When Circumcisions Transmit Herpes: We Need to Talk About It

A minority circumcision practice among ultra-orthodox Jews has been identified as the likely source of infants contracting herpes, but will religious sensitivities prevent the authorities taking action? It shouldn’t, and here’s why.

A new study published this month in The Journal of Pediatric Infectious Diseases Society provides evidence that the relatively uncommon but still used practice known as metzitzah b’peh (MBP) can transmit HSV-1, or the herpes simplex virus, to infants. The procedure involves the person carrying out the circumcision, known as the mohel, placing his mouth on the circumcision wound in order to suck out a small amount of blood which he then discards.

The New York Times has a description of one particular ritual:

The mohel lifted the infant’s clothing to expose his tiny penis. With a rapid flick of a sharp two-sided scalpel, the mohel sliced off the foreskin and held it between his fingers. Then he took a sip of red wine from a cup and bent his head. He placed his lips below the cut, around the base of the baby’s penis, for a split second, creating suction, then let the wine spill from his mouth out over the wound.

The health problem with this practice is that in just the American population alone, it’s estimated that more than half have HSV, and transmitting the virus to children at such a young age has been known to cause sometimes serious health complications, and even fatalities.

Cases of transmission between 1988 and 2012 were revealed in this latest study, with researchers from Penn Medicine’s Center for Evidence-based Medicine finding 30 reported cases of HSV-1 infant transmissions from New York, Canada and Israel. The systematic review, which is the first of its kind, examined six different studies, all containing descriptive accounts or case notes of infection after circumcisions that employed direct oral suction.

The researchers believe this study gives sufficient clinical evidence to say that the oral suction practice is dangerous and, while we don’t know how many are currently practicing the technique (though some figures estimate about 3,600 local circumcisions each year in New York City), it needs further investigation and follow-up.

The practice is extremely controversial, with the majority of mohels using a glass pipette or a sponge to draw blood away from the wound instead of the oral suction technique. However, there are some who stand by the ritual and fiercely defend it as safe. Furthermore, when in 2012 the New York City health department introduced a regulation requiring parents to sign a consent form before such circumcisions could go ahead, religious groups like the Agudath Israel of America and several other orthodox groups filed a lawsuit contending that the regulation violates their religious freedom.

Ultimately, a federal judge upheld the regulation based in part on the argument that it protects the religious liberty of the parents by allowing them to give informed consent, but the authorities have not been strict about enforcing the regulation, likely because of the religious sensitivities they seem to fear offending. That said, there is rising pressure for health authorities to do more on this issue.

In addition to the publication of this recent health data, the New York City Department of Health issued a health alert on July 22, saying the department had received confirmation of two new cases of HSV infection following the “orogential suction” circumcision ritual. It adds an explanation of just how damaging contracting HSV at such a young age can be:

In both of the cases reported in July, the infant boys were born to mothers with full-term pregnancies, had normal vaginal deliveries, and underwent ritual Jewish circumcision including direct orogenital suction on day of life 8. In the first case, the baby was evaluated as an outpatient on day of life 16 for pustular lesions on the penis and genital area. HSV infection was suspected, and a genital specimen collected for viral culture. The baby was admitted to the hospital and treated with acyclovir and clindamycin. Additional specimens were collected at the hospital for HSV testing, including CSF, blood, and swabs of lesions; all were negative for HSV, and the baby was discharged on day of life 19. On day of life 22, the initial viral culture taken as an outpatient was positive for HSV (non-typable). The baby was re-admitted to the hospital for intravenous acyclovir treatment. In the second case, the baby developed lesions on his penis, left thigh, and left foot beginning on day of life 17. On day of life 19, the baby’s pediatrician collected specimens for bacterial culture, which came back negative. The next day, after the appearance of new vesicular lesions, the pediatrician suspected HSV, and the baby was admitted to the hospital. Two swabs of genital lesions and one swab of a foot lesion were positive for HSV-1 by PCR. In both cases, the location of lesions, timing of signs and symptoms, and laboratory identification of HSV are consistent with transmission of HSV during direct contact between the mouth of the ritual circumciser and the newly circumcised infant penis.

There are some mohels practicing the ritual who contend that, with proper health screening under licensed (though self-regulated) circumcision practitioners, this ritual is entirely safe — that they would even go to jail rather than stop performing the ritual which, the devout believe, is the only way to confirm a newborn son as Jewish.

The problem here seems to be that we are finding it difficult to parse exactly where the line of religious liberty should end. We’ve heard the defenses for the wider practice of circumcision,  and at the very least there are some noteworthy if not compelling positive health outcomes relating to circumcision. There are also a number of arguments against circumcision, chiefly that the practice violates the autonomy of the newborn baby boy and his right to make decisions concerning his own body when he is capable. Yet, I believe those arguments aren’t needed here.

Despite what some mohels who still carry out oral suction might claim, we have strong evidence that this particular form of circumcision practice is not only just morally fraught, but is actively dangerous to the health of the child. With this in mind, enforcing a rule that demands informed parental consent, and punishing those mohels who refuse to comply or even actively flout the rule (as has been happening), is not only justified, it seems it is entirely necessary in order to safeguard the health of the child — which, of course, should always be our first concern, even above what I am sure is sincerely held religious belief.

Photo credit: Thinkstock.

103 comments

Carlos S
Carlos S3 months ago

If you're wondering why am here or why am doing this!, i just want to show appreciation to God, and i want other persons who is suffering from this deadly illness, ( Herpes, Coronary Artery Disease (Ischemic Heart Disease), Hiv/AID, Stroke, Trachea, Bronchus, and Lung Cancers, Diarrheal Diseases, Diabetes Mellitus, Dengue, Rotavirus, Other STD and others ) maybe because of ignorance. if you see this don't ignore, i was a victim of herpes, some one introduced him to me, i wrote him, told him what i was going through, though i was not to sure he could help, because i seen other persons, or post but no good outcome, he told me he could help, like others, i got the medicine or the herb whatever you may want to call it, he didn't even charge me, to God i didn't want to use it, but i did, to God be the glory am the one sending this post post today in good health and sound mind, ..smile.. i seek for him, i didn't mind the distance so i could show appreciation, i meet with Mr Oscar, he didn't ask for anything, all he said is, 'It's God doing. I saw him treat people with different situation and problem maybe worse than yours, tell others. so am telling you today, don't ignore this, if you see this post, tell the next person who you think might need this. contact him, via
Whatsapp - +2349033303321
Email - oscargiovanni4christ@gmail.com
Hangout - oscargiovanni4christ@gmail.com
God bless you. ..sm

SEND
Sandra M.
Sandra M.7 months ago

Happiness is all i see now I never thought that I will be cured from HERPES virus again. I have been suffering from a deadly disease (HERPES) for the past 3 years now, I had spent a lot of money going from one places to another, from churches to churches, hospitals have been my home every day residence. Constant checks up have been my hobby not until this faithful day, I was searching through the internet, I saw a testimony on how DR Aba helped someone in curing his HERPES disease, quickly I copied his email which is dr.abaherbalhome@gmail.com just to give him a test I spoke to him, he asked me to do some certain things which I did, he told me that he is going to provide the herbal cure to me, which he did, then he asked me to go for medical checkup after some days after using the herbal cure, behold I was free from the deadly disease, he only asked me to post the testimony through the whole world, faithfully am doing it now, please brothers and sisters, he is great, I owe him in return. if you are having a similar problem just email him on ( dr.abaherbalhome@gmail.com ) or you can whatsApp his mobile number on +2348107155060

SEND
Olivia L.
Olivia Labout a year ago

I am so Happy to be writing this article in here, i am here to explore blogs and forum about the wonderful and most safe cure for HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS . I was positive to the deadly Virus called HERPES and i lost hope because i was rejected even by my closet friends. i searched online to know and inquire about cure for HERPES and i saw Dr Alli testimony online on how he was cured so many persons from Herpes Disease so i decided to contact the great herbalist because i know that nature has the power to heal everything. i contacted him to know how he can help me and he told me never to worry that he will help me with the natural herbs from God! after 2 days of contacting him, he told me that the cure has been ready and he sent it to me via DHL and it got to me after 14 days! i used the medicine as he instructed me (MORNING and EVENING) and i was cured! its really like a dream but i''m so happy! that’s the reason i decided to also add more comment of Him so that more can be saved just like me! and if you need his help,Email him on allispellhelp1@gmail.com or his cell number: 2348100772528

SEND
Janet J.
Janet J.about a year ago

All thanks to Dr Oboite for curing my HEPATITIS C VIRUS with his herbal medicine, i do not have much to say but with all my life i will for ever be grateful to him and thank God Almighty for using Dr Oboite to reach me when i thought it was all over, today i am happy with my life again after the doctor have confirmed I am NEGATIVE,i have never in my life believed that HEPATITIS C VIRUS could be cured by herbal medicine. so i want to use this means to reach other persons who have this disease by testifying about Dr Oboite that all hope is not lost yet, try and contact him by any means for any kind of disease with his email: droboiteherbalcurehome@gmail.com or call and whatsapp him on 2348054265852 He will help you and his herbal medication is sure.
he has the cure for all this disease as he told me and it listed.
GENITAL WARTS
EPILEPSY
GENPILENCIN
HIV AIDS
DIABETES
STROKE
EXPANDS OF PENIS AND BREAST
HERPES.
SYPHILIS
CANCER
HIRE BLOOD PRESSURES.
AND BODY BOILS.
THANK TO YOU ALL FOR YOUR TIME OF READING MY TESTIMONY AND MOST ESPECIALLY YOU
Dr Oboite I PRAY TO GOD TO NEVER LET ME AND MY FAMILY FORGET YOU IN OUR LIFE.

SEND
Susan L.
Susan L.about a year ago

After reading other comment from people who Dr Fred Has cured using herbal remedy , i came to a conclusion to order his herbal remedy for Herpes using his whatsapp contact 2348139097317 so i can get a solution for me and my husband because we have been infected with herpes for some years now. with just few weeks of taking Dr Fred herbal remedy , Me and my Husband are totally cured from Herpes which i ask you to contact him through his contact; www.drfredherbalcenter.webs.com , Whatsapp ... 2348139097317 , drfredherbalcuringcenter@yahoo.com . please dont write to other herbal doctor because when i did , i did not receive any package from them but Dr Fred delivered as promised. he is the only herbal doctor to be trusted

SEND
Past Member
Past Member 1 years ago

My name is Rechard Joel i am from USA, I am here to give my testimony about a doctor who helped me in my life. I was infected with HERPES in 2014, i went to many hospitals for cure but there was no solution, so I was thinking how can I get a solution out so that my body can be okay. One day I was in the river side thinking where I can go to get solution. so a lady walked to me her name is kutrila telling me why am I so sad and i open up all to
her telling her my problem,that i have herpes genital she told me that she can help me out, she introduce me to a doctor who uses herbal medication to cure HERPES and gave me his email, so i mail him. He told me all the things I need to do and also give me instructions to take, which I followed properly. Before I knew what is happening after two weeks the HERPES that was in my body got vanished . so if you are you are having herpes or any kind of disease listed below and you also want cure, you can also email him at: drojemenspellhome@hotmail.com or call him 2349052116214, you will also get healed with your illness,if you are having any type of this disease or infection kindly email doctor Ojemen for cure

1 cancer
2 stroke,
3 HIV
4 herpes
5 ulcer
6 Hepatitis disease
7 Diabities

kindly email doctor Ojemen for you own cure if you have any disease listed above via :drojemenspellhome@hotmail.com or call him 2349052116214

SEND
Past Member
Past Member 1 years ago

My name is Rechard Joel i am from USA, I am here to give my testimony about a doctor who helped me in my life. I was infected with HERPES in 2014, i went to many hospitals for cure but there was no solution, so I was thinking how can I get a solution out so that my body can be okay. One day I was in the river side thinking where I can go to get solution. so a lady walked to me her name is kutrila telling me why am I so sad and i open up all to
her telling her my problem,that i have herpes genital she told me that she can help me out, she introduce me to a doctor who uses herbal medication to cure HERPES and gave me his email, so i mail him. He told me all the things I need to do and also give me instructions to take, which I followed properly. Before I knew what is happening after two weeks the HERPES that was in my body got vanished . so if you are you are having herpes or any kind of disease listed below and you also want cure, you can also email him at: drojemenspellhome@hotmail.com or call him 2349052116214, you will also get healed with your illness,if you are having any type of this disease or infection kindly email doctor Ojemen for cure

1 cancer
2 stroke,
3 HIV
4 herpes
5 ulcer
6 Hepatitis disease
7 Diabities

kindly email doctor Ojemen for you own cure if you have any disease listed above via :drojemenspellhome@hotmail.com or call him 2349052116214

SEND
Barbara P.
Barbara P.1 years ago

Been Herpes is just like been through hell; well special thanks to God almighty for using DR.OKOROM the greatest HERBAL CURE in curing my Herpes disease. I was diagnosed of this disease in the year 2010. Thou I was taking my medications buy I was not myself. Until last two weeks. My friend came to me and told me that he saw many testimonies on how a greatest HERBAL CURE cured people Herpes disease. Thou I never believe in HERBAL, I said to myself "seen is believing" I took his name and searched it on GOOGLE, I saw many testimonies myself. Quickly, I copied his email I emailed him, he gave me a form to fill which I did, then he called me and told me that his gods required some items in which he will use in HERBAL a curing on me. And i told him to get the listed items needed to prepare my cure because by then i have little faith in him, few hours later he called me and told me he is through preparing the cure. so he send it to me I got my parcel, it was a herbal cure as described by DR. OKOROM took the herbal cure and after taking it for a week and some days. He told me to go for check up, I went to the hospital and had a test,and i was cured. Quickly I called him and tell him what happened he congratulated me. I promise to tell the world about him. You can contact via email dr.okoromspellhome@live.com or http://dr-okorom.webs.com/

SEND
Tammy H.
Tammy H.1 years ago

I am here to give my testimony about Dr Ikuku who helped me in my life, i want to inform the public how i was cured from (HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS) by Dr Ikuku,i visited different hospital but they gave me list of drugs like Famvir, Zovirax, and Valtrex which is very expensive to treat the symptoms and never cured me. I was browsing through the Internet searching for remedy on HERPES and i saw comment of people talking about how Dr Ikuku cured them. when i contacted him he gave me hope and send a Herbal medicine to me that i took and it seriously worked for me, my HERPES result came out negative. I am so happy as i am sharing this testimony. My advice to you all who thinks that their is no cure for herpes that is Not true just contact him and get cure from Dr Ikuku healing spell cure of all kinds of sickness you may have.Remember delay in treatment leads to death email him @ {Ikukuhealingspell@outlook.com} or call him 2348147673679 Robert Becker from USA

SEND
Thibuat Louis Sydney

how i get my herpes cure with the help of doctor okunade herbal treatment.contact him via 2348110651073

I prefer HIV than HERPES.i contacted viral diseases caused by herpes viruses,many people never have symptoms even though they are carrying the virus. i never knew that i have herpes until i notice Blisters and ulceration on my cervix,feeling Pain when urinating,high temperature ,feeling unwell,Cold sores around the mouth and Vaginal discharge.when i notice it then i went to hospital for test, and the doctor told me that i have herpes! i was crying because of the pain and itching and the doctor also told me that there is know cure.when in got home, i told my husband about it and he has know bad reaction toward it.he always give me hope that some days i will get the cure.i was at work when my husband called me that he saw a post on the internet posted by a woman from USA on how she was cure from herpes with the help of a herbal doctor called doctor okunade. so i ask him if he has the herbal doctor contact he told me yes, i tell him to send me the herbal doctor email.so i collect the herbal doctor email and mail him about my herpes that i need cure.he reply my mail,and told me to send him my details about my self.after that he told me that his herbal medicine is free,that all he need from me is to provide the items needed for the preparation,wish i did.after few days he send the herbal medicine to me and tell me how to use.after few days i found out that the pain and i

SEND