South Africa Resumes Canned Hunting

“Canned hunting” is back in season for South Africa after a judge upheld an appeal by predator breeders.

In 2007, Environmental Affairs and Tourism Minister for South Africa Marthinus van Schalkwyk instituted rules to restrict the practice of captive or “canned” hunting. The rules were already seen as a cowardly compromise by animal rights activists who hoped to see the practice abolished entirely.

Under the 2007 rules, animals must be allowed to roam free for at least 24 months before they are fair game for hunters, contrasted with the previous practice of setting animals loose from their cages to be immediately killed by hunters. After two years in the wild, the animals were no longer considered tame and were eligible for hunting.

Minister Van Schalkwyk originally proposed an even shorter time of six months before the animals could be hunted. A confusing position from someone who has spoken out so vehemently against the practice of canned hunting.

Animal rights activists at the time accused the government of caving to pressure in 2007 from the captive breeders who bring over $450 million. And now the threat from the breeders has proven quite real as the high court upheld their appeal of Van Schalkwyk’s rules, saying the rules were not rational.

Jason Bell-Leask of the International Fund for Animal Welfare says that the most rational decision would have been to ban the practice of breeding lions in captivity for hunting.

It seems likely that the judge’s decision had as much to do with the big coffers of the South African Predator Breeder’s Association as with the admittedly arbitrary standard set by Van Schalkwyk. Abolishing the practice of breeding captive lions may have outraged the breeders even more, but it would have presented a more rational and easily defensible standard.

Hunting wild animals is already an example of the worst in human arrogance and irresponsibility. We disguise cold-blooded murder as “sport” or hide it under the deceptive veil of a bucolic appreciation of the outdoors.

But canned hunting represents the absolute height of hubris and laziness. It’s hard to imagine how someone could view proud and powerful animals as products out of a factory, bred for immediate release and slaughtered moments after taking their first breaths outside of a cage.

Canned hunting is to wild hunting what factory farming is to family farms, and both of those former examples have been able to show us the horrifying lengths of cruelty humanity will go to when we view animals as nothing more than objects, property to be used for whatever profit we can gain from their exploitation.

Minister Van Schalkwyk’s mistake was to trying to regulate canned hunting instead of abolishing it outright. A mistake that we see all too often in animal advocacy. 

If we seek to help animals, if we seek to make the world a better place for them, if we seek to end their torture, exploitation, captivity, slavery, and murder, then we have no alternative but veganism. 

We must refuse to eat, use, wear, or exploit animals in any way and we must advocate for an absolute end to all industries that profit from animals’ misery.

Related Stories: 

Canned Lion Hunting Is Cruel: An Activist Spotlight

Country Music Star Troy Gentry’s Canned Hunt Video Released by Animal Rights Group

The New Vegan CEO


Photo: Sheep purple

Love This? Never Miss Another Story.


Jospeh R.
Jospeh R.3 months ago

Hey nice post man! Thanks for incredible info. Archery Site

Diane L.
Diane L.2 years ago

You people DO realize this article is now TWO YEARS OLD, don't you?

heather g.
heather g.2 years ago

Thank you, Mac McDaniel, for an excellent article.

When greed and money are involved - ethics flies out of the window.
Shame on the South African government for not showing leadership....

Michelle S.
shelly S.2 years ago

This makes me so ashamed to be South African! Money talks, and as usual, the animals rights are ignored. When will we wake up and see???

Marcia Shiel
M s2 years ago

south africa is as stupid and cruel as mexico,asia and the usa...all idiots who deserve to suffer for the rest of their miserable selfish lives

Past Member
Kathryn E.2 years ago

I don't know how anyone can get away with this nowerdays. a lion is the most powerful king of the jungle, its twisted and immoral to oragnise this trophy hunting to feed the ego and vanity of cruel unenlightened men (and shockingly also women!) This is UNNATURAL killing for the KING to be hunted for the vanity of man. No lion is EVER in nature supposed to have a predator, this is sinful A-Dharma and does not respect the creator

this is the twisted immoral perverted mind of modern man, vanity, Profit and GREED is completly transparent, sickening uglly and gross. Stop this perverted human ignorance now.

Selwyn M.
Selwyn M.3 years ago

As long as there are Humans and Politicos,Killing is the sport.Sometimes we kill Rhinos,us humans need their horn,in the States we are wiping out all the Wild Mustangs and Burros to appease the Cattle Ranchers,us Humans need the land,In US and the UK we are wiping out Family-Pets because of the way they look they might bite us Humans.
We just love Killing.

Lise K.
Lise K.3 years ago

I'm against any kind of hunting, but canned hunting is the worst!

Rhoda Barkhan B.
Rhoda Barkhan4 years ago

I have just returned from a visit to a "Golf Estate" where there are lion cubs bred for canned hunting. Maybe if the world will say "we will not visit your country until this terrble action is stopped, " we may get some results. I live in S. Africa and cannot condone this terrible action. Please, people, put your money where your mouth is a write to the department of tourism advising that they will not see you or your money until this terrible action is stopped.

Rita S
Rita S4 years ago

The world will never see eye to eye. Good article.