START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
1,075,813 people care about Education

Does Football Make an American High School Great?

Does Football Make an American High School Great?

Should the presence of a football team be a criterion for considering a school outstanding?

The Washington Post has been ranking U.S. high schools for 16 years. They just released their 2014 list, but for the first time included whether each school has an 11-person football team. Jay Mathews, who creates the list, justifies his decision by writing that research indicates that high school sports, including football, give students valuable time-management and leadership skills.

Mathews explains how the Challenge works:

We take the total number of Advanced Placement, International Baccalaureate and Advanced International Certificate of Education tests given at a school each year and divide by the number of seniors who graduated in May or June. I call this formula the Challenge Index. With a few exceptions, public schools that achieved a ratio of at least 1.00, meaning they had as many tests in 2013 as they had graduates, were put on the national list at We rank the schools in order of ratio.

But this year Matthews has added something different:

I added a question to The Post’s annual survey: “Do you have an 11-person football team?” To my astonishment, 67 of the top 100 schools, ranked by participation in college-level tests, said they do not field a team, denoting a shift in American high school culture, at least in those schools that challenge their students most.

He goes on to question whether the top academic schools in the U.S., who have abandoned the football culture, should stand as a model for all high schools nationwide. But apparently he disagrees, stating that football provides excellent training in leadership and time-management.

Mathews should take a look at the impact of football on the culture and life of American high schools.

As a high school teacher in the U.S. for over 20 years, I have seen over and over again how high school football rules the school especially, but not exclusively, during football season. The big bucks are raked in because of football. The football players are placed on pedestals, regardless of what kind of students they are. Football becomes the god to whom we all bow during football season. Education takes second place.

In spite of Title 9, football has traditionally grabbed a much bigger share of the sports budget than any other sport, and especially female sports.

There are numerous ways in which students can learn leadership, and work as a team: the multitude of clubs that exist on every high school campus, leadership classes, the community service requirements for high schoolers, and wonderful programs like Sojourn to the Past. Football is one of many options, not THE option.

If Mathews had actually spent extended time in five or six American high schools, as I have, he would understand that football can serve more as a pernicious influence than a benefit.

Indeed, why football? Why not softball, or volleyball, or soccer? Moving beyond sports, how about rating schools for their performing arts curriculum, or their music program? There’s plenty of team-building going on in these arenas.

I’d like to suggest the European model here. I grew up in the UK, where school sports were a necessary evil, but none of us really embraced them as anything noteworthy. By contrast, my town and my local community had numerous sports teams that were extremely competitive. That’s where sports really took off, and I believe that’s where they belong.

American high schools have, in my experience, become places where the football team is god, and I believe that is wrong. Jay Matthews, please take the football team question off your “Challenging High Schools” index.

Read more: , , , , , ,

Photo Credit: thinkstock

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it


+ add your own
11:54AM PDT on Apr 19, 2014

Sadly, football as we know it, is an American mindset and does not now nor will it ever an indicated of a "good school". It is the teachers, the students and their eduction and what they do with it that truly makes a good school.

Recently, a "local" HS spent $62,000,000 (that's sixty-two million dollars folks) on a "new" football stadium. What a horrible, horrible waste of "taxpayers" money. But as I said earlier, football is an American mindset and even more so in Texas.

How many BETTER WAYS can you can you think of to spend the money? Don and I CAN! :-))

9:50AM PDT on Apr 15, 2014

Football is an addiction in many schools in the South and Midwest. Guess they don't have much else to do in those small towns on the Texas plains. The over-emphasis on team sports in this country is ubiquitous. We are not alone. Just think of the football (soccer) insanity of other civilized countries. The crowd frenzy has occupied us from the time of the Roman games. At least the Greeks waited for every four years.

9:32AM PDT on Apr 14, 2014

Football does not add a single thing to a high school except for the hope of trophies to put in the concourse. It is the stupidest waste of education money I have ever seen. They hide the money that they are taking away from English and Science and funneling straight to the Coach's salary. I am proud that in high school I stood up to the coach who taught Algebra and didn't do a very good job at it.

6:12PM PDT on Apr 12, 2014

No. This obsession with sports and athletes needs to stop

4:44PM PDT on Apr 12, 2014

Football doesn't impress me in the slightest.

10:39AM PDT on Apr 12, 2014


12:19AM PDT on Apr 12, 2014

All the above statements are spot on. But the elephant in the room is the cost of maintaining the football field, the locker room, uniforms, insurance and the most costly of all is the coach's salary. They are paid more then a regular teacher. Add to this the injuries to these young boys that could be fatal.

12:19AM PDT on Apr 12, 2014

All the above statements are spot on. But the elephant in the room is the cost of maintaining the football field, the locker room, uniforms, insurance and the most costly of all is the coach's salary. They are paid more then a regular teacher. Add to this the injuries to these young boys that could be fatal.

10:45PM PDT on Apr 11, 2014

No, it makes it stupid.

8:45PM PDT on Apr 11, 2014

Why is it that a multi-billion dollar industry such as football can't be expected to find and train its players instead of expecting the public school system to use taxes for this? Some of these high schools spend more money on those 11 football oafs than on the rest of the entire school. Why?

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

Thanks Chris for the informative article. Petition signed yesterday: "John, you took action on September…

If there is no oil involved the USA does not seem to care, hmmm...

ads keep care2 free

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.

site feedback


Problem on this page? Briefly let us know what isn't working for you and we'll try to make it right!