START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
Jan 26, 2008

How collective decision-making works well; how it goes wrong.

The Wisdom of Crowds
by James Surowiecki
Anchor; Reprint edition (August 16, 2005), $14
ISBN: 0385721706

New Yorker business columnist James Suroweicki demonstrates that large groups of people can be smarter than an elite few, explaining both why democracy works, and also how it goes wrong.

The crowd can be wise: IF it is diverse; if it has a particular kind of decentralization; if its individual members think independently; and if they all have some information.

A group made up of only people who agree with each other (such as all-conservative OR all-liberal groups) make bad decisions. So will a group in which most members defer to the judgment of a few. And even a large and diverse group of independent-minded people are unlikely to make good engineering decisions if none of them know anything about engineering.

The collective judgment of a large and diverse group of voters, however, WHEN all of them have some information (even if each of them thinks all the others are misinformed), AND they are free to disagree and contest with each other, AND their individual opinions can be aggregated in a process that produces a collective judgment -- that judgment will be a good one. Not a perfect one, but good enough to live with, and better than an elite few could have decided for them.

Some of the elements of "why it goes wrong" connect with "how societies fail" in Collapse (by Jared Diamond). When a small group of decision-makers with centralized power are insulated from the effects of their decisions, you have a disaster in the making.

Suroweicki makes the point that the input of each individual's local information and personal self-interest is important, and essential to making democracy work. Each individual voter does not have to be fully informed about all factors affecting everybody; each individual does have to have a way to get our own information into the pot and our personal questions answered.

The book is a good contribution to understanding how Homo Wannabe Sapiens could actually become Homo Sapiens Sapiens, but it is just a starting point. Much more needs to be written on how to create good group decisions, and how to avoid bad ones. Quickly, before a dumb, partisan, groupthink mob runs us all off the edge of a cliff.

Some quotes:

"Gustave Le Bon had things exactly backward. If you put together a big enough and diverse enough group of people and ask them to 'make decisions affecting matters of general interest," that group's decisions will, over time, be 'intellectually [superior] to the isolated individual,' no matter how smart or how well informed he is."

"Diversity and independence are important because the best collective decisions are the product of disagreement and contest, not consensus or compromise... Paradoxically, the best way for a group to be smart is for each person in it to think and act as independently as possible."

James Suroweicki on NPR

Also worth reading: Blink and The Wisdom of Crowds, a dialog between James Surowiecki and Malcolm Gladwell, in Slate magazine.

Imported from external blog

Visibility: Everyone
Posted: Saturday January 26, 2008, 7:58 am
Tags: thinking books [add/edit tags]

Group Discussions
Or, log in with your
Facebook account:


Anitra Freeman
female, age 65, married, 2 children
Seattle, WA, USA
(0 comments  |  discussions )
Instead of using this blog, I have been posting most of what I write on Facebook ( lately (since 2010). For the last few months, I\'ve been reorganizing my website ( as a WordPress blog, intending to make all future po...
(0 comments  |  discussions )
\nAre we given rights by God, or by government?NEITHER ONE.Our rights and freedoms are protected by the U.S. Constitution; they are not bestowed by the U.S. Constitution. We have them because we were born human, period. Rights pre-exist law, or else la...
(0 comments  |  discussions )
\nBad news; a Real Change vendor tells me that Seattle police chased him out of his encampment last night; \"They\'re chasing everybody off of Queen Anne.\" He was told if he came back he\'d be arrested for criminal trespassing. He saw no trespassing sign...
(0 comments  |  discussions )
I am demonstrating blogging to a workshop student.

(0 comments  |  discussions )
\\nWe declare that no man nor nation nor race have a greater right than others to enjoy the fruits of their work, as the ecological sphere is our common condition of life http://www.beat Nous déclarons qu\\\'auc...
(0 comments  |  discussions )
\\n Kære Læser\\n Vi deltager i Eovendo, hvor man kan penge til støtte for gode formÃ¥l ved at se reklamer pÃ¥ computer, tablet eller smartphone. \\n  NÃ¥r vi henviser ...
(0 comments  |  discussions )
\\nBeats4Change is proud to present the plans for a caring community in Mgbidi, Imo State, Nigeria. \\n We have purchased a plot of land as foundation for our activities there.So far you can help by donating a click on \\n Beats4Change is...
by O O O.
(0 comments  |  discussions )
  Care2Connect. \\r\\n \\r\\n  Create Your Legal Commuity Society \\\"Standing\\\"\\r\\n\\r \\n  First consult this active hard votes pre made,Postions pre written to not change or change less & be fully trackable to hold them to your person...
(0 comments  |  discussions )
\\n \\nLISTEN-to-DONATEThis months plays benefit the Solar Electric Light Fund. The tune \\\"Grothbros - Tollah Tra Flex\\\" is from the Beats4Change album \\\"Here Comes the Sun\\\". The full album is available for purchase at BandcampThe Solar Electr...

Mar 31
Blog: How to Extend the Life of your TRIAD Boilers by Kayleigh L.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — \\nHow to Extend the Life of your TRIAD Boilers \\r\\n \\r\\nCorliss Engine Review\\r\\nEvery user desires to prolong the life of a unit. TRIAD assists their clients in achieving this important objective by informing them of ways they can avoid problems... more
Feb 27
Blog: Dr Oz Weight Loss - The 100% Natural And Very Efficient Diet Pill by Debra S.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — \\nYes, Dr. Oz called Garcinia Cambogia Extract (HCA) the Holy Grail of Weight Loss. He went on to say, “Anytime I see a scientist get this excited about something like Garcinia Cambogia Extract and when I looked through some of this research and... more
Blog: My Favorite Websites by krysta I.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — \\nIFAW:\\r\\nOCEANA:\\r\\nPETA:\\r\\nEARTH 911:\\r\\nANI MALs ASIA:\\r\\n \\r\\n\\r\\n\\n more
Feb 21
Blog: testing one two three by Geoff M.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — hello world more
Blog: Garcinia Cambogia Reviews From Actual People Garcinia Pure Extract Is A Huge Success February 20 by Dany M.
(0 comments  |  0 discussions ) — \\nGarcinia Cambogia Reviews From Actual People Garcinia Pure Extract Is A Huge Success February 20\\r\\nGarcinia Cambogia System The Dr. Oz Lose Weight Quick Process Without Having Side Effects\\r\\nHe went on to say, “At any time I see a researcher... more
Content and comments expressed here are the opinions of Care2 users and not necessarily that of or its affiliates.