START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
5,735,746 people care about Animal Welfare

Constitutional Right to Farm? Or Legal Right to Torture Animals?

Constitutional Right to Farm? Or Legal Right to Torture Animals?

Farmers in North Dakota are seeking to add an amendment to the state’s constitution that would guarantee the legal right to farm and ranch.

The North Dakota Farm Bureau hopes to bring the ballot measure before voters next year. The amendment would read:

“The right of farmers and ranchers to engage in modern farming and ranching practices shall be forever guaranteed in this state. No law shall be enacted which abridges the right of farmers and ranchers to employ agricultural technology, modern livestock production and ranching practices.”

The measure is largely a reaction to recent efforts by the Humane Society of the United States to bring animal welfare measures to ballots in states like Ohio. Farmers in North Dakota hope to cover their bases with a constitutional amendment in case HSUS shows up and attempts to curtail their business practices.

“Business practices,” “modern livestock production,” these are phrases that sound professional and harmless but anyone who has seen pictures or footage of CAFOs know that “agricultural technology” and “ranching practices” include dehorning, debeaking, castration, boiling animals alive, tearing newborn calves from their mothers and branding cows on their faces.

These euphemisms obscure the truth about what animal agriculture actually is: unmitigated cruelty, misery and death. The text of the amendment could more accurately read:

“The right of farmers and ranchers to slit the throats of animals so they choke on their own blood. No law shall be enacted which abridges the right of farmers and ranchers to employ ‘rape racks’ to forcibly impregnate cows, tear their babies away shortly after birth, kill the baby for veal and milk the mother to death for dairy products.”

Let it be known that I am not siding with HSUS. I do not agree with their sentiment that animal use is inevitable and the only thing we can do is to try to give animals larger cages. I advocate nothing short of veganism. No animal use, however “humane,” can be justified morally.

While I disagree with the HSUS’s tactics, it’s disgusting to see ranchers and farmers who react to growing public concern about animal rights by digging in their heels and trying to legally enshrine their cruel practices in a state constitution.

These farmers know that the tide is turning against them and they’re panicking and doing everything they can to keep their cruel industry going as long as they can. But the animal rights issue will be solved by education and boycott, not through welfare legislation.

Its passage could be seen as a setback for the movement, but a constitutional amendment can’t stop a grassroots movement to educate people about animal rights. A constitutional amendment can’t stop a person from going vegan. A constitutional amendment can’t stop a movement.

If you want to see the end of the “modern livestock production” and “business practices” of animal agriculture you have the power to save animal lives without a ballot referendum simply by going vegan.


Related Stories:

Videotape a Farm In Iowa, Go to Jail

Why Iím Still Vegan

Hunting, A Constitutional Right?


Read more: , , , , , , ,

Photo credit: Keith Evans

quick poll

vote now!

Loading poll...

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it


+ add your own
10:18AM PST on Jan 9, 2012


11:39PM PST on Dec 31, 2011

Being vegan does not prevent tractors from chopping up critters. Try local, better yet, start a garden, join a community garden, grow food somehow

8:51AM PST on Dec 25, 2011


9:08AM PST on Dec 8, 2011

interesting article, thanks for sharing :)

11:40AM PST on Dec 4, 2011

NO ONE has the right to abuse an animal. I've became vegan so that I am not responsible for the cruelty to animals. I'm happy to see more and more younger educated people join the cause. I would fight any law like this and hope people with compassion will do the same in ND. Sounds like the politicians in ND are being bought off with money by the farmers.

9:53AM PST on Dec 4, 2011

Thanks for the article

4:36AM PST on Dec 4, 2011

No! Animals should have the right NOT to be farmed!

1:12PM PST on Dec 3, 2011


That looks like a useful link for anyone interested in Humane

10:47AM PST on Dec 3, 2011

Jane B.: You keep flaming, even when people are trying to help you. It's pretty clear that you have no interest in helping to improve the lives of animals who are bred and born to be tortured from the time they enter this life, but I am trying to show that I'm willing to work with you.

If you're ever ready to do your own homework, you can find the addresses and contact information for humane farms, and for markets and restaurants that sell Certified Humane foods at this link:

Here is a link to their page with a list of the products that have been certified Humane, and it includes a list of products that are no longer certified:

10:34AM PST on Dec 3, 2011


add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

Petition signed. Must be time for folks who live near SeaWorld to hand out flyers to people before they…

Chafee has the sort of principle lacking among so many of our politicians. He does what he sees as right,…

Robert V. So a cheetah killing a gazelle is a murderer?

meet our writers

Joanna Parkman Joanna Parkman is the Causes editorial intern for Care2. After a stint in Central America, she has... more
ads keep care2 free

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.

site feedback


Problem on this page? Briefly let us know what isn't working for you and we'll try to make it right!