START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
914,826 people care about Women's Rights

Shiloh Jolie-Pitt, Gender Bender?

Shiloh Jolie-Pitt, Gender Bender?

It’s hard to be three years old these days.  You’re too young to read and good books, you’re too old to get to sleep all day or be carried around all of the time, and frankly it’s really about time those silly toddlers start acting like the men and women they are going to grow up to be some day. 

And apparently, first we need to start with the clothes, especially if you are going to be in the public eye.

No one knows that better now that Shiloh Jolie-Pitt, daughter of Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt.  Now that the terrible twos have come and gone, they youngster has been seen sporting a look that gossip mags are decrying and if she was the next coming of Brandon Teena.

Shiloh, 3, had just come from the hairdressers when magazine editors in the US decided she looked more like her brother, Knox.

Her superstar parents, Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie, have been slammed for dressing the tot like a boy for a while, according to ninemsn.com. They reportedly call her ‘John’.

One US publication ran the cover line ‘Why is Angelina turning Shiloh into a boy?’.

The same magazine in a story fielded ‘experts’ to explain the child’s short haircut. Alana Kelen, senior fashion stylist at VH1, said: ‘Shiloh is pushing the boundaries of a tomboy look and crossing over to cross-dresser territory.’

I’ve written before about my utter annoyance with the idea of “girl” clothing.  Between sparkly todder clothes and pre-tweens being sold French Maid outfits that border on lingerie, the desire for marketers and media to make little girls extraordinarily feminine and extremely sexualized way too early continues to run rampant.

As Mary Elizabeth Williams points out on Salon, the frenzy over a girl in pants and short hair regardless of her age is puzzling (after all, did we all already forget the 70s?).

It’s easy to laugh at all the furor over one little girl’s hair — and believe me, I do, heartily — but the hand-wringing over Shiloh says a hell of a lot about how eager we are to narrowly define sex roles, and how easy it is to incite outrage when we transgress in the slightest. Shiloh, that poor girl, may not be the über fashionista that Suri Cruise is, but guess what? Go to a playground sometime, and see how well you fare identifying the gender of any little kid who isn’t in a fairy costume or a football jersey. Oh, to have a dollar for every parent who’s put a foot in the mouth over some cherub in a snowsuit.

Which leads to the question — who, by the way, decided that short hair and pants were the exclusive domain of boys? Keira Knightley, Natalie Portman, Halle Berry, Victoria Beckman and, uh, every other woman who’s ever cut her hair are going to be pissed when they hear about this.  Likewise, say what you will about parents who force a gender-neutral identity on their kids, but it’s pretty ridiculous to go straight to j’accuse! town every time a tyke isn’t all decked out in extreme parodies of femininity — or, for that matter, masculinity. You think all the ink given to Shiloh is crazy? Ever seen what happens when a boy dares to flout convention and wear long hair? The outrage!

And, yes, pretty much every parent of a little girl will end up cutting off all of her hair at some point.  It’s a rite of passage, especially if you have a toddler who refuses to stay still long enough to get a brush through it.  And I’d much rather let her run around in a pair of sweats and her favorite Star Wars T-Shirt than try to dress her in clothes she doesn’t feel like wearing.

Being a toddler is about learning that you have an individual will, and pushing it as far as you can while you create your own identity.  It’s sad when it has to be done in the public eye, and the media feels the need to critique the identity she is creating.

Read more: , , , ,

wikimedia commons

quick poll

vote now!

Loading poll...

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

194 comments

+ add your own
5:25PM PDT on Mar 19, 2012

Shiloh is pretty little girl even with short haircut or tomboy look.


7:36PM PDT on Apr 26, 2010

Not all girls want to be princesses! I was always dressed in boy's clothes. My closest cousin in age was a boy, so I always ended up with all his old clothes when he outgrew them. In fact, I liked them better than girls clothes (whoever came up with idea of stockings for girls??!!!)

10:34PM PDT on Apr 22, 2010

My mother had my hair cut at the barber's, boy style, until I was laughed at in kindergarten for such short hair (I looked like a boy !!). I rebelled & insisted on growing my hair from then on. Shiloh is only 3 - she can decide when she's a bit older if she wants long or short hair. Who's business is it anyway ?

4:56PM PDT on Apr 20, 2010

Who cares?

11:03PM PDT on Apr 16, 2010

My 4 year old son has painted toenails. He saw me doing it one night and wanted to try it himself. I figured "What a great time for some fime motor training". Now he has orange and black toes that he is proud to show. Will he be gay because of this? No. He is already "married" to one of the girls in his preschool.

8:07AM PDT on Apr 13, 2010

Pants, t-shirts, short hair are comfortable clothes! What if Shiloh wants to dress like that? Have you tried arguing over clothes with a 3-year-old? It gets ugly pretty fast!

5:46AM PDT on Mar 31, 2010

My Mother cut my hair short every spring so it would be easier to look after during the summer. My own child, a 9 yr old boy, refuses to have his hair cut - he plays drums, and is a rocker wanna-be......who knows what next year will bring, but for now, it is what it is. The media has to find something else to do!!!

8:12PM PDT on Mar 29, 2010

It's shameful how much people pay attention to celebrity children while millions of kids go neglected by their own parents.

5:12PM PDT on Mar 28, 2010

many years ago, when i used to go to sci fi conventions, jack chalker talked about this issue. he and his wife would dress their toddler in orange clothes, yellow, white, anything but blue, then see how people reacted. most times people thought their little boy was a girl. and then they would be embarrassed when told that the child was a boy. :)

5:09PM PDT on Mar 28, 2010

i would much rather see a little girl shiloh's age dressed in t-shirts and jeans with short hair than the horrible obsession some parents have to push their little girls into fashion shoes, a la that little bonet girl that was murdered many years ago.

long live parents who dress their children normally!!!

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

great stuff .... a good news story .... hope for humanity!

Three cheers for the rescuers. So wonderful to hear that humanity did the right thing instead of following…

The U.S. is beyond being ready for a female President (I voted for Cynthia Mckinney in '08, Jill Stein…

ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.