START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
752,279 people care about Education

Should Teachers Be Judged by Standardized Test Scores?

Should Teachers Be Judged by Standardized Test Scores?

Should a teacher’s job performance be judged on his or her students’ standardized test score?

Yes, say 80% of U.S. states which subscribe to this theory, but now new research has arrived calling into question whether such scores are a fair measure of a teacher’s job performance.

Researchers from the University of Southern California and the University of Pennsylvania teamed up to determine whether student test scores were a reflection on the quality of teaching. In their newly published study, they failed to find a substantial correlation between scores and the standard of instruction. Teachers that rated highly in a number of ways including principal and student evaluations often had underwhelming test scores. Conversely, teachers who ranked poorly by these other measures had students who scored exceptionally on the tests.

The fact that one facet cannot predict the other suggests that there is a flaw in the way the educational system determines which teachers get to keep their jobs. Speaking to the Washington Post, Morgan Polikoff, a professor and researcher at USC, said, “We need to slow down or ease off completely for the sakes for teachers, at least in the first years, so we can get a sense of ‘what do these things measure? What does it mean?’ We’re moving these systems forward way ahead of the science in terms of the quality of the measures.”

Troublingly, teachers are already actively receiving bonuses or, worse yet, pink slips based upon data that has not yet been proven to be a reliable judge of performance. The national push to make standardized testing the focus of education isn’t benefiting students any more than it is teachers.

The new study is hardly alone in pointing out the disparity between standardized test scores and the characteristics we formerly used to judge good teachers. Not long ago, the American Statistical Association broke down the different factors that account for how well a student does on a standardized test. The group calculated that teacher influence accounts for somewhere between 1 to 14% of a student’s score, meaning that the vast majority of the score is up to factors out of the teacher’s control.

Despite the mounting evidence that test scores are not a good indicator of teacher performance, states are giving growing weight to test scores all the same. 35 states mandate that test scores are a “significant” factor in evaluating teachers, though some have even dictated that it be the “most significant” factor; only ten states do not require test scores to be considered in the teacher evaluation process.

Surprisingly, President Obama’s educational policies are promoting this unfortunate trend. In order for school systems to receive money from the Race to the Top program, they must have restrictive teacher evaluation systems in place.

Teachers already feel enough pressure to teach to the tests, why compound the problem by making their jobs depend on them, too? We stand to undervalue if not outright lose great teachers who pass along the kind of wisdom and thirst for knowledge that standardized tests can’t measure if schools continue down this current path.

Read more: , , , , , ,

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

64 comments

+ add your own
7:00PM PDT on Aug 30, 2014

Life is a test.

12:02PM PDT on May 19, 2014

Oh this just slays me. Never can a teacher be judged by test scores alone. I understand the need to have a subjective way to evaluate but this is not the way

3:42AM PDT on May 17, 2014

This would be interesting.

10:15AM PDT on May 16, 2014

NO

4:01AM PDT on May 16, 2014

The last paragraph says it all for me. Good teachers inspire curiosity and a desire to learn - which doesn't necessarily show up in standardised scores.

1:39AM PDT on May 16, 2014

Maybe we should start judging politicians on how life improves for their constituents. By the number of bipartisan bills they vote for & what they accomplish. I don't think there would be many who made the grade....
A standardized test only tells one what the student can spit back. It has no bearing on critical thinking. They are unfair with questions. I once taught in the Valley in TX & one of the questions had to do with snow & ice - very few valley kids had ever seen either one. A test is only supposed to be administered with 1 thing in mind - what does the student need to learn. It should never be the means by which a person advances to the next grade nor a basis for what a teacher has taught.

8:19PM PDT on May 15, 2014

Its about time they start looking into this. There are just some people (me included) that have no problem with their daily homework and projects but they just can not test very well--the stress of it and just in general makes test an unfair way of determining whether or not students have actually learned anything.

7:22PM PDT on May 15, 2014

Are we still debating this ridiculous issue? Any politician who says our children come first, and then bases teacher performance on standardized tests is a liar.

5:41PM PDT on May 15, 2014

What about parents? I don't care about "judging" them, but they need to be help accountable. They are the first and at times the most effective teachers.

2:29PM PDT on May 15, 2014

One such test, does not, a teacher make...

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

These stories are certainly appropriate for Halloween! Thank you for these diverse cultural stories…

Adam S. wrote: "Good for them. A gun is my guarantee that the government will fear me rather than the…

ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.