START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
2,474,663 people care about Human Rights

S.F. Gay Couple Lose Immigration Battle

S.F. Gay Couple Lose Immigration Battle


U.S. born Bradford Wells and Australian born Anthony John Makk have been married for seven years after having wed in Massachusetts,  and have been together for 19 years, but the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services this week denied Makk’s application for permanent residency as a spouse of an American citizen because the federal Defense of Marriage Act bans the federal government from treating same-sex partners as married.

From the San Francisco Chronicle:

The decision was issued July 26. Immigration Equality, a gay-rights group that is working with the couple, received the notice Friday and made it public Monday. Makk was ordered to depart the United States by Aug. 25. Makk is the sole caregiver for Wells, who has severe health problems.

“I’m married just like any other married person in this country,” Wells said. “At this point, the government can come in and take my husband and deport him. It’s infuriating. It’s upsetting. I have no power, no right to keep my husband in this country. I love this country, I live here, I pay taxes and I have no right to share my home with the person I married.”


The agency’s decision cited the Defense of Marriage Act as the reason for the denial of an I-130 visa, or spousal petition that could allow Makk to apply for permanent U.S. residency. “The claimed relationship between the petitioner and the beneficiary is not a petitionable relationship,” the decision said. “For a relationship to qualify as a marriage for purposes of federal law, one partner must be a man and the other a woman.”

ICE’s director John Morton in June issued a memorandum that suggested DOMA-related cases might be put on the back-burner, especially if applicants would meet all other necessary criteria for citizenship. This call to prioritize cases did not, however, specifically mention LGBTs and as such its impact has been questioned.

Makk contends he meets all other criteria for citizenship and that he has always played by the rules when it comes to immigration law.

From a previous San Francisco Gate article:

Makk said he has scrupulously abided by U.S. immigration laws during their relationship, always holding a valid visa, never working illegally and never overstaying a visa by even a day. For many years, Makk was able to remain in the country through a special visa granted to traders by establishing a business designing and importing architectural glass from Australia. That business collapsed with the 2008 housing crash, taking his visa with it.

Since then, he has invested in the rental apartment building in hopes of securing an E-2 investors visa, but immigration officials have told him that he has not invested enough money.

The couple has been actively searching for other properties, but Makk said he cannot risk investing in something that would only bankrupt them and that he has scant hope of finding something viable in the next two weeks. There is no hard dollar figure that immigration officials say immigrants must invest to qualify for an investor visa.

The couple’s options from this point on are limited, and are even more complicated because of Wells’ poor health.

They must now decide whether Makk wishes to remain in the country illegally to file an appeal in this case — which appears unlikely to succeed — or consider a move back to Makk’s birth country Australia.

Group Immigration Equality has contacted California Democratic Sens. Dianne Feinstein and Barbara Boxer, and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-San Francisco, and asked them to intervene in the case.

As a last resort legislators can introduce private legisation on behalf of specific couples so as to halt immigration proceedings against them, but such bills are certainly not routine.

Pelosi’s office has said it will “exhaust all appropriate immigration remedies” to try and help the couple.

Immigration Equality are also appealing directly to the Obama administration to intervene.

Until the Defense of Marriage Act is repealed, however, these sorts of cases will continue to occur.

Related Reading:

How does DOMA Hurt Same-Sex Couples?

Bankruptcy Court: Defense of Marriage Act Unconstitutional

CREW Files Ethics Complaint Against Boehner Regarding DOMA Defense


Read more: , , , , , , ,

Photo used under the Creative Commons Attribution License with thanks to brainchildvn.

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it


+ add your own
11:12PM PDT on Aug 20, 2011

Sigh, another heart-breaking story and clear strike against DOMA. Get rid of it already for crying out loud. Let people live freely.

11:46AM PDT on Aug 15, 2011

This is appalling. They've been together 19 years and they want to deport Makk. Another reason why DOMA is a disgrace. I really hope that this is sorted out, without him being deported. Shame on America if this happens.

12:58PM PDT on Aug 14, 2011

Yet another reason why DOMA needs to be repealed. I signed the petition.

3:56PM PDT on Aug 10, 2011

Yet, millions of illegal immigrants are living in this country,working the system, and receiving every social service they can get.

3:51PM PDT on Aug 10, 2011

One more reason to be embarrassed to be an American.

1:38PM PDT on Aug 10, 2011

It's OUR loss... taxpayers will end up taking care of the American born spouse, instead of allowing the law-abiding spouse to stay and care for his long-time marriage partner.

This is so very wrong...

11:55AM PDT on Aug 10, 2011

So. Angry. Cannot. Comment. Without. Extreme. Profanity.

10:56AM PDT on Aug 10, 2011

I guess picking on these two guys is SO much easier for ICE than actually focusing their attention on the millions of people here illegally in this country--those who were NEVER here legally, who never even bothered to try to become legal citizens, and yet are reaping all the benefits despite being criminals. What ICE is doing is comparable to the Department of Justice focusing on only arresting jaywalkers, people who run a red light, and people with messy lawns, rather than focusing on killers, rapists, and child molesters. Not saying all illegal aliens are major criminals but they ARE criminals, whereas this Aussie has done nothing to break the laws of this country, actually wants to be a citizen, is married by state laws, and has been here totally legally for nineteen years. ICE should be ashamed of themselves.

10:53AM PDT on Aug 10, 2011

Terrible. DOMA does it again. :(

10:12AM PDT on Aug 10, 2011

You know, ICE, changing a name doesn't change the animal. This is still the same agency that has time to single out people for political reasons.
I like and respect Bill Clinton, but DADT and DOMA were politically his lowest points. DOMA should be thrown out along with DADT. NOW!

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

Wonderful news lets hope more can be saved from cruel humans x

A few years ago I read of an elderly man who robbed a bank, asking for $1 so he could be taken to jail.…

I have seen only a hand full of Bees this year, very sad.

meet our writers

Steve Williams Steve Williams is a passionate supporter of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Trans (LGBT) rights, human... more
ads keep care2 free

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.

site feedback


Problem on this page? Briefly let us know what isn't working for you and we'll try to make it right!