START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
2,495,653 people care about Environment & Wildlife

Stop Selling Sea Turtles for Meat in Cayman Islands

Stop Selling Sea Turtles for Meat in Cayman Islands

There’s a turtle farm in the Cayman Islands that sells sea turtles for meat. Indeed, it is the only remaining turtle farm left on earth.  The Cayman Turtle Farm (CTF) is government sanctioned under the guise of being a research and conservancy program.  It also is a popular tourist attraction where the public is encouraged to watch and swim with the turtles, it lets children hold hatchlings and advertises the Farm as the premiere British Caribbean Islands wedding destination.

Florida-based Sea Turtle Conservancy (STC) has teamed with WSPA International (World Society for the Protection of Animals) to stop CTF from farming green sea turtles.  This includes a Care2 petition.

“The Cayman Turtle Farm tries to promote its operation as something beneficial to wild turtle population” said David Godfrey, STC Executive director, in a recent press release.  “Despite the lack of evidence that the turtle release program actually benefits the wild population, countless individuals around the world are led to believe that the program works and that it is a successful option for saving and restoring wild sea turtle numbers.”

“It’s truly horrific to see this type of neglect and cruelty taking place at a tourist attraction. Life in the Cayman Turtle Farm is a world away from how sea turtles live in the wild,” said Dr. Neil D’Cruze, WSPA Wildlife Campaign Leader.

CTF is denying the allegations and stated in its own press release that it has called for an independent review of operations at the Farm scheduled for December of this year.  It is currently unknown who or what organization will be performing the review.

A video at CTF was made by WSPA and can be seen on YouTube.  Among other things like excrement-polluted holding tanks the turtles are forced to live in, it alleges overcrowded living conditions forcing the turtles to resort to cannibalism.

Sea Turtles Facts

Wild sea turtles are solitary creatures that swim thousands of miles. They have been around for 110 million years, since dinosaurs roamed the earth. Sea turtles can grow to 700 pounds, depending on the species. They eat jellyfish, seaweed, crabs, shrimp, sponges, snails, algae and mollusks. The sea turtle is an endangered species found in warm and temperate waters.

Sea turtles cannot retract their limbs and head into their shell, like other turtles can. They migrate hundreds of miles for nesting and feeding.  For that reason, tracking wild turtles is difficult.

Female turtles leave the sea to make a nest in sandy beaches and lay their eggs.  Once mature, the hatchlings migrate back to sea under cover of nightfall. Only about one in 1,000 hatchlings survive, often becoming food for crabs, birds and other marine animals.

The sex of sea turtles is determined by the temperature at the time of incubation. Climate change is producing more female sea turtles because temperatures above 85º Fahrenheit (30ºC) produces predominately females. Below 85º Fahrenheit (30ºC), the eggs more likely become male.

Sea Turtles normally follow the moon and stars’ reflections to navigate back to the waters.  Artificial lighting near beaches confuses turtles, making them more vulnerable to predators and dehydration.

Accusations

CTF has not responded to STC’s claim that in August 2012, the Farm lost about 300 juvenile turtles when a pipe broke resulting in a lower water level, leaving the overcrowded turtles baking in the sun.  The most obvious questions are why were the turtles left exposed?  Why weren’t the turtles moved to a temporary setting with enough water?

STC disagrees with CTF procedure of releasing farm-raised turtles into the wild and calling it conservation. STC claims CTF is actually increasing international demand for turtle meat and shell products.  Currently, CTF sells about ten percent of its turtles for meat.  Turtle steak, fritters and soups are standard fare on menus in the Cayman Islands.

STC feels there are three problems with releasing farm-raised turtles into the wild:

1. Farm-raised turtles at CTF have a number of documented diseases; releasing them into the wild will introduce those diseases to the wild population.
2. CTF stock was collected from breeding colonies throughout the Atlantic. Releasing turtles of mixed genetic origin into the wild will likely affect the wild population in negative ways.
3. The ability of sea turtles to return to breeding sites is genetically hard-wired.  Releasing turtles to breed that originated from different oceans into a wild population could have devastating effects.

Godfrey reports “The impact of the Farm’s agenda to open international markets to sea turtle trade is much more obvious. The Cayman Farm has a long history of working to ease international regulations that would allow them to market and sell turtle meat and shell produced at the Farm. To be sure, the Farm would like to put ‘green turtle soup’ back on the menu in Europe and elsewhere.”

WSPA released a 24 page report on CTS called “A Case for Change.”  The major concerns cited are threat to sea turtle welfare, failure of the conservation mandate, human health risks and the financial unsustainability of the program.  It recommends ending the commercial production of green sea turtles and suggests it become a sea turtle research and education center.

What You Can Do

Sign the Care2 petition.

Learn more by visiting WSPA’s website stopseaturtlefarm.org.

Spread the word through Facebook and Twitter.

Related Care2 Reading:

International Turtle Experts Search for the Elusive Hawksbill

Heroic Volunteers Spend Night and Day Saving baby Sea Turtles

Soldiers Looking Out for At-Risk Turtles

Artists Get Surprise ‘Thanks’ During Rescue of Snapping Turtle

Read more: , , , , , , , ,

Photo credit: Thinkstock

quick poll

vote now!

Loading poll...

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

83 comments

+ add your own
10:32AM PDT on Sep 25, 2013

Mark D: There's a lot of passion there, for sure, but would it be possible to couch it in language that's not so rude? I really do think the way you expressed your opinions was inappropriate. Common courtesy costs nothing. You can get your point across clearly and politely, the two are not mutually exclusive. Thank you. :-)

10:31AM PDT on Sep 25, 2013

Regarding your comments on intelligence, reptiles have proved to be very intelligent. Crocodilians can be taught complex tricks and commands and this ability to learn does not diminish with age - unlike with the proverbial dog. Being a mammal is not synonymous with being intelligent, necessarily. Little research has been done on turtle/tortoise intelligence so I think the door is still open on that one. However, I'm confused as to how intelligence relates to the issues brought up in the article.

10:31AM PDT on Sep 25, 2013

Norman L. Your comments did not address issues ( mentioned in the article as being of concern to biologists who specialise in turtle conservation), regarding the introduction of disease into wild populations from the farmed turtles, the failure of the farm to keep the various strains that they have collected from the wild genetically pure which causes problems if the genetically mixed turtles are introduced to the wild, and the devastating problems that could be caused in relation to the animals' homing instincts.

The survival rate is inapplicable here. There are basically 2 ways of reproducing. One is to produce a small no. of offspring and put a lot of effort into making sure that they survive to adulthood and can breed. Humans would be an example of this, along with cows and sheep. The other way is to produce many offspring and not make much effort to bring them up. Many of them will die but the sheer numbers produced in the first place mean that there are enough to make it through to adulthood and breed to continue the species. Essentially, turtles are fine with this breeding strategy. Once a turtle reaches adulthood, there is little that is a threat to it, naturally. The problems for turtles are climate change as mentioned in the article, adults dying due to boat propellors, eating plastic bags that they think are jellyfish, being eaten by people etc. All these problems are compounded by the issues brought up by the biologists at STC mentioned just now above.

Re

2:06AM PDT on Sep 25, 2013

That's disturbing. I read the name of the place, & I thought it sounded like a cool place to go. I was SO wrong!! I cannot believe they actually EAT those turtles. That's gross! Those turtles should not be eaten, they should be protected!

12:46PM PDT on May 4, 2013

Thank you for the petition. Unfortunately, it was closed, but I have signed numerous petitions related to sea turtles.

6:09PM PST on Nov 11, 2012

Norman L. Stop spewing your disgusting lies about how the turtles haven't survived in massive quantities for millions of years without human slaughter, and leave our precious world's wildlife alone to survive in the ecosystem as they have done for eons without disgusting, homicidal human apes like you. all you have proved is you and your factory torture farm friends are among the human race's greedy psychopaths that do not deserve the oxygen they breathe. If you believe so strongly that wildlife should be factory farmed and tortured, then put your money where your mouth is, I'd like to see you and your murdering friends in the Cayman islands regarded as expendable wildlife, tortured and slaughtered for human consumption, send your putrid meat to the Chinese they eat anything.

10:59AM PST on Nov 11, 2012

already signed and shared but thanks for sharing :)

4:29PM PST on Nov 10, 2012

Signed & shared petition. Disgusting.

2:23PM PST on Nov 10, 2012

Thanks for the petition.

6:37PM PST on Nov 9, 2012

signed - humans are destroying everything they touch!

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

They didn't euthanized Excalibur. He had no symptons, he was not sick, not in pain. They executed him.…

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches and writes about ancient Greek and Latin and is Online Advocacy and Marketing... more
ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.