Rejecting the ALS Challenge: Pamela Anderson’s Animal Rights Argument

Pamela Anderson, model, actor and animal rights advocate, has broken with popular culture and rejected the ALS ice bucket challenge. Her reason: she believes that animal testing to find cures for diseases like ALS is wrong.

Published on Facebook on Wednesday, August 20, the post shows a photo of Pamela Anderson holding a sign that says “Stop Animal Testing” with a lengthy explanation of Anderson’s reasoning as to why she, as an animal rights supporter, feels that she cannot support the ALS ice bucket challenge:

Anderson is a long-time supporter of PETA and has been particularly outspoken against the fur industry.

Of course, the media has run with this story because Anderson is one of only a handful of celebrities to have turned down the challenge, and the only major celebrity to raise concerns about medical testing on animals.

The commentary at large has been overwhelmingly negative. Many have made personal attacks against Anderson, citing her own plastic surgeries as evidence of her perceived hypocrisy, while others have trivialized her arguments as not worthy of a response. However, Anderson raises some important issues that at the very least deserve attention.

Specifically she draws attention to the fact that animal testing experiments can, indeed must, involve suffering — and many times procedures that, were they carried out on humans, would be classed as nothing less than torture. This is not to be emotive but simply a statement of fact.

There are also a number of studies that have shown that, while many countries have strict regulations on the use of animals,†welfare standards have been disregarded in animal testing (it may seem a cruel irony to have welfare standards, but they are there). In addition, a systematic review of animal testing has shown that publication bias and poor methodologies, as well as a media that is quick to highlight every new drug trial while it is in its infancy, might lead us to believe that animal testing is producing new and better drugs to treat everything from HIV to, yes, even ALS, at a far more consistent and successful rate than is the reality.

However, it would be incorrect to say that animal testing hasn’t given us a number of new, and even life saving treatments. Partly, the reason for this is because the system is set up so that every drug must first be tried on animals before it ever moves on to testing on humans — such is the framework for safely producing human treatments. As such, of course animal testing produces some viable treatments for humans precisely because we have devised a system that means this is often the only avenue by which new drugs can reach the market. It is not the only system, but other technologies still do not give the confidence level or range of testing methods that animal testing provides our medical authorities.

Nevertheless, it is true to say that drugs have arrived on the market after being tested on animals that, indeed, do save lives, from cancer drugs to MS and even ALS treatments that can slow the progression of the disease or at least help reduce its symptoms.

There are two very passionate sides to this argument, but the media has done Anderson a disservice by disregarding out of hand her opinions simply because of who she is.

If there is one criticism to be leveled at Pamela Anderson’s stance (truncated as it was for Facebook and so acknowledging that), it is that while making the case against animal testing, she has fallen prey to the temptation of framing the question incorrectly. The topic at hand is not whether animal testing works, because while its overall success rate is low it does produce results, but whether it is all right to subject other animals to suffering and life-ending tests, thereby reducing their agency to mere tools to be used at our discretion, in order to create treatments that will allow us (and, admittedly, other animals) a healthier, longer life. This is a dividing line in this argument and only after finding which side we are on is there cause to argue the more difficult rest.

But how has the ALS Association responded to Anderson’s concerns? To their credit, the ALS Association has responded with a robust but somewhat sensitive comment, telling The Daily Banter that if givers are concerned about animal testing, they can stipulate that their money should not be used for such research:

Significant advances have been made in ALS and other neurological disorders such as Alzheimerís Disease and Parkinsonís Disease using model systems such as rodents, flies and worms to better understand disease mechanisms and to develop therapies. With advances in technology made possible through research funding from The ALS Association, different approaches to minimize the use of these model systems are being developed. Similar to organizations globally, The ALS Association supports laboratories and scientists that strictly adhere to the guidelines provided by the National Institutes of Health. The Association is committed to honoring donor intent. If a donor is not comfortable with a specific type of research, he or she can stipulate that their dollars not be invested in that particular area.

This commitment, if transparent and properly adhered to (and that’s a big “if”), is one way that those opposed to animal testing can continue to support research into finding cures for diseases that blight the lives of humans and animals, while not contributing to animal suffering. Another is to do as Anderson has urged and support charities that have made an overt commitment to pursuing treatments and cures through means other than animal testing. Readers can find a helpful list of such charities here.

Photo credit: Thinkstock.

297 comments

Past Member
.6 months ago

All thanks to Dr Aba, I am here to share a life testimony of my self on how i came in contact with a real herbalist who helped me. i appreciate everyone for taken their precious time to read my testimony, 6 months ago i was diagnosed with ALS, this means that 6 months ago i was ALS positive when i told one of my good friend about this, she sympathized with me and then she said that she was going to help me out, she told me that we should do some research on the Internet, we came across Dr Aba and my friend said that she has come across a lot about him and said that he is a real herbalist remedy to all illness, i was really surprised on this and confused as well, I was so speechless and quickly i contact him to help me and he prepared some herbs for me and send it across to me and he told me the way i was going to be taken the medicine which i did, and in the next 2 weeks i went to the hospital and they said that i am now ALS negative, i am very happy about this, then i contacted Dr Aba again to tell him the good result , i asked him how he was able to help me, and he said that he was gifted with it that he can cure any disease. also reach him because health is better than wealth Email him via"dr.abaherbalhome@gmail.com you can call or whatsApp his number on +2348107155060 see more at drabaherbalhome.webs.com

John F.
.7 months ago

All thanks to Dr Aba, I am here to share a life testimony of my self on how i came in contact with a real herbalist who helped me. i appreciate everyone for taken their precious time to read my testimony, 6 months ago i was diagnosed with ALS, this means that 6 months ago i was ALS positive when i told one of my good friend about this, she sympathized with me and then she said that she was going to help me out, she told me that we should do some research on the Internet, we came across Dr Aba and my friend said that she has come across a lot about him and said that he is a real herbalist remedy to all illness, i was really surprised on this and confused as well, I was so speechless and quickly i contact him to help me and he prepared some herbs for me and send it across to me and he told me the way i was going to be taken the medicine which i did, and in the next 2 weeks i went to the hospital and they said that i am now ALS negative, i am very happy about this, then i contacted Dr Aba again to tell him the good result , i asked him how he was able to help me, and he said that he was gifted with it that he can cure any disease. also reach him because health is better than wealth Email him via"dr.abaherbalhome@gmail.com you can call or whatsApp his number on +2348107155060

John F.
.7 months ago

All thanks to Dr Aba, I am here to share a life testimony of my self on how i came in contact with a real herbalist who helped me. i appreciate everyone for taken their precious time to read my testimony, 6 months ago i was diagnosed with ALS, this means that 6 months ago i was ALS positive when i told one of my good friend about this, she sympathized with me and then she said that she was going to help me out, she told me that we should do some research on the Internet, we came across Dr Aba and my friend said that she has come across a lot about him and said that he is a real herbalist remedy to all illness, i was really surprised on this and confused as well, I was so speechless and quickly i contact him to help me and he prepared some herbs for me and send it across to me and he told me the way i was going to be taken the medicine which i did, and in the next 2 weeks i went to the hospital and they said that i am now ALS negative, i am very happy about this, then i contacted Dr Aba again to tell him the good result , i asked him how he was able to help me, and he said that he was gifted with it that he can cure any disease. also reach him because health is better than wealth Email him via"dr.abaherbalhome@gmail.com you can call or whatsApp his number on +2348107155060

Maria W.
Maria W.7 months ago

HOW I GOT CURED FROM ALS
I am Maria Whetzel, I was diagnosed of ALS (amyotrophic lateral sclerosis) in February 2014. I was on Ariluzole (Rilutek) to slow down the progress of the disease, I continued using the medication till a friend of mine told me about a herbal doctor from South Africa Dr Ejiro who prepares herbal medicine to cure all kind of diseases including ALS, i contacted Dr Ejiro via his email and bought the herbal medicine I received the herbal medicine through courier service within 7 days, when i received this herbal medicine i used it as prescribed and was totally cured of ALS within 3 weeks of usage, contact Dr Ejiro via his email ejiroherbalcure@gmail.com or call/whatsapp on +27617403481

Harry M.
Harry M.8 months ago

I am from U.S.A, I was diagnosed of ALS How i was cured of Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). I had been dealing with ALS for months and nothing happened. I was at my lowest and struggling with self-image issues due to Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. ALS can strike anyone at anytime, regardless of age, gender, or ethnic origin and younger and older people develop the disease. It was a terrible experience without no cure, one day I stumbled upon a friend of mine who introduce natural remedy to me about this Dr.ALAHO And i contacted him through his email and following the instruction, now am free from the disease. You can reach through his email address, dralahospelltemple@gmail.com of dralahospelltemple@hotmail.com or you can also contact him through his website http://dralahospelltemple.wix.com/dr-alaho...call +2349056803606.

Sliefert N.
Sliefert N.10 months ago

Hi Dr. Ogudo
Thank you for your wonderful article. The more that is written about people healing from ALS the more people diagnosed with ALS are given hope that they can survive and thrive. I know the Healing ALS film will help people heal and possibly prevent ALS.But now God use Dr.Ogudo To do herbal medicine to cure it for me.
My Name is Merlin I am from USA, I was diagnosed of ALS disease (Lou Gehrig’s disease) in 2012 and I have tried all I can to get cured but all to no avail, my life was gradually coming to an end, until i saw a post in a health forum about a herbal doctor from Africa who prepares herbal cure to cure all kind of diseases including ALS, MND, Epilepsy, Leukemia, Asthma, Cancer, Ghonorhea etc, at first i doubted if it was real but decided to give it a try, when i contact this herbal doctor via his email, he prepared an ALS herbal portion and sent it to me via courier service, when i received this herbal portion, he gave me step by step instructions on how to apply it, when i applied it as instructed, i was cured of this deadly disease within 7 days, I could not walk or talk understandably before but after i took the herbal cure as he instructed i regained strength in my bones and i could talk properly unlike before, I am now free from the deadly disease, all thanks to DR.OGUDO Contact this great herbal doctor via his email dr.ogudoherbalspelltemple@gmail.com
dr.ogudoherbalspelltemple@yahoo.com or call +2349031726182
You are

Jim Ven
Jim Venabout a year ago

thanks for the article.

Meshell Arnold
Meshell Arnoldabout a year ago

MY ALS HEALING TESTIMONY
My mouth is short of words, i am so so happy because DR.COLLINS has healed me from ALS ailment which i have been suffering for the past 6years now, i have spend a lot getting drugs from the hospital to keep me healthy, i have tried all means in life to always become ALS negative , but there was no answer until i found DR.COLLINS the prince of africa who provide me some healing herbal cure that he uses to help me, now i am glad telling everyone that i am now ALS Negative, i am very very happy, thank you DR.COLLINS for helping my life comes back newly without any form of crisis, may the good lord that i serve blessed you DR.COLLINS and equip you to the higher grade for healing my life. i am so amazed. so i will announced to everyone in this whole world that is ALS positive to please follow my advice and get healed on time, because we all knows that ALS disease is a deadly type,contact Dr.COLLINS for your ALS healing herbal cure today at: drcollinsherbalcure@hotmail.com He will be always happy to assist you online and ensure you get healed on time, today for your healing herbal cure immediately, thank you sir

Meshell Arnold
Meshell Arnoldabout a year ago

MY ALS HEALING TESTIMONY
My mouth is short of words, i am so so happy because DR.COLLINS has healed me from ALS ailment which i have been suffering for the past 6years now, i have spend a lot getting drugs from the hospital to keep me healthy, i have tried all means in life to always become ALS negative , but there was no answer until i found DR.COLLINS the prince of africa who provide me some healing herbal cure that he uses to help me, now i am glad telling everyone that i am now ALS Negative, i am very very happy, thank you DR.COLLINS for helping my life comes back newly without any form of crisis, may the good lord that i serve blessed you DR.COLLINS and equip you to the higher grade for healing my life. i am so amazed. so i will announced to everyone in this whole world that is ALS positive to please follow my advice and get healed on time, because we all knows that ALS disease is a deadly type,contact Dr.COLLINS for your ALS healing herbal cure today at: drcollinsherbalcure@hotmail.com He will be always happy to assist you online and ensure you get healed on time, today for your healing herbal cure immediately, thank you sir

Diana S.
Diana S2 years ago

Medical procedures and research should ONLY be tested on the species for which they are ultimately designed to help!!! And I agree that the US has more than enough subjects for that research in prisons, on death rows, and "leftovers" from Gitmo! And - there are plenty of volunteers already affected by the diseases (etc) being researched who would jump at the chance to get themselves cured by that research!!