December 16, 2007 -- Celebrated author Mark Steyn has been summoned to appear before two Canadian judicial panels on charges linked to his book “America Alone."
The book, a No. 1 bestseller in Canada, argues that Western nations are succumbing to an Islamist imperialist threat. The fact that charges based on it are proceeding apace proves his point.
Steyn, who won the 2006 Eric Breindel Journalism Award (co-sponsored by The Post and its parent, News Corp), writes for dozens of publications on several continents. After the Canadian general-interest magazine Maclean's reprinted a chapter from the book, five Muslim law-school students, acting through the auspices of the Canadian Islamic Congress, demanded that the magazine be punished for spreading “hatred and contempt" for Muslims.
The plaintiffs allege that Maclean's advocated, among other things, the notion that Islamic culture is incompatible with Canada's liberalized, Western civilization. They insist such a notion is untrue and, in effect, want opinions like that banned from publication.
Two separate panels, the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal and the Canadian Human Rights Commission, have agreed to hear the case. These bodies are empowered to hear and rule on cases of purported “hate speech."
Of course, a ban on opinions - even disagreeable ones - is the very antithesis of the Western tradition of free speech and freedom of the press.
Indeed, this whole process of dragging Steyn and the magazine before two separate human-rights bodies for the “crime" of expressing an opinion is a good illustration of precisely what he was talking about.
If Maclean's, Canada's top-selling magazine, is found “guilty," it could face financial or other penalties. And the affair could have a devastating impact on opinion journalism in Canada generally.
As it happens, Canadian human-rights commissions have already come down hard on those whose writings they dislike, like critics of gay rights.
Nor should Americans dismiss this campaign against Steyn and Maclean's as merely another Canadian eccentricity. Speech cops in America, too, are forever attempting similar efforts - most visibly, on college campuses.
In fact, New York City itself has a human-rights panel that tries to stamp out anything deemed too politically incorrect.
Since 9/11, Americans have been alert to the threat of terror from radical Islamists. But there's been all too little concern for a creeping accommodation of radical Islamist tenets, like curbs on critical opinions.
That needs to change.
Posted: Tuesday May 13, 2008, 11:21 am Visibility:
Everyone
Blog: 9/11 -- No planes, just special effects
(0 comments
|
discussions
)
— This one takes us deep
down the rabbit hole.On
9/11, "hijacked
airliners" did things
that were physically
impossible and beyond the
capacity of any pilots,
experienced or not.Here's
why the news media
doesn't want to look too
closely into the simple,
... more
Aug 7
Blog: Rein in DHS Travel Abuses
(0 comments
|
discussions
)
—
Planning a vacation?
Thinking about traveling
outside the country?
If you travel outside the
United States, you can
kiss your right to
privacy, and perhaps your
laptop, digital camera
and cell phone, goodbye.
With no suspicion and no
explanatio... more
Aug 3
Alert: Justice for Julie
(0 comments
|
discussions
)
—
Justice for Julie
Target: Kevin Kane,
Thomas Griffin, State's
Attorneys, Connecticut
Sponsored by: The
Care2 Coalition for
Justice
Horror story of a
substitute teacher right
here in my home state,
tried and wrongly
convicted on s... more
Jul 24
Blog: IN SOLIDARITY FOR CATE -- WHO HAD THIS ARTICLE WRONGFULLY REMOVED FROM C2NN
(0 comments
|
discussions
)
—
July 18, 2008 The
Audacity of VanityBy
Charles
KrauthammerWASHINGTON --
Barack Obama wants to
speak at the Brandenburg
Gate.
He figures it would be a
nice backdrop. The
supporting cast -- a
cheering audience and a
few fainting frauleins --
would b... more
Blog: Sweet Freedom for 1,000+ Puppy Mill Dogs‏ by James H.
(0 comments
|
discussions
)
—
Sweet Freedom for 1,000+
Puppy Mill
DogsFrom:Best
Friends Animal Society
(info@bestfriends.org)Sen
t:Mon 8/25/08 6:49 PMTo:
jamesheater@hotmail.com
To ensure that these
emails go to your inbox,
add us to your safelist.
If you are having tro... more
Blog: A PET'S TEN COMMANDMENTS...‏ by James H.
(0 comments
|
0 discussions
)
—
Fwd: A PET'S TEN
COMMANDMENTS...From:
NANCY VERNAND
(joandoe@sbcglobal.net)Se
nt:Wed 8/27/08 3:35 AMTo:
C Shumate
<charky38@yahoo.com>
; wrote:
Date: Tue, 26 Aug 2008
19:34:17 -0700 (PDT)From:
C Shumate
<charky38@yahoo.com>
;Subjec... more
Blog: I DO NOT CARE ANY MORE by James H.
(0 comments
|
discussions
)
—
WHO own's
AMERICAN?
Fwd: I
AgreeFrom:NANCY
VERNAND
(joandoe@sbcglobal.net)Se
nt:Wed 8/27/08 3:40 AMTo:
C Shumate
<charky38@yahoo.com>
; wrote:
Date: Mon, 25 Aug 2008
19:56:19 -0700 (PDT)From:
C Shumate
<charky38@yaho... more
Blog: 2008 by Leo S.
(0 comments
|
discussions
)
—
LETRA DEL AÑO 2008
DEL PORTAL ORICHAS.COM
Odun
7-1
Ody-OkanaArayeElese Iya
Ara
Testigos
8
7-10
Orichas que gobiernan
este año
YEMAYA, y su Oricha
acompañante es
CHANGO.
Refrán
Na Tobi Eye Ife, N... more
Blog: Sweet Freedom for 1,000+ Puppy Mill Dogs‏ by James H.
(0 comments
|
discussions
)
—
Sweet Freedom for 1,000+
Puppy Mill
DogsFrom:Best
Friends Animal Society
(info@bestfriends.org)Sen
t:Mon 8/25/08 6:49 PMTo:
jamesheater@hotmail.com
To ensure that these
emails go to your inbox,
add us to your safelist.
If you are having tro... more
Blog: A PET'S TEN COMMANDMENTS...‏ by James H.
(0 comments
|
0 discussions
)
—
Fwd: A PET'S TEN
COMMANDMENTS...From:
NANCY VERNAND
(joandoe@sbcglobal.net)Se
nt:Wed 8/27/08 3:35 AMTo:
C Shumate
<charky38@yahoo.com>
; wrote:
Date: Tue, 26 Aug 2008
19:34:17 -0700 (PDT)From:
C Shumate
<charky38@yahoo.com>
;Subjec... more
Content and comments expressed here are the opinions of Care2 users and not necessarily that of Care2.com or its affiliates.