START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x

Transphobic Bureaucracy Doesn’t Stop At Death

Transphobic Bureaucracy Doesn’t Stop At Death

Indignities continue after death for transgender people, who have no guarantee that the coroner will mark their gender correctly on their death certificates. When transgender activist Christopher Lee took his life in 2012, the Alameda County medical examiner glanced at his body and made a casual gender assessment, labeling him “female” and gouging an even deeper hole into the hearts of his friends and loved ones.

Now, with the help of Assemblywoman Toni Atkins, transgender activists are hoping to introduce some clarity on how to fill out death certificates for transgender people, in order to help others avoid similar situations.

Why should marking gender on a death certificate be so hard? Surely you can just look at someone, right? Actually, it’s not that simple. Transgender people may die at varying stages of transition (it’s worth noting that the suicide rate is especially high in the trans community, especially among youths), or may decide not to pursue bottom or top surgery.

Consequently, someone might have external genitals and be a woman, or vice versa. Coroners may make an assumption based on external appearance instead of hormone levels, expressed gender identity, legal identifications, or statements from friends and family.

For Christopher Lee, that meant being labeled as a woman after death, despite the fact that he was on testosterone and identified as a man. It was just one more insult in a life of misgendering and transphobic attitudes, and he’s not the only transgender person who’s been labeled with the wrong gender after death. Despite the fact that his government IDs reflected his gender correctly and people who knew him could testify to the fact that he was a man, the coroner went with basic physical findings.

That’s because California, like other states, lacks a clear protocol on how to handle the deaths of transgender people. Coroners aren’t given any guidance on recording their gender after death, and proceed using the information that’s right in front of them, even if it conflicts with the reality of the decedent’s life. Under Assemblywoman Atkins’ bill, however, coroners would record a gender identity consistent with that expressed by the deceased, with legal documentation like a driver’s license or passport acting as sufficient documentation to prove it.

In addition, the bill streamlines the name change process for trans Californians, who currently have to go through the courts to change their names and amend legal documents like birth certificates. Getting a court order is expensive, and also exposes the petitioner to the risk of outing, thanks to the fact that courts require people to publish information about the proposed change in a newspaper of record. The bill creates a much safer and more private system for updating government documents, and creates an easy way to keep these documents consistent with a person’s gender identity.

This marks a key change from California’s somewhat haphazard system, which in addition to being expensive can also be somewhat discriminatory. Until 2012, trans people who wanted to change their sex markers on government documents had to provide documentation of gender confirmation surgery, for example, which meant that people who couldn’t afford or didn’t want surgery had to endure the humiliation and danger of having the wrong gender marked on documents like drivers’ licenses and passports.

If successful, this bill will make bureaucracy just a little bit safer for trans Californians — even after death.

Read more: , ,

Photo credit: Daniel X. O'Neil.

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

34 comments

+ add your own
7:45PM PDT on Apr 29, 2014

Trans* people are PEOPLE. They are who they are and don't hurt anyone else. The discrimination has got to end. They are not "confused" or "wrong". I know many trans* people, and they aren't hurting anyone.

5:23PM PDT on Apr 29, 2014

sad

4:00PM PDT on Apr 29, 2014

Leslea? even you define incorrectly. My BOY friend (with a penis!) sometimes sits to pee, you offend me with your narrow viewpoint (sarcasm)

Why is it so important? Are you any less you by a gender differentiation? so you have a penis and a vagina...pretty uncommon, you must have chosen to let that define your life rather than dealing with your body and moving on...I wish you all the best.

3:55PM PDT on Apr 29, 2014

Here is an idea. Let's call all people IT.

this is one of the silliest things I have read about. sorry, no sympathy here

12:05PM PDT on Apr 29, 2014

noted

11:27AM PDT on Apr 29, 2014

Maybe because I am not trans, I don't care what goes on my death certificate. By yhat point it just won't matter. And I would hope that those who love me would realize it's just not important what others think. In my lifetime I would like to see the whole world enlightened. When I die I'll be on to better things.

11:25AM PDT on Apr 29, 2014

It is EXACTLY this type of casual misgendering (along with other direct and indirect discrimination) that causes trans* people to be so much more likely to die early.

And that doesn't just include suicide and other self-harming actions that can lead to death. It also increases the chance of a person being murdered or seriously harmed by another person, if they are 'outed' by deliberate misgendering.

So, to those saying that it really doesn't matter because the person is dead... it DOES matter. Because it is the exact same attitude that is nonchalantly applied to LIVING trans* people on a daily basis, and it's not just hurtful and ignorant - it directly endangers them.

11:12AM PDT on Apr 29, 2014

Coroner's reports are meant to convey scientific fact, not the lies of those in la-la land. DNA tells the truth. Male and female is what the species is designed on. There is a very small percentage that are born with the characteristics of both, i.e. hermaphrodites, but if you aren't one of those cursed with such a flaw then it is very clear what you are and there is no real or reasonable room to complain otherwise.

10:50AM PDT on Apr 29, 2014

wow, we're still having the trolls who insist parts make the gender.

Ok brainiacs. I had BOTH ovaries and testes when I was born. What was I? Vagina AND penis. Yes, I even have a uterus.

What am I? Male? Female? How about if my genetics show XXY? There's an XX AND an XY. Which am I then?

Gender isn't between the legs. It's not in whether you stand or sit to pee. It's between your ears. Your limitations and inability to grasp this concept, is YOUR failure alone.

10:39AM PDT on Apr 29, 2014

And so it goes....

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

Im also glad she survived. "Your signatures helped bring justice for Andra Grace. Without the angry…

you do not build yourself up by putting someone else down

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches ancient Greek, Latin and Classics at Saint Peter's University in New Jersey.... more
Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.