Is a Library Without Books Still a Library?

California’s San Francisco State University is opening a newly-renovated library that will house only a quarter of the million or so books of its collection. Only books in “high-demand,” recently published titles and books recommended by the university’s departments will actually be on shelves in the library; the rest will be housed in five three-story high units. They can be retrieved in five to ten minutes via a robotic arm that is activated by an electronic prompt.

Deborah Masters, the university librarian, described the old library as a “rabbits’ warren” in the New York Times; the new structure has been updated to include open space as well as multimedia stations, group study areas and a café. Such renovations indeed recognize that libraries, or at least those on college and university campuses, are seen and used as places for students and others to gather and socialize. With more resources such as scholarly articles from academic journals and even books now available on the internet — and with a student population more used to accessing information via computers rather than by paging through books and hefty tomes of bound journals — devoting more of the physical space to multimedia resources makes sense. The library of my own college became so strapped for space that, a few years ago, it launched a project to weed out its holdings, removing duplicate books and bound copies of academic journals that had gone unused for years.

The jury is out about what could be and is lost when a library no longer offers its patrons aisles of books to wander through. Faculty from San Francisco State University’s Creative Writing Department are mourning the loss of shelves. “There’s a trend now where books are being stored in big vats and they aren’t available for us to touch and see,” says novelist Peter Orner. He adds that “I wouldn’t be a writer if, when I was an undergraduate at the University of Michigan, I didn’t wander the open stacks.”

The New York Times notes that more than a dozen universities, including five in California, have installed similar mechanized systems.

I truly love books. It really is not the same to curl up in a chair or the couch and activate the iPad, or balance your laptop on your knees. Books don’t need recharging and “navigating” from page to page remains cumbersome. On the other hand, I just as truly appreciate being able to view a library’s catalogue from my home computer and to access books and articles in electronic form a few minutes after I think I’d like to read them. On a very personal note, because the demands of caring for our teenage autistic son mean that I have to be home a great deal and simply do not have the time to stroll around library stacks, being able to access so much from my computer has meant that I can actually continue with my own research.

The very word “library” comes from the Latin word for book, liber. Certainly what constitutes a “book” is changing as more people use Kindles, iPads, their phones and computers to read “books.” Could libraries one day have no books at all or a scant few of the paper and page sort? Or are issues of access and convenience more important?


Related Care2 Coverage

World Book Night Seeks Volunteers

Library Sued For Blocking Native American & Wiccan Websites

E-book Borrowing: Publishers and Libraries Disagree

Photo by Librarygroover

Love This? Never Miss Another Story.


Connie T.
con t.2 years ago

a techno library? - not in this household.

Lynn D.
Lynn D.2 years ago

My house will always have books both physcial and that's because my Kindle is ALWAYS full and as I keep buying more books, waiting for my cloud version to fill up also but, I bought a houseful of books and am NOT getting rid of them until they're all read! And "YES" a library will still be a library (probably more of techno library) if it only has computerized type books!

Kathy Perez
Kathy Johnson3 years ago

I will never allow books (REAL books) to disappear in MY family

Nikki B.
Nikki B.3 years ago

I love my kobo, it's great for reading novels at work because I don't have to worry about tattering another book in my bag and it cuts down on the amount of paper used to print the books. However not all books are available in electronic form, the libraries need to keep track of this and keep those books on the shelves otherwise we loose some great books.

vicky t.
vicky T.3 years ago

The day real books disappear will be the last day of my life

Debbie Crowe
Debbie Crowe3 years ago

I like walking the aisles looking at the book titles. If I find one that looks interesting, at least I can pull it out and read a bit to see if I want to take it home!! If it wasn't on the shelf, I would not know about it and that could be my loss!!

I tried using a Kindle, and I would much rather hold a REAL book in my hands any day!!!

iii q.
g d c.3 years ago

public libraries seem to be cutting back, and discarding (!!!) books...
there seem to be a lot less choices already...

iii q.
g d c.3 years ago

we like to touch, see and wander the stacks... sometimes one "discovers" new and interesting books...

Teresa Wlosowicz
Teresa W.3 years ago

I'd say no.

Teresa Wlosowicz
Teresa W.3 years ago

difficult question