START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good

BREAKING: 9th Circuit Rules Prop 8 Trial Tapes to Stay Sealed

BREAKING: 9th Circuit Rules Prop 8 Trial Tapes to Stay Sealed


The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals has handed down a decision to prevent the unsealing of trial tapes recorded during the 2010 Proposition 8 trial.

From the court opinion, Judge Stephen Reinhardt writing:

We resolve the narrow question before us on a narrow basis when we conclude that the district court abused its discretion by ordering the unsealing of the recording of the trial notwithstanding the trial judge’s commitment to the parties that the recording would not be publicly broadcast.

[. . .]

For the reasons discussed above, we reverse the order of the district court as an abuse of its discretion and remand with instructions to maintain the trial recordingunder seal.

The order also notes that the district court shall not return to former Chief Judge Walker the copy of the recording that he lodged with the court.

Chief U.S. District Judge James Ware ruled on Sept. 19 of last year that there was no compelling reason to keep the trial tapes out of the public domain, and that in the interests of public confidence in the judiciary it was in fact imperative to release the tapes so as to be as transparent as possible. He also ruled that a Supreme Court motion blocking Judge Vaughn Walker, who presided over the trial, from broadcasting live trial proceedings did not prevent unsealing the tapes after the fact.

As such, Ware ordered the tapes to be unsealed but stayed his decision until September 30 to allow for further court action. Defendant intervenors appealed.

The 9th Circuit, in the opinion issued today, disagreed with Ware’s ruling, writing that Judge Vaughn Walker, compelled by the Supreme Court, had given his assurances that the tapes would not be broadcast and that his sticking to that word was a key interest in maintaining public confidence. This in itself, the court said, constituted a compelling reason to keep the trial tapes under seal.

As such, the 9th Circuit judges concluded “for the reasons we explained above, that the integrity of the judicial process is a compelling interest that in these circumstances would be harmed by the nullification of the trial judge’s express assurances, and that there are no alternatives to maintaining the recording under seal that would protect the compelling interest at issue. In short, the recording cannot be released without undermining the integrity of the judicial system.”

Following an exhaustive trial period in 2010, the now retired Judge Vaughn Walker ruled that the 2008 ballot initiative, Proposition 8, was unconstitutional at even the most basic level of judicial scrutiny. Today’s ruling is a procedural matter that has no impact on this original case, for which the 9th Circuit is yet to hand down a decision.

The court must also decide on a motion to vacate Judge Vaughn Walker’s ruling. Defendant intervenors argue Vaughn Walker was in a same-sex relationship at the time of the trial and, they say, this may have introduced an element of bias in his ruling.

Related Reading:

California Supreme Court Hears Prop. 8 Standing Issue

Unsealing of Prop 8. Trial Tapes Gets Hearing

Prop. 8 Tapes Case May Itself be Recorded

Read more: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Photo used under the Creative Commons Attribution License, with thanks to angela n.

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it


+ add your own
10:22AM PST on Feb 6, 2012

That's really a shame since California is always so progressive, contemporary and forward thinking and believes in truth and transparency. I'd like to know what exactly it is they're trying to hide.

Judith g., California hasn't gotten there yet but if it keeps up like this it will be as bad as Texas, Arizona, Utah, Alabama, Florida and anyplace that's dominated by conservative based hatred, intolerance and bigotry.

3:39AM PST on Feb 6, 2012

As I recall from reading the original court ruling, the homophobes' own witnesses made the case for gay marriage. That's what the homophobes don't want people to see.

10:18AM PST on Feb 5, 2012

P.S. After those comments, that should be enough reason to open them up. Those comments admit there's wrongdoing. We, the people, know wrongdoing occurs; but as long as How we were wronged by judicial misconduct is not disclosed, we would be kept deaf, dumb and blind about it, that makes everything legal and OK! @$$holes!

10:07AM PST on Feb 5, 2012

Per the article:
"the 9th Circuit judges concluded ........ 'for the reasons we explained above, that the integrity of the judicial process is a compelling interest.... .... In short, the recording cannot be released without undermining the integrity of the judicial system.”

The 9th Circuit judges admit that they have something to hide! Their integrity is as stake here. Seem to me the judicial process would be embarrassed and scandalized if the truth came out.

1:32AM PST on Feb 5, 2012

Wish Vaughn had not made that promise to keep the tapes confidential!

11:22PM PST on Feb 4, 2012

Agree with Sandi C. and Hannah L.

10:54PM PST on Feb 4, 2012

Transparency my ass!
I may have been born in CA., but i'm so thankful i have been here in wonderful WA. for the past 35+ years

9:50AM PST on Feb 4, 2012

What are they hiding?

9:34AM PST on Feb 4, 2012


7:54PM PST on Feb 3, 2012

What has happened to California? It's as backward as Texas!

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

it is good to see some much much needed reforms in jail system

Caitlin - it's been going on for a long time. about 20 years ago, i was temping for an investigation…

Allegations are very concerning and, if after investigation are found to be true, are not consistent…

meet our writers

Steve Williams Steve Williams is a passionate supporter of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Trans (LGBT) rights, human... more
ads keep care2 free

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.