Blog: ACLU Wins Challenge to Patriot Act NSL Provision  



ACLU HomeJoin the ACLUTake Action
ACLU LogoACLU Online Title
May 9, 2008

ACLU Wins Challenge to Patriot Act NSL Provision


Internet Archive librarian, Brewster Kahle, is finally allowed to speak out about the FBI's unconstitutional NSL. Watch the video.

The ACLU won a hard-fought victory in another legal challenge to the national security letter (NSL) provision of the Patriot Act. As the result of a settlement agreement, the FBI this week withdrew an unconstitutional national security letter issued to the Internet Archive and agreed to unseal the case, finally allowing the Archive's founder to speak out for the first time about his battle against the record demand.

The NSL, issued in November of 2007, asked for personal information about one of the Archive's users, including the individual's name, address, and any electronic communication transactional records pertaining to the user. Brewster Kahle, founder and digital librarian of the Internet Archive, decided to fight the NSL because it exceeded the FBI's limited authority to issue such demands to libraries. The lawsuit is the first known challenge to an NSL served on a library since Congress amended the national security letter provision in 2006 to limit the FBI's power to demand records from libraries.

The NSL included a gag order, prohibiting Kahle from discussing the letter and the legal issues it presented with anyone else except his attorneys, who were also gagged. The gag also prevented the ACLU from discussing the NSL with members of Congress, even though an ACLU lawyer who represents the Archive recently testified at a congressional hearing about the FBI's misuse of NSLs.

"The free flow of information is at the heart of every library's work,” said Kahle. “That's why Congress passed a law limiting the FBI's power to issue NSLs to America's libraries. While it's never easy standing up to the government - particularly when I was barred from discussing it with anyone - I knew I had to challenge something that was clearly wrong. "

NSLs are secretly issued by the government to obtain access to personal customer records from Internet Service Providers, financial institutions, and credit reporting agencies. In almost all cases, recipients of the NSLs are forbidden, or "gagged," from disclosing that they have received the letters. The ACLU has challenged this Patriot Act statute in federal court in two other cases where the judges found the gags unconstitutional: one involving an Internet Service Provider; the second, a group of librarians.

Since the Patriot Act was passed in 2001, relaxing restrictions on the FBI's use of the power, the number of NSLs issued has seen an astronomical increase, to nearly 200,000 between 2003 and 2006.

>> Read more about the case.

>> Learn more about the ACLU's work on NSLs.


Posted: Saturday May 10, 2008, 8:24 am
Visibility: Everyone
     

Tags: No Tags

Group Discussions start a discussion
Comments  

Flag as Inappropriate

AUTHOR: JUST CAROLE

female, age 107
committed relationship, 1 child
Culver City, CA, USA
JUST'S SHARES
Jul 24
Blog: IN SOLIDARITY FOR CATE -- WHO HAD THIS ARTICLE WRONGFULLY REMOVED FROM C2NN
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — July 18, 2008 The Audacity of VanityBy Charles KrauthammerWASHINGTON -- Barack Obama wants to speak at the Brandenburg Gate. He figures it would be a nice backdrop. The supporting cast -- a cheering audience and a few fainting frauleins -- would b... more
Jul 18
Blog: Mail Ballots - cost, convenience, voter turnout, and other lies
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — July 18, 2008 Mail Ballots - cost, convenience, voter turnout, and other lies By Charles Corry ~ In Colorado we are approaching a primary election on August 12th and bumbling county clerks and other election entities are scrambling to promot... more
Blog: Conyers Trying to Avoid Impeachment of Bush and Cheney
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Ok, Patriots . . . THIS SH*T HAS GONE FAR ENOUGH! Take a stand -- we are ALL being toyed with and mocked! Note it, circulate it, and act on it!!!!*C*IMPEACH THEM!Conyers Trying to Avoid Impeachment of Bush and Cheney ".....left little doubt that ... more
Jul 17
Blog: Ohio Attorney Files to Lift Stay on '04 Election Case, Cites Allegations, Evidence of Massive Fraud by a Number of GOP Operative
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Ohio Attorney Files to Lift Stay on '04 Election Case, Cites Allegations, Evidence of Massive Fraud by a Number of GOP OperativesLeading Data Security Expert Joins Press Conference, Case, Notes Fraudulent Patterns That Should Have Triggered Investiga... more


SHARES FROM JUST'S NETWORK
Jul 24
Message: Am i making any difference? by James H.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Is any one reading what i re-post? Am i just wasting my time? Dose any one care? more
Message: [AnimalAntiCrueltyCrusaders] Bait Dog Killed in Fight-Dog Training / Authorities Turn a Blind Eye in Tenn,‏ by James H.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — [AnimalAntiCrueltyCrusade rs] Bait Dog Killed in Fight-Dog Training / Authorities Turn a Blind Eye in Tenn,‏From:animalanti crueltycrusaders@yahoogro ups.com on behalf of MuleKist (QARR@nycap.rr.com)Sent:T hu 7/24/08 7:05 PMTo: AnimalAntiCrueltyCrusa... more
Message: [AnimalAntiCrueltyCrusaders] FW: Animal Shelter Sued For Backing From Agreement‏ by James H.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — [AnimalAntiCrueltyCrusade rs] FW: Animal Shelter Sued For Backing From Agreement‏From:animal anticrueltycrusaders@yaho ogroups.com on behalf of Marjorie Banks (Banks_marj@comcast.net)S ent:Thu 7/24/08 8:39 PMTo: UnitedStatesAnimalProtect ion@yahoogrou... more
Message: [friendsofgraysoncohumanesoc] Leitchfield,KY:Cat Stuffed in Backpack, Thrown Over Shelter Fence, Transport Available‏ by James H.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — [friendsofgraysoncohumane soc] Leitchfield,KY:Cat Stuffed in Backpack, Thrown Over Shelter Fence, Transport Available‏From:friend sofgraysoncohumanesoc@yah oogroups.com on behalf of schwender@aol.com (schwender@aol.com)Sent:T hu 7/24/08 9:09 PMTo: fr... more
Message: Re: [friendsofgraysoncohumanesoc] Re: I cleaned up your mess today (sad but true story long)‏ by James H.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — From:friendsofgraysoncohu manesoc@yahoogroups.com on behalf of Jo Ann Gutschow (jo1970@att.net)Sent:Thu 7/24/08 9:35 PMTo: friendsofgraysoncohumanes oc@yahoogroups.com thnx.good luck on your search when you are ready, its hard to loose a k... more


MORE MEMBER BLOGS
Jul 24
Blog: The Killing Machines by ella Z.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Duncan Kennedy reports on Mexico's illegal drugs trade and the lives that are lost as a result of it. Mexico's illegal drugs trade is worth billions of dollars a year. The price is death on a grand scale; so far this year more than 1,400 people ... more
Blog: People of the World, Look at Me by ella Z.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — The people of Berlin experienced the full range of Barack Obama's charisma on Thursday evening. At times he was reserved, at others engaging. Sometimes combative, and also demanding. Ultimately, though, the message he delivered at the Siegesäule... more
Blog: The Obamessiah’s Prayer by Frank H.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) —   The Obamessiah’s Prayer By Michelle Malkin  •& nbsp; July 22, 2008 06:57 AM Reader Ben E., nauseated by the media worship of the Obamessiah, has penned the The Obamessiah’s Prayer for his liberal flock. It g... more
Blog: Cliff Notes version of Obama press conference in Jordan by Frank H.
(0 comments  |  discussions ) — Cliff Notes version of Obama press conference in Jordan By Michelle Malkin  •& nbsp; July 22, 2008 11:10 AM 1. “Uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu uuuuuuh.” 2. As commander-in-chief, er, rather, when I’m commander-in-chief&hel... more
Blog: One Green Summer by Head T.
(0 comments  |  0 discussions ) — If your summer vacation plans include traveling with the canine members of your family, be sure to check out Care2's traveling tips for dogs.And speaking of the dog days of summer, get these five favorite raw vegan salad dressings--perfect for hot... more
 
Content and comments expressed here are the opinions of Care2 users and not necessarily that of Care2.com or its affiliates.