South Dakota Bill Would Mandate Religious Counseling Prior To Abortion

A bill making its way through the South Dakota legislature would mandate that all women who need an abortion first undergo “counseling” at a Crisis pregnancy center and then wait 72 hours before the procedure could be performed.  The bill also creates a burden of proof of sorts by requiring that a women “prove” she is not being coerced into a decision to terminate her pregnancy.

The state Senate Health and Human Services Committee voted 6-1 to send the bill to a full chamber.  The House has already passed the measure and the governor is likely to sign it.

Assuming the bill becomes law it will likely face a legal challenge as it unreasonably restricts women’s rights to access legal health care procedure.

Mandatory counseling/waiting bills are offensive for a number of reasons.  They drum up the imaginary problem of women “rushing” through the decision and process of terminating a pregnancy when the evidence does not support this reality at all.  They also take away from women the right to make informed medical decisions and instead institute a “gatekeeper” charged with “protecting” the woman from the pernicious forces of medical advice.

But an additional, and often overlooked problem with these measures blur the line between religion and state to a level that is very likely unconstitutional.

Crisis pregnancy centers are at their core anti-abortion fronts grounded in Christian-right anti-choice ideology.  They almost always receive state funding and, through legislation such as what is pending in South Dakota, become de facto benefactors of the state and entangle the state into essentially sponsoring or endorsing a specific religious belief about abortion.  And that is key as cpc’s don’t offer verified and accurate scientific evidence to buttress their recommendations.

So when the state anoints these religious-based crisis pregnancy centers to gatekeepers of access to reproductive health services it is forcing women to under go religious rather than medical counseling prior to accessing these services.

Even more disturbing, South Dakota admits this is what they are doing with this particular measure since one of the purposes of the bill is to help women cope “spiritually” with unintended pregnancies.

The First Amendment is clear that a state cannot find itself endorsing or “entangled” with a particular religious belief.  But that is exactly what this South Dakota measure does.  These lawmakers have decided that ministers and not doctors are the people best equipped to help women make a difficult medical decision.  And that right there is constitutionally impermissible.

photo courtesy of alexandralee via Flickr

171 comments

Ellen Emerson
Ellen Emerson4 years ago

I might support a 24 hour waiting period for young women under 18, but religious counseling forced on a woman of any age... WTF?! Are we living int he 1600s? Look up where the saying Rule of Thumb comes from - this is another case of men making up laws that only affect women.

Pbrane Thefunkyboson
Past Member 4 years ago

Holy crap (no pun intended ;D), are they joking?

Linda O.
Linda Owen4 years ago

Ridiculous!

Matilda H.
Past Member 4 years ago

This is ridiculous.

angela g.
angela glanzer5 years ago

This is one of the most ludicrous things I've ever heard.

Audrey L.
Audrey L.5 years ago

What absolute craziness. Please keep religion out of politics South Dakota. Concentrate on important issues for your state.

Linda T.
Linda T.5 years ago

I wonder why the ACLU is not fighting these absurd laws with the separation of chuch and state cluas in the constitution? This as well as funding pregnancy centers are clearly a violation.

Melanie Clark
Melanie Clark5 years ago

This is so sad. I mean, now they want to "push" their religion on others who wouldn't otherwise want it. It's no one's business but the woman's own for wanting an abortion. I do not like this at all. I hope that someone(s) put a stop to all these abortion/miscarriage laws very soon because I'm starting not to trust anyone in the U.S. anymore.

Botyfltiger E.
Past Member 5 years ago

Anneles, hear, hear, I learned young about 'our' ex-religion, there are more hypocrites in the catholic religion then, I think, any other religion in the World.

annelies j.
annelies j.5 years ago

Boty, I agree, but Christianity is the one I grew up with and know more about. The more I get to know it, the less I can accept it.