START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good

COPENHAGEN: The Cop15 Blame Game

COPENHAGEN:  The Cop15 Blame Game

At the United Nations Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen (Cop15), global leaders aren’t just negotiating a climate deal—they’re positioning to avoid blame if the talks fail.

David Corn reports for Mother Jones that as soon as U.S. climate change envoy Todd Stern arrived at the Bella Center this Wednesday, he quickly listed all of the Obama administration’s actions to address climate change: The Clean Air Act, the proposed reduction in emissions, boosted fuel economy standards, and so on. Stern then changed the subject to China, observing that “by 2020, China’s emissions will top those from the United States’ by 60 percent, and then by 80 percent in 2030.”

Stern’s message is clear: If the talks don’t succeed, it’s not America’s fault. Corn writes that “with fundamental questions unresolved—particularly the obligations of China and the other major developing nations—it’s quite possible the talks could collapse and yield an orgy of accusation. Thus, the need for governments to fret about Plan B, as in Plan Blame. The real problem is, if such a worst-case scenario does occur, each of the major players will indeed have plenty of cause to point fingers at the others.”

But are we really in a position to point fingers? The United States spent an average of $130 billion a year on the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq from 2003 to 2009. The Obama administration has requested $138.6 billion for 2010, plus approximately $30 billion more for the additional troop surge.

When the Congressional Budget Office estimated the cost of a climate bill several months ago, it came up with a dramatically different sum: $22 billion per year.

As Matthew Yglesias writes for The American Prospect, “the United States has in the recent past undertaken initiatives that cost dramatically more than a strong climate initiative. We did it because we could afford it, and because the political elite in the United States takes military ventures seriously and wants to see them succeed. Well, averting catastrophic climate change is important too. … Whether we leave a legacy of leadership that meets that challenge will be determined largely by what happens at Copenhagen and what the Senate does to live up to whatever commitments the Obama administration makes there.”

The final deal needs to be inclusive of all people. Mantoe Phakathi of Inter Press Service writes that the deal needs to account for gender rather than simply classifying women as “vulnerable groups,” a term used in climate change policies in many countries, including South Africa and Kenya.

“Gotelind Alber, a researcher for the U.N.’s agency for housing, UN-HABITAT, said women in city slums are more vulnerable after natural disasters—women are often last to hear warnings of coming disasters, unable to move quickly while safeguarding children in their care, and in the breakdown of order that typically follows, exposed to violence.”

Finally, in the largest demonstration so far at Cop15, hundreds of youth created a “climate storm” inside the Bella Center yesterday, as Joshua Kahn Russell reports for Grist. The young activists clapped, snapped, and pounded their feet in representation of the typhoons and hurricanes that have ravaged communities around the world this year [Video below].


This post features links to the best independent, progressive reporting about the environment by members of The Media Consortium. It is free to reprint.  This is a project of The Media Consortium, a network of leading independent media outlets.

Read more: , , ,

UN Climate Conference
by Alison Hamm, Media Consortium

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it


+ add your own
10:45PM PDT on May 3, 2013

Thank you for info.

10:44PM PDT on May 3, 2013

Thank you for info.

10:42PM PDT on May 3, 2013

Thank you for info.

10:41PM PDT on May 3, 2013

Thank you for info.

10:40PM PDT on May 3, 2013

Thank you for info.

9:44PM PST on Dec 16, 2009

Aye lassie; stewarts of the earth;now we see more definitve
connectedness in yer parlance.
Soooo; the sheeple and the stewarts . Hmmmmm
Yes; I think I recall this pattern. Pg. 34 think tank strategies for beginners; right next to foxy bathroom wall suggestions and
excallating power definitions, categories and personality boosters.
OOOOOKAY; now let's see Gore,,, ahhhhhhh..fact of the matter isssssss; ttthhhhe reaaallityyyyy iiissssss.
Wait a minute ; I think I've got it. Cow stinkies....that's it
Somebody is trying to tell us that we should get into Beano!??
Beano futures; that's the ticket.I knew there was an answer to all this confusion.
Wait; what's that wallmart number again?

8:22PM PST on Dec 16, 2009

this is starting to remind me of Dr Strangelove;
remember the guy in the wheelchair who couldn't keep his arm
from flying up in the nazi salute?
zis all needs to STOP!
Zis has nothing WHAT SO EVER to do mit U.S.
Now listen to ze EDUCATED British my little ones
and don't vorry vot yur zeeing and shmelling and feeling.
Zo even if ze whole of ze mankind is kaput and ze whole planet is also KAPUT; zis is good..... Ya?
nice little cockarocha ya?
Que the texan dropping on the bomb waving his hat.

1:42PM PST on Dec 15, 2009

I say this all needs to stop! There is nothing man has done to cause whatever is happening. People, read your earth history!! All the answers are right there under your nose. Why are you believing people like Al Gore? I am telling all of you that this is total BullSh!t!! Here is a link for all of you sheeple to become a little more educated. Hmmmm, and it came from Great Britian.....the leaders in clean the earth....

6:15AM PST on Dec 15, 2009

Yes, I don't think the US should point the finger when they only spend $22 billion on the climate bill, but $130 billion on people getting killed. A lot of people here care about "today" and not tomorrow. They don't think about their kids, they only think about themselves. They don’t recycle; they let their cars running…why??? Something should have been done a long time ago, and now it's too late. It will not take long and the Arctic Ice is gone.

1:44AM PST on Dec 14, 2009

Thank you for the informationand including the links. As we know better we can do better by being an example as we each do our part!

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

I don't owe this prevaricating, vicious, vitriolic person one danged thing. I don't owe any of them anything.…

ads keep care2 free

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.