START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
1,366,563 people care about Politics

What Lies Ahead For Egypt After Mubarak?

What Lies Ahead For Egypt After Mubarak?

In the wake of now-former President Hosni Mubarak’s resignation after thirty years in power—and the jubilation in Tahrir Square marking the end of an era—what lies ahead for the biggest, most powerful Arab country?

Implications of Mubarak’s Resignation on Egypt and the Middle East

In the BBC, Robert Hardy, a public policy scholar at the Woodrow Wilson Center in Washington, D.C., reviews the implications of Mubarak’s resignation and departure from Cairo for Egypt and for regional politics:

 

First, President Mubarak’s resignation and his departure from Cairo do not mean that the Egyptian crisis is moving towards an early resolution.

On the contrary, Mr Mubarak has simply dumped his dilemmas into the lap of the military top brass.

Whether they can do a better job of dealing with them than he did – and whether the military can even retain its own cohesion – are far from certain.

……

Second, the success of ‘people power’ in Egypt is far more significant for Arabs everywhere than its success in Tunisia.

……..

The Egyptian example has already electrified public opinion throughout a region where a similar set of ills – autocracy, corruption, unemployment, the dignity deficit – prevail.

Autocrats whose security services are smaller and weaker than Egypt’s are more vulnerable to the chill wind of popular anger.

Those with the money to buy off dissent are already trying to do so. Poorer states, such as Jordan and Yemen, will have to borrow in order to do so.

Hardy also notes the effects of the uprising on regional economics—it has already had an effect on oil prices and, of course, tourism to Egypt—and its impact on political issues in the Mideast including ’the Arab-Israeli peace process, the growing influence of Iran, the battle against Muslim extremism.’ According to Hardy, ‘fears of Islamic revolutions everywhere are misplaced,’ as ‘most of the current dissent seems driven by nationalist rather than religious sentiment.’

Mubarak is Gone, But Mubarak’s Egypt Remains

The Guardian points out that, with Mubarak gone, the army is now in charge and some of the complications that are more than likely to arise as a result:

Egyptian and foreign commentators are sharply aware of how difficult it will be for the military to accept a democratic transition that includes the legalisation of its bugbear, the banned Muslim Brotherhood, the most powerful opposition force in the country.

“This is just the end of the beginning,” said Jon Alterman of the Centre for Strategic and International Studies. “Egypt isn’t moving toward democracy, it’s moved into martial law and where it goes is now subject to debate.”

Analysts also see risks for the army in the new situation, exposed to demands for a civilian transitional government that could challenge or dilute its own authority or launch investigations into corruption or human rights abuses. The army may also want to avoid an armed clash with the Republican Guards that would seriously destabilise the country and further rob the regime of legitimacy.

Might it be possible that Egypt in the post-Mubarak era might not look so different after all? Writing in the Atlantic, Max Fisher says that Mubarak stepping down does not mean the automatic end of ‘Mubarak’s Egypt,’ which is ‘composed of countless bureaucracies, institutions, and officials’ and is ‘likely to remain for a generation or more.’ While Mubarak’s departure is a historic moment for Egypt and the Middle East, Fisher emphasizes that

…… it’s important to remember that government do not transform overnight. Mubarak may be on his way out, but regimes are not confined to one man. They are vast networks, formal and informal, of partisans and technocrats, torture specialists and traffic cops, rent-seekers and public servants, all of them difficult or impossible to separate. The work of transforming Egypt to a democracy, whether by top-down reform or blanket purges, will likely be a difficult and frustrating process that could take a generation or more. Revolutions are messy, and this one is far from over.

Mubarak’s successor, Fisher writes, will ‘face public pressure to purge the ministry of its thousands of security and intelligence officers.’ While many in the US are ‘understandably concerned about Egyptian extremists rising in the wake of Mubarak’s departure,’ Fisher points out that ‘it’s worth bearing in mind that no one has killed more Egyptian civilians this year than the internal security forces.’

Analysis of Obama’s Handling of the Uprising in Egypt

Hardy in the BBC is frankly critical of President Obama’s handling of the crisis in Egypt:

 

The Obama administration’s handling of the Egypt crisis has been inept. The European Union has scarcely fared much better.

But even if their response had been sure-footed, the underlying conundrum would have been the same.

The West has, for decades, made stability a higher priority than democracy and human rights.

For Western powers, says Hardy, one ‘painful lesson’ to learn is about ‘how little influence they have, even in countries to which they give generous aid.’

Writing in the Guardian, Michael Tomasky states that it was

President Obama’s remarks on Friday afternoon were appropriate and powerful: the people of Egypt have inspired the world. For all the understandable frustration on the part of Egyptian protesters over the fact the the US wouldn’t commit to them more fully earlier, I think Obama and his people ended up playing this rather well. They turned up the heat incrementally, and but for one or two missteps, the timing was actually pretty good.

Critics, neocons especially, will say he didn’t lead, he followed. That’s true. And that was appropriate. It was up to the Egyptian people to lead this, not the United States.

This was Egypt’s show, not the US’s. And there is now, as Tomasky writes, a  ’great opportunity for the US, and all of the west, to help a people learn the habits of freedom, and for those habits to spread.’

Now What For Mubarak?

As for what is next for Mubarak himself, the picture is not at all clear. Swiss banks have frozen his accounts, the Guardian reports. Mubarak has reportedly flown to the the Red Sea resort of Sharm el-Sheikh and so far insists that he will stay in his homeland: In his first speech on the first of February, Mubarak pledged that he would ‘”die on the soil of Egypt and be judged by history.”‘

But exploratory discussions involving the Saudis, the US and the UAE have reportedly taken place about him moving to Dubai. One important issue is immunity from any prosecution he might face on charges of crimes against humanity after 300 deaths and documented abuses by the security forces.

According to the London-based paper al-Quds al-Arabi, revelations about the Mubarak family fortune and possible legal action over that are also a factor in planning for a post-presidential future.

Experts have estimated that the Mubaraks could be worth £43.5bn, with much of the wealth from investment deals in British and Swiss banks or tied up in upmarket real estate in London, New York, Los Angeles and expensive tracts of the Red Sea coast.

A ‘peaceful retirement’ in Sharm el-Sheikh would, the Guardian notes, be an ‘unusual outcome for an Arab president in the post-second world war era.’ While a number of Lebanese presidents have retired after serving their terms in office, Arab leaders have either mostly ‘died in office been murdered.’

To see more about the developments in Egypt, click here.

Most Recent Care2 coverage on the Egyptian Protests:

Mubarak Surrenders on the Anniversary of the Iran Revolution and the Release of Nelson Mandela

CAIRO: Amir Eid Music Video from Tahrir Square

12 Videos of Poetry, Performance, Music and Dance from Cairo’s Tahrir Square

Could Mubarak Step Down Today?

A Wedding in Cairo’s Club Tahrir (VIDEO)

Revolution’s Softer Side: Tahrir Square Is a Stage for New Poetry and Performance

VP Suleiman Warns “We Can’t Put Up With Continued Protests,” Wael Ghonim Emerges As Voice Of Revolution

Read more: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Photo by the author of a rally celebrating the departure of Mubarak in Journal Square, Jersey City, New Jersey.

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

47 comments

+ add your own
6:26AM PST on Feb 14, 2011

Yes, Mubarak did step down and the army took over (a military coup?). Do you see a civilian leader who you can point too like Martin Luther King or Gandhi (Pres. Obama's comparison)? Even a grass roots uprising has a leader, so where is he? Facebook and Twitter are the faceless leaders? So who is behind sending these messages? The army? the Moslem Brotherhood? Iran? Mubarak? Suleiman? The are a lot of questions to be answered before I see it as "remarkable" from my viewpoint. Beware, Iran is slowly moving up the east coast of Africa along the Red Sea toward Sinai and Egypt and the West is jubilant over an unknown revolution of a few hundred thousand people out of a population of 90 million. Yes, Mubarak seems to be out, the question is who is behind it and who will replace him? Let's hope for the best.

3:56PM PST on Feb 13, 2011

Mubarak came from the military, and had appointed Omar Suleiman ( head of the country's feared security agency) as Vice-President .
Now the military are in control.
Where to from here ? Democracy or the military?
And could a government survive without the backing of the military?
The future lies with the young people who brought Egypt to this point, but I fear there is much yet to be done.

1:56PM PST on Feb 13, 2011

CONGRATULATIONS, EGYPTIANS.

1:50PM PST on Feb 13, 2011

AFRICAN UNION. WHERE WERE YOU DURING THE EGYPTIAN REVOLUTION? WHAT ROLE DID YOU PLAY?

6:30AM PST on Feb 13, 2011

Whatever government comes out of this, I hope that they will listen to the people more than any other Egyptian government has in the past. They should also keep in mind the risk of having thousands of suddenly unemployed secret service officers looking for a job... organized crime and terrorist groups may be the highest bidder.

5:36AM PST on Feb 13, 2011

Thanks for the info.

10:13PM PST on Feb 12, 2011

Best wishes to a better future for the Egyptian people.

8:50PM PST on Feb 12, 2011

Since when has any country had a peaceful democracy under military rule? Muburak may have gone, but I'm not sure the future is as rosy as the people think. I hope I am wrong.

4:14PM PST on Feb 12, 2011

One could not help but rejoice with the People of Egypt. WHat a wonderful day for the Older Citizens, the ones growing into thier own, and above all, the little ones. I pray that the young ones will hang on to these memories, and treasure every story their elders tell them. My heartfelt wishes for continued success in taking their beloved country back. They deserve the best.

3:45PM PST on Feb 12, 2011

There is one small footage that stands out to me in the 17 days that this went on. It was a group of Egyptian Muslims in prayer, being surrounded arm in arm by Egyptian Christians. There was something so poignant to me seeing that.
Now, if that same act of brotherhood could continue Egypt will have a chance. I wish them all Peace.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches and writes about ancient Greek and Latin and is Online Advocacy and Marketing... more
Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free

more from causes

Animal Welfare

Causes Canada

Causes UK

Children

Civil Rights

Education

Endangered Wildlife

Environment & Wildlife

Global Development

Global Warming

Health Policy

Human Rights

LGBT rights

Politics

Real Food

Trailblazers For Good

Women's Rights




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.