Is It Ethical to Buy Vintage Fur?

Fur coats are not only completely unnecessary in modern fashion, but they’re also a product of animal cruelty and suffering. Encouragingly, major labels like Gucci have begun to accept this reality, and world governments are moving toward tightened restrictions on fur as fashion.

That said, though, where do we draw the line on vintage fur clothing?

What makes reused furs problematic?

On the face of it, purchasing secondhand furs from vintage stores may not seem as ethically troubling as buying new coats.

After all, no additional animals have had to undergo the squalid conditions of factory fur farms, nor have they endured agonizing deaths from  decompression chambers, electrocution or poisoning — sometimes via unfiltered exhaust fumes — to name just a few killing methods that, incidentally, are prohibited when slaughtering animals domestically for meat.

There may, in fact, be some moral reason to support wearing a vintage fur coat as much as possible, too. After all, animals already killed should not have died for a fleeting fashion trend. In terms of resource conservation and avoiding a throw-away culture, an argument certainly exists for keeping an inherited or second-hand fur.

Indeed, among the thrifty and craft-inclined, there’s been substantial interest recently in buying old furs from charity shops and estate sales and putting them back into use with repairs or re-purposing. And many feel that this enables people to enjoy a warm winter coat without harming any new animals or costing the environment.

Critics of these motivations should remember to check their privilege. For some people, a hand-me-down coat that sports either fur trim, fur lining or the like may be their only protection against the cold this winter season. I think it’s important to distinguish between necessity and choice — and make an allowance for that possibility.

But, certainly, fur brings to mind luxurious — and unnecessary — stoles, coats and hats worn by individuals who could very well afford to buy fur-free alternatives.

Fur feeds the industry, new or old

When I became a vegan, I had to make a number of decisions relating to where I drew moral boundaries on animal products. For example, I had to ask myself, if I won’t buy new leather products, will I still purchase vintage leather boots, briefcases, belts and the like? Are more ethical than new leather?

At first, I believed that this distinction justified wearing old leather products. I reasoned that I was not contributing to animal deaths, and that my money was not feeding into the system of animal oppression and abuse that I find abhorrent.

But this tricky moral question kept nagging at me. While I never actually purchased any vintage leather goods, I inherited a leather laptop case from my brother — and every time I used it, I felt uneasy. And one day it hit me: Other people didn’t know the case was secondhand leather.

They didn’t know that I hadn’t purchased the item and that I hadn’t fed into the system I was trying to rally against. They didn’t know I was vegan, and, therefore, might assume I supported leather.

After this simple revelation, I never used the leather bag again.

This little anecdote informs my thinking on vintage fur, too. Nearly everyone I know agrees without hesitation that the fur industry is barbaric and entirely unnecessary in a modern fashion context. They do not support fur farms, and they’d never want to be associated with animal cruelty.

As such, I believe that any and all fur coats or fur products — like boot lining — promotes a tolerance for a deeply disturbing industry. Whether these items are new or secondhand, they normalize wearing fur. A passerby doesn’t know why you chose vintage over new, and they may not know the animal suffering that is involved in making a fur coat.

Of course, if we’re applying this rule fairly, it’s important to consider some of the drawbacks of fur alternative: Are cheap, faux fur products imported from Asia really any better?

These are difficult questions, and I don’t think it’s helpful to condemn people for their choice to buy vintage fur. The emphasis must be on educating others to make informed choices – hopefully ones that don’t support a troubling fur industry.

It’s a tricky line to draw, but I think it comes down to one’s personal moral code on this issue. That said, a common thread exists at the heart of the matter: The fur industry must end, and we should focus on ensuring that fur fashion is a dying brand.

Photo Credit: Michael/Flickr

127 comments

JACQUI GLYDE
JACQUI GLYDE14 days ago

NO NO NO

SEND
Emma Z
Emma Z15 days ago

No.

SEND
katherine p
katherine p19 days ago

I have been dealing with this idea for yrs... even before i became vegan...i have never worn furs but do have some inherited...and couldnt just get rid of them... i toyed with the idea of giving them a burial... but i have kept them and send them the love they never had.... if that makes sense... i actually go to the ivory and protected species theory (cant even have ones you find, or buy used) which complicates matters more... should EVERYTHING be eradicated? might solve the problem, out of sight out of mind and therefore not desired...???? its a heavy issue that i lose sleep over for real!

SEND
Helga Blackthorne

I completely agree with what Margaret S said ! I wanted to write the Same !
Fur is Fur - No matter how old it is ! Everything else is Hypocrisy !

SEND
Margaret S
Margaret Scott20 days ago

Wearing fur of any age is wrong, Don’t excuse its use by saying it’s vintage, that animal still suffered untold agony. Fur is intended for the creatures who were born with it. Stop The Killing Now.

SEND
Janet Hotubbee
Janet Hotubbee21 days ago

I do not wear fur, so the choice to not wear vintage fur is easy for me. I think every person needs to search their own hearts before they purchase fur. There are so many faux materials that look just like fur these days why would anyone want animals killed to wear what they think is a "status" symbol of wealth?

SEND
Teresa F
Teresa F21 days ago

thank you for sharing, NO TO FUR,

SEND
Jeramie D
Jeramie D21 days ago

Wearing any fur is condoning murder

SEND
Monica Collier
Monica Collier21 days ago

No matter what I buy, vintage or new, is my choice and for my own reasons. I don't make a purchase with what others think in mind.

SEND
Susan H
Susan H21 days ago

NO to any fur.

SEND