START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
1,406,425 people care about Civil Rights

Former NSA Director Michael Hayden Apologizes for Not Keeping Spying Secret

Former NSA Director Michael Hayden Apologizes for Not Keeping Spying Secret

General Michael Hayden might look like a friendly older balding man, but look a little deeper. This 69-year-old had an illustrious career that included terms at both the CIA and NSA, with a stint during a particularly critical period of the NSA’s history: when the organization was perfecting and expanding its warrentless wiretapping program. In an interview with German publication Der Spiegel, he spoke out about the program, the future of intelligence and tensions between the United States and Germany caused by revelations of spying on German officials. What he had to say was an eye-opening glimpse into a world civilians rarely see.

As a former government official, General Hayden is in an interesting position to speak overall about the U.S. intelligence community, though he’s heavily limited in terms of what he can discuss due to confidentiality and security concerns. Between the lines, though, his defensiveness of the spying program comes through loud and clear, as does his affirmation that the United States has a clear right to spy not just on citizens, but foreign leaders and officers; “Look, we spy,” he told Der Spiegel. “We’re really good at it.”

He claims that the problem with the scandal lies not in the spying, but in the fact that it was revealed, suggesting that Snowden’s whistleblowing may have an undermining effect on the Internet: “There are countries that do not want the Internet as we know it. Russia, China, Iran, Saudi Arabia. The Snowden revelations will now allow them to argue that we Americans want to keep a single, unitary Internet, because it just helps us spy.”

However, he’s not being entirely honest when he discusses this, as he goes on to note that the NSA, like other intelligence agencies and branches of the military, aims for “domination” in all realms, including cyberspace. This is a long-held treatise of American doctrine, playing a key role in how we establish ourselves both domestically and internationally — the goal is to maintain total control over land, sea, air and other spaces, including virtual ones, allowing us to use them as we please and creating an environment where we can deny access and use to our enemies. The spying scandal fed into a larger iteration of the domination doctrine, explaining why some nations and their leaders might have room for pause.

General Hayden also acknowledged that the United States might have fouled up when it came to spying on European officials, especially in Germany, where privacy is valued very highly. While the United States may value a privacy culture (though General Hayden does not, as demonstrated in an exchange in 2006 when he indicated he didn’t think the Fourth Amendment didn’t protect people from spying), the German community takes it extremely seriously. Consequently, the spying scandal created a significant breach between the United States and Germany.

In a rare admission of wrongdoing, he suggested that the United States needs to work hard to repair its relations with Germany, and should focus on creating a more functional agreement between the two countries. While he didn’t directly call for an apology to the German government, he did indicate that he personally felt ashamed about the spying — but it was a tempered apology: “I am prepared to apologize for the fact we couldn’t keep whatever it was we may or may not have been doing secret and therefore put a good friend in a very difficult position. Shame on us. That’s our fault.”

This comment was a reminder that General Hayden seemed more concerned about being caught out at spying than the actual ramifications of the spying itself. As the man who oversaw much of the implementation of the spying program, he clearly felt an obligation to defend it, but his open defense raises interesting questions about what is going on inside the walls of the NSA right now, where new officials are making critical decisions about safety, security and surveillance.

Read more: , ,

Photo credit: Gerald R. Ford School of Public Policy.

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

43 comments

+ add your own
10:18AM PDT on Jun 22, 2014

Sometimes secrets are necessary.

1:28AM PDT on Apr 16, 2014

I do want to know whose spying on me. I have that right and the US governments spying on it's own citizens is WRONG. I think Snowden should be given a metal for telling us what our government was doing illegally. I suppose using his logic that if you're raped while you're sleeping you're better off not being told. The government is violating not just the rules of our Constitution/Bill of Rights but the spirit. Shame on them all.

8:43PM PDT on Apr 11, 2014

Ignorance can be bliss, and in this case we would be much better off not knowing about all this spying. Every country spies, maybe not on this scale, but they are doing it.

5:04PM PDT on Apr 6, 2014

yes Chris, every country does, the US is the only country in the world that spies on every single person in the world on this massive of a scale, it's a big deal. They shouldn't be allowed to do this crap

6:06PM PDT on Apr 5, 2014

Snowden is a patriot and hero - - this guy??

7:33PM PDT on Apr 4, 2014

evil. just plain evil

6:50PM PDT on Apr 4, 2014

IN 1973 I WENT TO WORK FOR THE FEDERAL GOVT. MY MILITARY SUPERVISOR SAID THE OFFICE OF THE FED GOVT WERE COVERTLY SURVEILLED...I STATED I DO NOT CARE AS I DO NOT DO ANYTHING WRONG. ANYWAY, APPARENTLY LOTS OF FEDS DID THINGS WRONG WHEN I DID NOT AND THEY GOT LOTSA LOTSA MORE MONEY THAN I DID...MY MY MY......IN MY LAST GOVT JOB I WAS BLAMED BY LYING PIG WOMEN FOR THINGS I NEVER KNEW ABOUT....YOUR GOVT AND NOT MYSELF HAS GONE TO KILLER HELL. ALSO, JUST SO ALL OF YOU ALL KNOW IF YOU HAVE A DISABILITY CASE AND YOU ARE NOT A POLITICAL AND INTEL AND NEWS MEDIA ASS KISSER YOUR CASE WILL TAKE A VERY LONG TIME...IF EVER...TO BE PROCESSED......

5:04PM PDT on Apr 4, 2014

I suggest everyone copy their electric bills and send them to the NSA. Call their office with every phone call and conference them in. Cc: them on every email.

It will save tax dollars and we'll end up in the same place.

Our world ended with decades ago. We're just late in finding out.

I wonder if Al Gore still wants to take credit for the Internet?

2:55PM PDT on Apr 4, 2014

Big brother is watching you and upset that you found out! Big corporations are watching you and don't care if you know.

12:28PM PDT on Apr 4, 2014

Surprise, surprise! Big Brother's another old white guy.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

Erika S... They do have a right to live where they want, as long as they obey the laws and enter the…

A hopefully good step forward. I've found that most physicians are not all that interested in mental…

ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.