START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
Jan 21, 2014

Europe’s depressed carbon markets are to be given an automatic ‘market reserve’ facility allowing at least 100 million carbon allowances – or 12% of the market – to be withheld or released to buoy prices, according to a document set for release on 22 January.

The plan is set out in a one page legal amendment to the Emissions Trading System (ET directive that EurActiv has seen. This would allow an 'auto-backload' of carbon allowances to be triggered “if the total number of allowances in circulation is lower than 400 million,” the paper says.

But the automated mechanism will not begin operating until 2021 and it is far from ideas pitched by environmentalists such as a minimum carbon price, or a ‘carbon central bank’ that would have handed a regulatory board the power to set prices and so determine climate policy. 

“The Commission may raise the dikes, but it is forgetting to pump out the toxic floodwater,” said Greenpeace’s EU climate policy director Joris den Blanken, referring to the large volumes of surplus carbon allowances in the system.

“And there's no guarantee that a new tide won't come rushing in again,” he added.

Few NGO or industry analysts canvassed by EurActiv expected the new proposal to have a significant long-term effect on carbon prices, although the proposal’s simplicity was welcomed by some.  

The EU’s Emissions Trading System (ET is widely acknowledged to face three problems:

  • A linear cap on carbon allowances that reduces at 1.74% a year, far below what is needed to meet the EU’s objective of an 80% cut in emissions by 2050
  • The surplus of billions of allowances as a result of economic recession and over-allocation
  • It operates as a fixed supply of allowances that is structurally unable to adapt to changing demand patterns, so causing price volatility.

“This proposal is mainly trying to address the third problem and some of the surplus perhaps,” said Jesse Scott, the environment head of Eurelectric, the European electricity industry’s association in Brussels.

'A tweak to the market'

“It’s helpful as far as it goes but not wildly exciting,” she added. “It is a tweak to the functioning of the market that is not going to have a radical impact on the basic cap which drives prices.”

In an impact assessment accompanying the 2030 package, with which the new structural reform will be released tomorrow (22 January), the Commission does propose increasing the linear cap to 2.2%.

But number-crunchers at Friends of the Earth contend that, on its own, this will delay achievement of the EU’s decarbonisation goals from 2050 to 2066 (as opposed to 2070 with a 1.74% target) and call for a cap above 3%.

Brook Riley, a spokesman for the group, described the proposal as “too little, too late” and “just abysmal”. Sarah Deblock though, a spokeswoman for the International Emissions Trading Association said that a majority of her members would welcome a similar ‘flexible supply mechanism’.

Such a reserve would “improve the ETS,” she said, “although our reflection has looked at different types of triggers.”

Carbon market glut

However, Europe’s enormous carbon allowance glut, which continues to depress carbon prices and offers no disincentive to coal use, would remain unaddressed by the withholding of 100 million allowances a year.

According to research by the environmental group Sandbag, up to 3.8 billion allowances in the trading period to 2020 could be surplus to requirements. Analysis by the group indicates that manufacturing sectors accrued roughly 680 million spare allowances over the 2008-2011 trading period, with a net value of around €10.5 billion.  

Prices now are too low to run up such huge surpluses. But because EU companies can meet their emissions cutting obligations by offsetting them with carbon allowances bought at bargain basement prices, Sandbag estimates that the bloc’s emissions could even increase by 2.2% every year and still technically meet the EU’s 2020 target of a 20% cut on the greenhouse gas emissions level in 1990.

Damien Morris, Sandbag’s head of policy told EurActiv that the new proposal had been stripped down to little more than “a permanent automated backloading system.” His group still hoped for a discrete cancellation of allowances, or an option for allowances to depreciate in the reserve through an expiry date system.

Backloading

In 2013, a backloading proposal to address market over-supply was put to the European parliament, where it faced ire from conservative politicians and industry groups which argued that it would make their businesses uncompetitive in a global market largely unencumbered by climate policies.

A compromise proposal that pleased few but saved the faces of many finally limped home last Spring. Carbon prices are still languishing at below €5 a tonne today.

Surprisingly, officials from the employers confederation, BusinessEurope, which led opposition to the backloading move last year declined to comment on this draft ahead of publication.

But a letter sent by the group’s director-general Markus Beyrer to the EU president Jose Manuel Barroso on 8 January 2014, supports a continued allocation of free allowances to industry at a reference price of €30 a tonne, the value at which the bloc hoped allowances would trade.  

“In the longer-term, full compensation through free allocation based on benchmarks must allow the most efficient companies to be globally competitive without being penalized by indirect and direct carbon costs,” Beyrer’s letter said.

Visibility: Everyone
Posted: Tuesday January 21, 2014, 7:47 am
Tags: [add/edit tags]

Group Discussions
Comments
Or, log in with your
Facebook account:

Author

marjolein s.
female, age 62, committed relationship, 2 children
Amsterdam, Noordholland, Netherlands
MARJOLEIN'S SHARES
Feb
13
(0 comments  |  discussions )
In a meeting of the EU General Affairs Council nineteen states opposed the approval of  GM Maize Pioneer 1507, developed jointly by DuPont and Dow Chemica l, while five supported it and four abstained from any view, EU officials sa...
Feb
11
(0 comments  |  discussions )
How to spread the news 02/11/14 This is really awfull, i did write many hosst announcements, but they dissapeared, luckely
Jan
12
(5 comments  |  discussions )
I shared 3 times the smae story with different types, so one of them would show up in my group Greenforever, but NOOOO, nothing is there, strangely enoough old shares come up, i am sure i shared much more the last months but in hostshares it ends 6 mo...


SHARES FROM MARJOLEIN'S NETWORK
Mar
31
(1 comments  |  discussions )
ZEN was suspended by Eric with no warning. We don't know any reasons nor how long it will last.... I asked about it on the forum but my post was immediately deleted. 2 threads and petitions about Zen also. And 2 her help-groups. :-( Untill today no...
Feb
18
(0 comments  |  discussions )
Hello my C2 Family, First let me say Thank You to those of you who have so sweetly fwd my posts. You are SO AWESOME!! I will never forget your help. Anytime I can repay the favour, please tell me. Second, my Submit button has disappeared leaving ...
Feb
16
(0 comments  |  discussions )
My little Valentine, Lily, loves taking pictures. She said "Mom, let's do a Valentines photo shoot, so I can send the pics as cards to our friends" lol.  I can't believe she's 5 yrs old! Looking back at my 1st album of her: "Lilyanna Jane, is cra...
Feb
15
(0 comments  |  discussions )
New Petition! Speak out against Time-Warner Merger with Comcast! Let your opinion be know before your bill goes up and your programming choices dwindle. Urge DOJ and FCC to Not Allow Merger of Time-Warner and Comcast http://www.thepetitionsit e.com...
Feb
13
(0 comments  |  discussions )
New Petition! Speak out against Time-Warner Merger with Comcast! Let your opinion be know before your bill goes up and your programming choices dwindle. Urge DOJ and FCC to Not Allow Merger of Time-Warner and Comcast http://www.thepetitionsit e.com...


MORE MESSAGE
Mar 31
Message: what's going on?... by Apolonia P.
(1 comments  |  discussions ) — ZEN was suspended by Eric with no warning. We don't know any reasons nor how long it will last.... I asked about it on the forum but my post was immediately deleted. 2 threads and petitions about Zen also. And 2 her help-groups. :-( Untill today no... more
Feb 17
Message: Petitions that stop abuse to the speechless by Aza C.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Can someone please tell me why petitions that want to end animal abuse,end the on going pain being inflected on the poor helpless animals. Paim that only ends when the animal dies. Is it that the 23 plus million members don't care or understand that... more
Message: Thanks by Gail B.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Thank you all for the warm welcome, still learn how to use the site. May the grounds you set your feet upon be blessed every step of the way. more
Feb 15
Message: My Daughter's Friend Needs Help by Cameron F.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — This is Venus Marquez's friend, Gina Arellano. Venus is a friend of my daughter Nikka.  She seems to be covered in rashes/sores due to possibly chickenpox and needs to raise at least 200 Euros - about $275 US - to cover medical expenses. If you... more
Feb 13
Message: Free Puppy Ads In Terrifying Abundance! by Karen O.
(0 comments  |  0 discussions ) — I was so upset, when on my homepage, in the news section...there appearred, all sorts of advertisements all over, for free puppies...these are surely going to reappear in the future,  as horrific abuse cases.  What is wrong with people? Do t... more
 
Content and comments expressed here are the opinions of Care2 users and not necessarily that of Care2.com or its affiliates.