START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
1,353,497 people care about Women's Rights

Bottle-Feeding Bans are Harmful for Moms and Babies

Bottle-Feeding Bans are Harmful for Moms and Babies

In an effort to promote breastfeeding, Venezuela’s Congress is considering a proposal to ban baby bottles entirely within the country. Odalis Monzon, one of the legislators behind the measure, spoke on state television last Thursday, saying “We want to increase the love (between mother and child) because this has been lost as a result of these transnational companies selling formula.”

The proposed legislation is clearly well-meaning. Scientists and doctors have known for years that breastfeeding has as number of benefits for infants. It protects against common childhood illnesses, lowers a child’s risk of developing obesity and diabetes later in life, and best of all… unlike formula, it’s 100% free.

The legislation also makes sense when you look at how formula has been marketed worldwide. For decades, companies like Nestle pushed formula feeding aggressively in developing nations, giving away free samples in maternity wards and sometimes even hiring sales girls in nurse uniforms to stop by women’s houses.

In poor nations, this was bad news for two reasons. First, mothers would try to “stretch” their supply of formula by diluting it with extra water, resulting in malnourished infants. And second, these women often had little access to clean water, resulting in infants dying of water-borne illnesses.

Due to public backlash in the 70s and 80s, formula manufacturers like Nestle have backed off in how they promote formula in poor countries. But in many ways, the damage has been done. The World Health Organization estimates that worldwide, only about 40% of babies are exclusively breast-fed for the first 6 months of life.

It’s easy to understand why Venezuela would want to promote breastfeeding in light of this history with formula companies, but passing laws that place restrictions on women’s parenting choices is not the solution.

The truth is, formula may not be quite as healthy as breast milk, but not all mothers are able to breastfeed. Some mothers may have infectious diseases or be taking medications that prevent them from breastfeeding. Some babies may have trouble latching on. Some women may simply find breastfeeding painful or uncomfortable — or they may not have the time while juggling a home and a career. As millions of adults raised on formula can attest, it is by no means a death sentence.

While the politicians behind the law say that bottles would be allowed in special cases — like the death of the mother, or for women with inadequate milk supply — families would have to individually petition the health ministry to receive an exemption. If a child isn’t able to breastfeed, is it really a good idea to spend hours, days, or weeks waiting for a government exemption? It seems babies would be much healthier if a struggling family could simply go to the grocery store and pick up food for their child as needed.

There’s also another downside to this proposal — it penalizes working moms who want to pump breast milk for their children. Very few workplaces would allow a woman to bring her child to the office for the first six months or year of life to breastfeed every few hours. (And employers are already likely to look down on breastfeeding employees anyway.) Without bottles, how is a woman supposed to store pumped milk for her child?

In the end, laws like this end up hurting the very women and children they claim to protect. Hopefully, Venezuela will do the right thing and shoot this proposal down this week.


Read more: , , , , ,

Photo credit: Tom & Katrien via Flickr

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it


+ add your own
7:43PM PDT on Jul 14, 2013

Thank you

6:35AM PDT on Jun 25, 2013

This seems quite ridiculous, far too restrictive. While breastfeeding is preferable some women for various reasons are unable to do so. Jane R certainly has an interesting comment as do many others. Governments can over extend their reach. Wait for it....a black market in baby bottles coming up soon!

8:44AM PDT on Jun 24, 2013

Thanks for sharing.

4:09AM PDT on Jun 24, 2013

Why to ban?

3:32PM PDT on Jun 23, 2013


6:00PM PDT on Jun 21, 2013

It is better to breastfeed than bottle feed,but IT SHOULD BE THE PARENTS' CHOICE!!!! The govt needs to stay the f**k out of family affairs.

6:29AM PDT on Jun 21, 2013


5:43AM PDT on Jun 21, 2013

For most women, breastfeeding is clearly the best option, but if you are unable to breastfeed for any reason, making your own formula is the next best thing.

Infant formulas have been found contaminated with all sorts of toxic chemicals, including melamine, arsenic, BPA, perchlorate, dioxin, and genetically engineered ingredients; most commercial formulas are also loaded with fructose.

Recipes for infant formulas made from cow’s milk, goat’s milk, and liver are provided. Try a search on the Internet, "homemade organic baby formula recipes."

But be careful about the water you use to make your infant formula as some may contain harmful levels of manganese, fluoride, and other contaminants.

3:51AM PDT on Jun 21, 2013

Wouldn't it be better to ban the formula and not the bottle by making the formula by prescription?

3:53PM PDT on Jun 20, 2013

This is just as bad as bans on breastfeeding. And I've seen some breastfeeding advocates get pretty militant, being judgmental of women that weren't able to breastfeed and saying that it's a mental block or something. Of course it's better to breastfeed, but it isn't always possible. They should trust mothers to use their own judgment instead of telling them how to parent.

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

While ants are important to the ecosystem, I'm not sure what to think of the suggestion of intentionally…

meet our writers

Julie M. Rodriguez Julie M. Rodriguez is an arts, green living, and political writer based in San Mateo, CA. Her work... more
ads keep care2 free

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.

site feedback


Problem on this page? Briefly let us know what isn't working for you and we'll try to make it right!