my care2
make a difference

community

shares

share your passions, stories, inspirations, and more

Blog: What we owe what we eat.  



Ok, people-I am going to try and post this article via PRRA as I think it may interest those who missed it when it was first written three years ago. Thanks and have a beautiful day!

 

WHAT WE OWE WHAT WE EAT

WHY, MATTHEW SCULLY ASKS, IS CRUELTY TO A PUPPY APPALLING AND CRUELTY TO LIVESTOCK BY THE BILLIONS A MATTER OF SOCIAL INDIFFERENCE? By George F. Will | NEWSWEEKJul 18, 2005 Issue  Sponsored by    Email To A Friend Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link. Your Name Your Email Address Recipient's Email Address Separate multiple addresses with commasMessage (optional):       Matthew Scully, a former speechwriter for President George W. Bush, is the most interesting conservative you have never heard of. He speaks barely above a whisper and must be the mildest disturber of the peace. But he is among the most disturbing.If you value your peace of mind, not to mention your breakfast bacon, you should not read Scully's essay "Fear Factories: The Case for Compassionate Conservatism--for Animals." It appeared in the May 23, 2005, issue of Pat Buchanan's magazine The American Conservative--not where you would expect to find an essay arguing that industrial livestock farming involves vast abuses that constitute a serious moral problem.The disturbing facts about industrial farming by the $125 billion-a-year livestock industry--the pain-inflicting confinements and mutilations--have economic reasons. Ameliorating them would impose production costs that consumers would pay. But to glimpse what consumers would be paying to stop, visit factoryfarming.com/gallery.htm. Or read Scully on the miseries inflicted on billions of creatures "for our convenience and pleasure":"... 400- to 500-pound mammals trapped without relief inside iron crates seven feet long and 22 inches wide. They chew maniacally on bars and chains, as foraging animals will do when denied straw... The pigs know the feel only of concrete and metal. They lie covered in their own urine and excrement, with broken legs from trying to escape or just to turn..."It is, Scully says, difficult, especially for conservatives, to examine cruelty issues on their merits, or even to acknowledge that something serious can be at stake where animals are concerned. This is partly because some animal-rights advocates are so off-putting. See, for example, the Feb. 3, 2003, letter that Ingrid Newkirk, president of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals--animals other than humans--sent to the terrorist Yasir Arafat, complaining that an explosive-laden donkey was killed when used in a Jerusalem massacre.The rhetoric of animal "rights" is ill-conceived. The starting point, says Scully, should be with our obligations--the requirements for living with integrity. In defining them, some facts are pertinent, facts about animals' emotional capacities and their experience of pain and happiness. Such facts refute what conservatives deplore--moral relativism. They do because they demand a certain reaction and evoke it in good people, who are good because they consistently respect the objective value of fellow creatures.It may be true that, as has been said, the Puritans banned bearbaiting not because it gave pain to the bears but because it gave pleasure to the spectators. And there are indeed degrading pleasures. But to argue for outlawing cruelty to animals because it is bad for the cruel person's soul is to accept, as Scully does not, that man is the only concern.Statutes against cruelty to animals, often imposing felony-level penalties, codify society's belief that such cruelty is an intrinsic evil. This is a social affirmation of a strong moral sense in individuals who are not vicious. It is the sense that even though the law can regard an individual's animal as the individual's property, there nevertheless are certain things the individual cannot do to that property. Which means it is property with a difference.The difference is the capacity for enjoyment and suffering. So why, Scully asks, is cruelty to a puppy appalling and cruelty to livestock by the billions a matter of social indifference? There cannot be any intrinsic difference of worth between a puppy and a pig.Animal suffering on a vast scale should, he says, be a serious issue of public policy. He does not want to take away your BLT; he does not propose to end livestock farming. He does propose a Humane Farming Act to apply to corporate farmers the elementary standards of animal husbandry and veterinary ethics: "We cannot just take from these creatures, we must give them something in return. We owe them a merciful death, and we owe them a merciful life."Says who? Well, Scully replies, those who understand "Judeo-Christian morality, whose whole logic is one of gracious condescension, or the proud learning to be humble, the higher serving the lower, and the strong protecting the weak."Yes, of course: You don't want to think about this. Who does? But do your duty: read his book "Dominion: The Power of Man, the Suffering of Animals, and the Call to Mercy." Scully, a conservative and hence a realist, knows that man is not only a rational creature but a rationalizing creature, putting his intellectual nimbleness in the service of his desires. But refraining from cruelty is an objective obligation. And as Scully says, "If reason and morality are what set humans apart from animals, then reason and morality must always guide us in how we treat them."You were warned not to read this. Have a nice day.

Posted: Monday February 25, 2008, 2:12 pm
Visibility: Everyone
      

Tags:
add/edit tags

Group Discussions start a discussion
Comments add comment
Compose your comment and submit:

Jacqueline Tremlin (452) 		Tuesday February 26, 2008, 8:42 am
This is a GREAT article! Thank you so much for posting it. Lots of good points to mull over...

Tom M. (312) 		Wednesday March 12, 2008, 4:09 am
Thanks Deedy. This puts things into perspective. All the anger (myself included) over the puppy tossing Marine while millions of ignored farm animals are suffering horribly cruel lives and deaths 24/7. Although for a brief shining moment another video focused the public's attention on what really goes on before those juicy steaks and hamburgers end up on their dinner plates. Of course, the USDA quickly spun the matter into a "health" issue, ignoring the plight if the "contented" dairy cows that were rewarded for "giving" us their milk until they were worn out by being stabbed with forklift blades, electrocuted with cattle prods, poked in the eyes and waterboarded with high-pressure hoses just because they couldn't stand up anymore.

Flag as Inappropriate

AUTHOR: DEEDY M.

female
single
Covington, KY, USA
DEEDY'S SHARES
Jul 5
Blog: Primate sanctuary of note
(1 comments  |  discussions ) — Please checkout http://www.junglefriends. org/ as featured on ABC Primetime this week. more
Jun 11
Blog: Farm animals Anti-Cruelty Act
(2 comments  |  discussions ) — Quote:"The Farm Animals Anti-Cruelty Act was introduced in Congress on June 5th by Congressmen Christopher Shays (R-Ct) and Jim Moran (D-Va). H. R. 6202 seeks to make a federal offense the killing, mutilation, disfigurement, torture or intentiona... more
Jun 3
Blog: Animal Welfare films./documentaries
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Hi, all! Since there are many of you on CARE2 who are concerned with Animal Welfare issues, I thought it would be interesting to get input on what films, if any, you may have seen that inspired you to really get involved with the issues affecting... more
Mar 17
Blog: Deedy's "noted and submitted" stories for 3/17/08
(3 comments  |  discussions ) — Hopefully, these will be of interest to folks who may have missed them on the CARE2 News page.IFAW's Seal Team Prepares for the WorstEnvironment  (tags: sea, ls, wildlife, animals, globalwarming, Animal Welfare, canada, seal hunt ) Kevi... more


ads keep care2 free
SHARES FROM DEEDY'S NETWORK
Oct 6
Blog: Queen Elizabeth wants a Raise, by Scott S.
(0 comments  |  0 discussions ) —  I own YOU,.. Lizzy To the citizens of the United States of America from Her Sovereign Majesty Queen Elizabeth II: In light of your failure in recent years to nominate competent candidates for President of the USA and thus to govern yourse... more
Blog: L.A. Woman(Liz),Doors,I See Your Hair Is Burnin, Never Saw a Woman, So Alone, by Scott S.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — L.A. Woman(Liz),Doors,I See Your Hair Is Burnin, Never Saw a Woman, So Alone,  visit site Offbeat  (tags: L.A. Woman(Liz), Doors, I see your hair is burnin, Never saw a woman, So Alone, Love, scott shaubel, photons, evolution ) Scott - ... more
Message: Wilderness Survival: Back to Nature by Fred H.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — If you were lost in the wilderness right now, do you have the skills to survive? This group focuses on wilderness survival in different locations such as the tropics, deserts, forests, & more!http://www.care2.com /c2c/group/wilderness_sur vival more
Alert: SPCA RAIDS TWO PUPPY MILLS IN ONE WEEK by Carol W.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — PLEASE READ TODAY'S UPDATE ON THE SPCA. READ & SIGN MY PETITION.  WE NEED YOUR HELP TO CLOSE ALL PUPPY MILLS.  http://www.thepetitionsit e.com/1/action-alert   Thank You Carol Waterman A Dedicated Animal Activist Montreal, Qc... more
Blog: SPCA RAIDS ON 2 PUPPY MILLS by Carol W.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — UPDATE ON THE PUPPY MILL RAIDS IN QUEBEC.   PLEASE VISIT MY SITE AT: http://www.thepetitionsit e.com/1/action-alert Thank You. Carol Waterman A Dedicated Animal Activist Montreal, Qc. Canada more


ads keep care2 free
MORE MEMBER BLOGS
Oct 6
Blog: Most Alaskan Glaciers Retreat and Thin (LiveScience.com) by mark s.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — LiveScience.com - Most of Alaska's glaciers are retreating or thinning or both, a new book by the U.S. Geological Survey reports. more
Blog: NASA spacecraft zooms above surface of Mercury (Reuters) by mark s.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Reuters - A car-sized NASA spacecraft zoomed above the surface of Mercury on Monday, viewing rocky terrain never before seen up close on our solar system's sun-baked innermost planet, scientists said. more
Blog: IDNR Hearings Continue: Proposed Mine Site on Eagle Habitat by Jane W.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — The fight continues!  Tomorrow and Wednesday there will be hearings in Springfield, Illinois regarding the proposed mine site in the sensitive wetland/eagle habitat along the Illinois River.  I will update my share after the hearings! I'... more
Blog: Hands On: WowWee Alive Panda Cub by Darrin O.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — We got a chance recently to check out a robot of the cute and cuddly variety, as opposed to the kind that will take your face off. The sickeningly cuddly and cute WowWee Alive Panda Cub. While it doesn’t go so far as to chew bamboo in your livin... more
Blog: Queen Elizabeth wants a Raise, by Scott S.
(0 comments  |  0 discussions ) —  I own YOU,.. Lizzy To the citizens of the United States of America from Her Sovereign Majesty Queen Elizabeth II: In light of your failure in recent years to nominate competent candidates for President of the USA and thus to govern yourse... more
 
Content and comments expressed here are the opinions of Care2 users and not necessarily that of Care2.com or its affiliates.
Copyright © 2008 Care2.com, inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved