START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
3,441,413 people care about Animal Welfare

Kosher Animal Slaughter Still Banned in Poland

Kosher Animal Slaughter Still Banned in Poland

Last December the Polish Constitutional Court banned ritual slaughter after finding it violated the country’s animal protection laws, but it was unclear at the time whether the ban would be upheld.

The controversy over religious slaughter has been brewing in Poland since 1997 when the country required slaughter to “follow the loss of consciousness” after stunning under its Animal Protection Act — a step that is forbidden by kosher and halal rules.

Jewish shechita and Muslim dhabiha slaughter methods that produce kosher and halal meats require animals to be conscious during slaughter, which involves having their throats slit before they are bled out. Most countries require stunning prior to slaughter, which is believed to be more humane. However, in other countries, including the U.S., religious slaughter may be exempt from animal welfare laws.

Animal rights groups filed a petition over an exemption that allowed religious slaughter that was enacted in 2004 following objections to the ban from religious groups. Last year, the court decided that the exemption was unconstitutional and that slaughtering animals without stunning them first violated the 1997 Animal Protection Act.

Last week, the government rejected a bill that would have overturned the ban on religious slaughter.

The reactions to the ban being upheld have been mixed with some arguing religious intolerance. However, according to the Economist, no anti-Semitic or anti-Muslim arguments were used to debate the ban, only arguments for animal welfare and the country’s interest in keeping exports flowing.

Polish Chief Rabbi Schudrich compared the ban to Nazi propaganda and threatened to resign, but the loudest opposition seems to be coming from those who stand to lose money over the ban. What was intended to allow for religious slaughter for a small sector turned into big business.

According to The Independent, by 2011, up to 30 percent of all Polish beef exports came from ritually slaughtered cattle – more than 150,000 animals – and brought in about one billion euros. Following the ban, producers were the ones who stirred more outrage than religious communities.

However, this week Poland’s Prime Minister Donald Tusk announced that he has no plans to reintroduce legislation to lift the ban, but added that the government would wait for a decision by a constitutional court on “whether the ban on kosher slaughter was harming the rights of religious minorities,” reports Reuters.

Still, the issue here isn’t about religious intolerance, it’s about animal suffering and the thousands of animals who remain fully aware of what is happening to them while they are being killed. While many exemptions exist for religious slaughter, most countries consider modern slaughter methods that involve a loss of consciousness prior to killing to be more humane and cause less stress to animals. Despite the protests over the ban, there are still some that sympathize with its goal.

Severyn Ashkenazy, the founder of the Progressive Jewish Community of Poland, stated that, “We Jews must behave honourably and lead in kindness toward animals… Now we live in the greatest scientific century, should we not rather trust a veterinary doctor than a mashgiach [supervisor of kosher observance]?”

 

Comparison of ritual slaughter methods vs. stunning (warning: graphic footage).

Read more: , , , ,

Photo credit: Thinkstock

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

110 comments

+ add your own
8:16PM PDT on Aug 18, 2013

I am Jewish, and I could not watch the entire video. Seeing a cow's head writhe and eyes stare in pain was too much. I'd always heard that kosher slaughter was humane. Reading this thread, it appears that might not be true. My wish would be for all who slaughter animals to get together to determine the most humane way, get that method into law, and then get it enforced.

12:48PM PDT on Aug 17, 2013

Well done, Poland! For the first time, I'm really proud of my country!

5:32AM PDT on Aug 9, 2013

thanks for sharing

9:22AM PDT on Aug 1, 2013

I don't think any God asks us to treat animals badly. My God is surely not mad at me if I eat meat that didn't suffer his last moments. Of course the best thing I did is that I am veg and don't have to worry about were my vegetables come from

8:55AM PDT on Aug 1, 2013

"Religion is for the weak-minded"
--A. Einstein

I rest my case.

3:26PM PDT on Jul 29, 2013

Ritual killing, is ritual killing. There should be NO exceptions to this. I totally oppose animals being killed in this inhumane manner. I don't give a cr@p for the religious zealots who insist they should have exceptions. No F$cking exceptions @$$hats - you are all cruel, murdering bastards.

1:18AM PDT on Jul 29, 2013

Noted.

4:47AM PDT on Jul 24, 2013

Actually, Australian halal slaughterhouses stun animals prior to slaughter!! That's due to differing interpretations of the Quran, but it proves that stunning is possible...

Of course, the best thing to do to help animals and the environment (and human health!) is to go vegan :)

6:51AM PDT on Jul 22, 2013

I think that people who don't live in Poland don't know what is going on. Our law ban only ritual slaughtering in factories, and not ban private slaughter inside religious groups.
In my opinion any kind of such treating animals is simply cruel and feeling-less. They should be left of conscious before death!

9:32AM PDT on Jul 21, 2013

I butcher my own chickens and I don't stun them first because a stunner is about $1,500. I understand people's sensibilities about watching an animal struggle for life while it is bleeding out, but I must pose a question that I have posed on this site before: How do we place value on a life? Insects are animals with central nervous systems, should we not be allowed to make termites suffer with chemicals to protect our homes? Should we criminalize the burning or beheading of a tick? Roaches? Ants? Mosquitoes? Cockroaches? I am an animal welfare advocate and believe that domestic animals should be properly cared for and lead a good life even if they will eventually be slaughtered. My concern is that someone, somewhere will sue a state because it's animal cruelty laws are biased toward domestic mammals and birds and that insects and other animals commonly considered to be pests are not receiving equal treatment under the law. When that day comes, I fear that all animal welfare laws my be undermined.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

meet our writers

Beth Buczynski Beth is a freelance writer and editor living in the Rocky Mountain West. So far, Beth has lived in... more
Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free

more from causes




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.