Victory! Obama Signs the Animal Crush Prohibition Act

On December 9, President Barack Obama signed into law The Animal Crush Video Prohibition Act of 2010, which criminalizes the creation, sale, and marketing of videos that depict small animals intentionally being tortured and killed in what are more commonly referred to as “crush videos” or “crush porn.”

Crush videos were illegal in the U.S. until the Supreme Court overturned the 1999 Crush Act with a vote of 8-1 in the case of U.S. v. Stevens last April with the position that it was overly broad and violated the First Amendment right to free speech.

The 1999 law in question, which covered the creation, sale and possession of depictions of animal cruelty was targeted at the sales of “crush videos,” which show women crushing small animals to death with their bare feet or high heels and is also considered to fall in the realm of sexual fetishes. Excluded was anything that contained “serious religious, political, scientific, educational, journalistic, historical or artistic value.”

The vote overturned the conviction of Robert Stevens, who was found guilty of selling videotapes of dogfights in 2005 under the guise that “he is an educator, and his subject is the history and status of pit bulls,” despite reports of his involvement in the dog fighting world.

Since then, a new stronger version of the bill was drafted and sponsored by Senators Jon Kyl, R-Ariz., Richard Burr, R-N.C. and Jeff Merkely, D-Ore., and Reps. Elton Gallegly, R-Calif., and Gary Peters, D-Mich. Exemptions for videos of hunting, fishing and trapping were also made. The penalty for violating the law now carries up to seven years in prison.

While the First Amendment is vital to our ability to engage in free expression and what has value may be considered a slippery slope, most of us would agree that materials containing anything showing the brutal torture and death of helpless animals and serves only prurient interests simply have no inherent value, and fall on the scale of obscenity or child pornography, which are afforded no constitutional protection.

“The ASPCA has long recognized the dangerous potential for animal cruelty to lead to more serious crimes. By banning crush videos, our federal government is potentially helping to protect the community from other serious crimes and sending a clear message to individuals seeking to profit from the suffering of helpless animals. This law protects both animals and free speech by focusing specifically on crush videos, which clearly have no place in our society,” said Dr. Randall Lockwood, senior vice president of ASPCA Forensic Sciences and Anti-Cruelty Projects. 

Related Stories: 

Supreme Court: Animal Cruelty Trumps Free Speech

Animal Cruelty Case Splits Roberts, Alito

U.S. Senate Votes to Ban Crush Porn

creative commons

367 comments

Julie Botsch
Julie Botsch2 years ago

Thank You.

Shanti S.
S S.3 years ago

Thank you.

Beverly G.
bev g.3 years ago

oh well done SIr. i hope this all works out and its an end to it all. Lets hope all the animals wil be ok. Its a tall order i know God bless them for putting up with evil man. Poor litle mites.

Patricia Guilhem
Patricia Guilhem3 years ago

Merci Monsieur le Président des Etats - Unis. J' espère que cette loi sera respectées.

Gysele van Santen

this article is from Dec. 2010, why am i just now seeing this.

Natasha Salgado
natasha salgado3 years ago

This is great news if in fact it's accurate...just odd as there is a very recent case involving these repulsive crush videos and it was thrown out. Hmm i'll def check into this. Thanks

rhonda dorothy knight
rhonda knight3 years ago

Confusing?? to crush or not to crush that is the question??? I am bloody getting off this sick planet.

Sun Ah C.
Sun c.3 years ago

I don't get it. Obama signed this 2010? Then what is going on with the Judge Sim Lake? He just ruled that crush videos are protected by the first amend.
http://www.care2.com/causes/animal-crush-videos-are-protected-by-the-first-amendment.html
Our country laws regarding the animals are too weak. Really pisses me off.

Nicolas Nasrallah

For once the human race had showed compassion and intolerance to senseless violence. Good for President Obama.

LILING OH
Liling O.3 years ago

Thank you for this wonderful piece of news..
At least ,this is a very good beginning to help protect more animals and the lives that hey truly deserves to have!