START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
Jan 31, 2007

Focus:Animal Welfare
Action Request:Think About
Location:United States

A Brief Guide to Meat and Dairy Labels and Their Relevance to Animal Welfare


Meat and Dairy Labels

An alert shopper may notice a variety of labels on meat and dairy products making such claims as "grass fed," "cage free," or "natural."

What exactly do these labels mean, especially in terms of animal welfare? Some of the labels represent adherence to actual guidelines, while others don't even relate to the conditions in which the animals lived. So how meaningful are these labels to compassionate consumers and for the animals involved?

Eliminate Confusion About Label Profusion

Following are each of the most common labels, decoded:

"Certified Organic"*: The animals must be allowed outdoor access, with ruminants—cows, sheep, and goats—given access to pasture. (Consumers should be aware that there have been concerns about lax enforcement, with some large-scale producers not providing meaningful access to the outdoors.) Animals must be provided with bedding materials. Use of hormones and antibiotics is prohibited. These are requirements under the National Organic Program regulations, and compliance is verified through third-party auditing. Currently, there are no federal or state programs to certify aquatic animals, including fish, as organic.

Free-Range Poultry: The birds should have outdoor access. However, no information on stocking density, the frequency or duration of how much outdoor access must be provided, nor the quality of the land accessible to the animals is given. Indeed, the only national guidelines for the term "free range" are basic U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) requirements that poultry raised for meat—but not for eggs—have some access to the outdoors. Producers must submit affidavits to the USDA that support their animal production claims in order to receive approval for this label.

Pasture-Raised and Grass-Fed: The animals have access to the outdoors and are able to engage in natural behaviors, such as grazing. However, no information on stocking density, the frequency or duration of how much outdoor access must be provided, nor the quality of the land accessible to the animals is given. Producers must submit affidavits to the USDA that support their animal production claims in order to receive approval for these labels.

"Certified Humane"*: The animals must be kept in conditions which allow for exercise and freedom of movement. As such, crates, cages, and tethers are prohibited. Outdoor access is not required. Stocking densities are specified to ensure animals are not overcrowded, and animals must be provided with bedding materials. Hormone and non-therapeutic antibiotic use is prohibited. Compliance is verified through third-party auditing. Certified Humane is a program of Humane Farm Animal Care.

Hormone-Free, rBGH-Free, rBST-Free, and No Hormones Added: These labels on dairy products mean the cows were not injected with rBGH or rBST, genetically engineered hormones that increase milk production. Hormones are commonly used to speed growth in beef production, and their use by both the beef and dairy industries are associated with animal welfare problems. Chicken and pig producers are not legally allowed to use hormones. These claims do not have significant relevance to the animals' living conditions. There may be some verification of this claim.

Cage-Free: As birds raised for meat, unlike those raised for eggs, are rarely caged prior to transport, this label on poultry products has virtually no relevance to animal welfare. However, the label is helpful when found on egg cartons, as most egg-laying hens are kept in severely restrictive cages prohibiting most natural behaviors, including spreading their wings.

Vegetarian-Fed: These animals are given a more natural feed than that received by most factory-farmed animals, but this claim does not have significant relevance to the animals’ living conditions.

Dolphin-Safe: In the United States, a Dolphin Safe label on a can of tuna means that no dolphins were intentionally chased, encircled, traumatized, injured, or killed in order to catch tuna swimming beneath the dolphins. Due to pressure from other countries, the U.S. government has made multiple attempts to weaken the rules and allow the use of the label even if the tuna were caught by deliberately setting nets on dolphins. The HSUS and others have won a series of lawsuits to maintain the integrity of the label, so a Dolphin Safe label in the United States still means that the tuna were not caught using methods that harm dolphins.

Natural: This claim has no relevance to animal welfare.

Grain-Fed: This claim has little relevance to animal welfare, but feeding ruminants—cows, sheep, and goats—high levels of grain can cause liver abscesses and problems with lameness. As such, beef products labeled "grain-fed" most likely come from animals who suffered lower welfare than beef products labeled "grass-fed."

"Free-Farmed"*: The animals must be kept in conditions which allow for exercise and freedom of movement. As such, crates, cages, and tethers are not prohibited. Outdoor access is not required. Stocking densities are specified to ensure animals are not overcrowded, and animals must be provided with bedding materials. Hormone and non-therapeutic antibiotic use is prohibited. Compliance is verified through third-party auditing. Free-Farmed is a program of American Humane.

No label: Most likely, the absence of a label means animals are raised in factory farm conditions that significantly reduce their welfare.


* The claims listed in quotation marks—Certified Organic, Certified Humane, and Free-Farmed—are programs with guidelines or standards, whereas the remaining claims are only labels. 

Visibility: Everyone
Posted: Wednesday January 31, 2007, 4:40 pm
Tags: [add/edit tags]

Group Discussions
Comments
Or, log in with your
Facebook account:

Jackson Z. (5)
Tuesday February 28, 2012, 3:43 pm
I know this is old, but just in case anybody is reading this... "vegetarian-fed" does not mean the feed is natural to the animal. More natural than, say, feeding them cannibal feed, but it's still incorrect to say it's natural. Chickens, for example, are omnivores, which is why it always bothers me that "vegetarian fed" is a selling point. A cow can be fed a 100% vegetarian diet without actually eating anything a cow should be eating.

Author

Lisa S.
female, age 28, single
Mcminnville, OR, USA
LISA'S SHARES
Dec
5
(0 comments  |  discussions )
Give Us, O Lord, a Steadfast Heart     Give us, O Lord, a steadfast heart, which no unworthy affection may drag downwards; give us an unconquered heart, which no tribulation can wear out; give us an upright heart, which ...
(2 comments  |  discussions )
Graham Scones (makes 4-6)1 cup whole wheat pastry flour8 whole wheat grahams, crushed1 Tb flaxseed meal2 tsp baking powder1/4 cup cold margarine1/4 - 1/3 cup soy milk1 1/2 Tb Splenda sugar blend (or 3 Tb sugar)Variations: orange cranberry (add 1/3 cup...
(0 comments  |  discussions )
Vegan German Pancakes1/2 cup white whole wheat flour1 Tb ground flax seeds1 1/2 tsp Splenda sugar blend1/8 tsp salt3/4 cup or more soy milkapricot or raspberry preservesberriespowdered sugar (optional)Combine flour, flax meal, sugar, and salt in a med...
Feb
23
(1 comments  |  discussions )
Consider animal suffering:- nearly 10 billion land animals killed for food each year in the US- one million animals are killed for food every hour in the US- American Meat Institute guidelines which specify that 95% of the cattle must be rendered inst...


SHARES FROM LISA'S NETWORK
Oct
4
(0 comments  |  discussions )
When John lost his father, all hope for school was shattered. He had only two years more to write his O’ Levels and finish his secondary education. He had no choice but to eventually stop attending classes as not only couldn’t he afford to...
Oct
2
(0 comments  |  discussions )
  Hope Chapel Church, Zambi a Pray for God’s wisdom as the church raises the remaining funds needed to sink a borehole on site. The church has managed to buy the steal, the water tank, and the truck for this project. ...
Oct
1
(0 comments  |  discussions )
  Pastor Fibion serves Forgotten Voices as Spiritual Ministry Advisor. He was our former Zimbabwe Director. In his role, Fibion shares a weekly devotion with the Forgotten Voices family. Please enjoy this reflection from a pastor with a de...
Sep
28
(0 comments  |  discussions )
Remmy, our Africa/Zambia Director is coming this fall and we want you to have some fun with him! Though he can’t be everywhere, we have come up with 3 ways you can engage with him and have a blast! All 3 also provide you with a way for youÂ...
Sep
27
(0 comments  |  discussions )
In Zambia, there is a phrase for the early rains that signal the start of a new farming season. Chihuna ngombe – literally translated “cattle  ;rescuer” The first rains help shoots of green grass to sprout for animals to fe...


MORE ALERT
Feb 18
Alert: ATTEND TUCSON'S 32ND ANNUAL PEACE FAIR & MUSIC FESTIVAL by Stuart T.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — \\r\\nCOME TO: \\r\\nTucson\\\' s 32nd Annual Peace Fair and Music Festival2014 Theme: Climate JusticeThis FREE event is Arizona\\\'s largest gathering of Peace, Justice, and Environmental groups, with Live Music, Tables, Food, Entertainment, Children\\\'s ... more
Alert: Petitions and More, Febr. 18 by Anneke A.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — http://animalpetitionsand more.blogspot.nl/2014/02/ petitions-and-more-febr-1 8.html\\r\\n more
Feb 17
Alert: DEMAND ALL PUPPY MILLS BE ILLEGAL ACROSS CANADA by jill C.
(1 comments  |  discussions ) — \\r\\n\\r\\nDEMAND ALL PUPPY MILLS BE ILLEGAL ACROSS CANADA\\r\\n\\r\\nauthor:  jill Campbell\\r\\ntarget:&nbs p;Prime Minister Steven Harper, Senators, Cabinet & Parliament Members\\r\\nsignatures:& nbsp;1,463\\r\\n\\r\\n\\r \\n\\r\\n\\r\\n1,463\\r\\ n5,000\\r\\nwe\\\'ve go... more
Alert: Petitions and More, Febr. 17 by Anneke A.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — http://animalpetitionsand more.blogspot.nl/2014/02/ petitions-and-more-febr-1 7.html\\r\\n more
Feb 16
Alert: Petitions and More, Febr. 16 by Anneke A.
(0 comments  |  0 discussions ) — http://animalpetitionsand more.blogspot.nl/\\r\\n\\ r\\n more
 
Content and comments expressed here are the opinions of Care2 users and not necessarily that of Care2.com or its affiliates.