authority only since 13.09.2007.


Mrs. President of SPA SOS also was presented there : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6FkmcpAoTE

Later in the interview to "Khreschatyk" newspaper she stated that the conditions at Smurnuy's Borodyanka became worse, while it is the fact that Mr. Smurnuy has arranged volunteers on work to care and socialize the animals:

http://glazoo.livejournal.com/350113.html
http://alien-g.livejournal.com/139674.html
http://scady-sxe.livejournal.com/102786.html
http://dogicat.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=43&t=3
http://rutabo.livejournal.com/10169.html

After Mrs. Drozdova coming to her position all of new staff were exempt, while old workers were remained at their places.

http://ziza.ru/2009/09/22/sobachijj_prijut.html

As coming out from this interview http://www.kreschatic.kiev.ua/ua/3396/art/1223236808.html, Dot Hayten personally visited shelter and he could see conditions in this shelter which took place before volunteers appeared there.

In a recent interview with to Le Matin newspaper http://www.lematin.ch/actu/suisse/nyon-uefa-aide-castrer-chiens-chats-283900 Tommy Tomek said that «for the last 6 months of work stripping Kyiv and its environs destroyed 50,000 animals»,  in fact, since the New Year the main work is provided by Drozodva's team, and since March 2010 the wave of poisoning began decrease under the press of publicity.

Please admit also that a half of exterminated animals are sterilized animals that were already socialized and were on care of animal protect organizations and publicity.

http://animalprotect.org/forum/index.php/topic,1686.0.html
http://forum.ua-vet.com/viewtopic.php?f=25&t=5446&hilit=%D0%B1%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B4%D1%8F%D0%BD%D0%BA%D0%B5&start=450

You can ask any of hundreds animal keepers, whose animals suffered from such harsh measures.

Simultaneously togheter with mobile poison squads, established by Kiev City authorities eliminations of animals during this period was executed by the renewed "budka" of Mrs.Olga Drozdova, which turned Borodyanka situation back in old times and closed access to shelter for volunteers and citizens, which already many times tried to get there :

2009.08.15 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zr9VyFL53w8&feature=related
2009.09.16 - http://ntn.ua/uk/news/criminal/2009/10/16/2175
2010.01.19 - http://tvline.biz/ru/tv/?id=8698643&act=tvp&channel=3

Recently one of animal protectress was injured by dog-catcher of  Shelter for animals" at an attempt to prevent to elimination of animals at Antonov ASTC (from evidence of witnesses, in order to save the tranquilizer puppies were killed with spades). Concerning the dog-cather who injured her a criminal case was opened.

http://www.stb.ua/e107_plugins/videotv/videoview.php?view.20131
http://www.stb.ua/newsv.php?item.38424

According to Kiev City Administration statisitcs in August 2009 there were 7.6 thousand homeless dogs in Kyiv http://www.intv.ua/article/154497/, while the press-service of "Shelter for Animals" informed that there were around 20-30 thousands stray animals in Kiev .

Real animal population numbers significantly set too high, in order to create the impression that the сitizens are fighting with animals, for this purpose articles "about war with animals" appear in newspapers, and zoopsychologist of Borodyanka declares in press that after sterilization dog becomes aggressive.


New Vice Mayor Mrs. Alla Shlapak said that at the time of March 2010 there were 50.000 homeless dogs, while in recent years the number of homeless dogs and cats never exceed 5.000-6.000 - and it can be easily checked.

Now, the press-service of "Shelter for animals" reports that in three months they captured about 15.000 of dogs to justify in some way the number cited at the beginning of the year.

To compare the last director of Borodyanka Myron Kuchinsky (was a head since 2003 till 2007) officially said that every year they cought “16 thousand” of animals.

While in October 2003 the numbers were next:

"A Head of State Administration of Borodyanka A.Dunayenko answers to "All-ukrainian fund of animal protection":
- during 7 months of 2003 the shelter entered 1399 dogs;
- By this time 1298 dogs left the shelter, including:
- Returned to citizens - 78 dogs, died - 183;
- Subjected to euthanasia - 1108."


http://www.sos-animals.info/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=20%3A2009-10-29-12-45-10&catid=22%3Anews&Itemid=3%E2%8C%A9=ru

I personally through half of year in 2007 visited the Borodyanka and places where animals signed to capture (when caught animals were killed, and press-inform of Borodyanka claimed that are brought in a "good conditions") and personally convinced that during six months in Borodyanka never could refrain 1000 dogs and cats, while the majority of caught animals are cubs, that acounted the same way as adults.

I have personal experience convinced that almost any problem can be resolved peacefully, the cases when it is only one way - evacuation, are single. All young and socialized animals can be rehomed and others - sterilized to stop the endless reproduction of animals, which have been assisted by Borodyanka for 12 years, purposely taking the remaining animals and intentionally leaving the females.

SPA SOS, althought the new information about Borodyanka since Drozdova is on her post is absent on their web-site, twice paid attention to the work of new director - in the report to Interim Commission of Supreme Soviet of Ukraine for investigation the infringement of the Constitution of Ukraine and laws of Ukraine, making illegal decisions by officials of the Kiev city council and its executive body in 2009.05.07 and in interview to newspaper "Komsomolska Pravda" (2010.03.02).

"Animals in the MP" Shelter for Animals in Borodyanka contained in concetrate camp conditions. The funds appropriated for their maintenance, are not used for other purposes. Contrary to law, volunteers and carers of animals are forced to pay money for treatment and sterilization of homeless animals. The activity of these Сommunal enterprises requires thorough investigation by law enforcement agencies", - http://search.ligazakon.ua/l_doc2.nsf/link1/DF44Z00A.html

"Now a new director - mrs. Drozdova, I laid a great Hope on her management, but she continues to practice of previous leadership of this concentration camp for animals." Borodyanka is closed to visitors, but after all, they must be interested in visitors." - http://kp.ua/daily/020310/217502/

I spoke about this situation to the representative of SOS during a picket against poisoning on March 11, 2010 (where also protested against Drozdova: «ГЕТЬ ДРОЗДОВУ!» - http://community.livejournal.com/ua_indymedia/500952.html) but they seems to can't do nothing.

There was hope that the situation will improve after finishing Campaign "STOP UKRAINE" and declaration of Boris Kolesnikov about humane approach to solving the quastion of animals - but Borodyanka remains the same. There is a suspicion - would not new shelters, opened to Euro 2012, the same way as "european" shelter of Borodyanka? I would like to experience Borodyanka was never repeated by anyone in the world.

I put the great hope that with Your support the conditions in shelter will be turned backwards, as they were before, althought the succes of replacing "a new, humane director" (known as Drozdova) was provided by foreign animal-care organizations.

In this regard I would like to ask the seniour representatives of international animal protection associations: Do You support the Borodyanka in its current form (2009.12.15-2010.07.15) and whether You planing to illustrate this situation on Your websites?

For more, visit ukranian news and try on next sites:

http://helpdog.kiev.ua
http://forum.ua-vet.com/
http://forum.staffrise.com.ua/
http://dogicat.org/
http://animalprotect.org/
http://community.livejournal.com/animalrights_ua/
http://community.livejournal.com/eco_zooza_ua/

Kind regards,

Stefan Khrabrov, the citizen of Ukraine
Visibility: Everyone
Posted: Sunday July 25, 2010, 3:02 pm
Tags: animals sos borodyanka [add/edit tags]

Group Discussions start a discussion
Comments
Or, log in with your
Facebook account:
Compose your comment and submit:




Ard Kossa (0)
Sunday October 23, 2011, 8:10 am
Im from Ukraine. Its really is a problem

Author

Stepan Khrabrov
Author Tools:
Compose New Share
male , single
Kiev, Ukraine
STEPAN'S SHARES
Aug
8
(3 comments  |  discussions )
After Kravchuk's Promise to fix the situation with killing animals in Ukraine, - "And the quick reaction Yanukovych was not surprised. He believes that the orders given by the President, after the letter will be implemented faithfully. Otherwise, ...


SHARES FROM STEPAN'S NETWORK
May
24
(0 comments  |  discussions )
crisseica: I donate one tweet a day to help children recover from trauma. You can too! http://t.co/NzAMfGY3 #DT @operationSAFE
May
23
(0 comments  |  discussions )
crisseica: Animals Petition: TELEMADRID: Dejen de emitir el programa "Quiero ser torero" | http://t.co/Psu3QX82 http://t.co/bYEwSd84
(0 comments  |  discussions )
crisseica: "O GRITO DO BICHO": URGENTE: ONG de Portugal convoca todos nós contra touradas no distrito de Maia http://t.co/awSyjIKa
(0 comments  |  discussions )
crisseica: ま&at ilde;‚‹ã §ã ;™ï¼ 8;。-I am Maru 4.-: http://t.co/t4Qm1AHF via @youtube
(0 comments  |  discussions )
crisseica: Mountain lion in Santa Monica shopping area shot and killed - National Pet Rescue | http://t.co/9Ar3VB02 http://t.co/WnhbRgc6


MORE MEMBER BLOGS
May 24
Blog: Global warming winner: Once rare butterfly thrives by mark s.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Global warming is rescuing the once-rare brown Argus butterfly, scientists say. more
Blog: Antioxidants and Free Radicals by Clara M.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Most people have heard of antioxidants and free radicals, but many are unclear as to what they actually are. Free radicals are atoms which contain an odd number of electrons. They tend to form with the action of oxygen on certain molecules, and in an... more
Blog: Sky Watch Friday by Antonette S.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Click on photo to view in full-size Want to join in on the fun? Click here to see how you can be a part of Sky Watch Friday. Copyright ©2004-... more
Blog: Climate Warming Helps British Butterfly Spread by mark s.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Warming in Great Britain appears to have given a little brown and orange butterfly an edge. The brown argus butterfly has spread about 49 miles (79 kilometers) northward on the island over 20 years, observations indicate. more
Blog: Magma Crystals Hold Clues to Volcanoes' Inner Workings by mark s.
(0 comments  |  0 discussions ) — More than 500 million people live close to volcanoes that could erupt with little or no clear warning, causing widespread devastation and even global effects on climate, as in the case of the 1991 eruption of Mount Pinatubo. Although scientists keep ... more
 
Content and comments expressed here are the opinions of Care2 users and not necessarily that of Care2.com or its affiliates.
Copyright © 2012 Care2.com, inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved