START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
2,430,771 people care about Environment & Wildlife

Would You Go to a Zoo to See a Squirrel?

Would You Go to a Zoo to See a Squirrel?

Last week was a tough one for zoos. A Sumatran tiger cub, the first to be born at the London Zoo in 17 years, was found dead at the edge of the pool in its den, just two weeks after it was born and before keepers could determine its sex. In the Dickerson Park Zoo in Springfield, Missouri, a senior zookeeper,†John Bradford, was killed after being crushed by Patience, a 41-year-old Asian elephant. Tian Tian, the Edinburgh Zoo’s giant panda, appears to have suffered a miscarriage six months after she was artificially inseminated.

These and other incidents have led some to ask if we need a completely different model for zoos. Would endangered wild animals be better off in nature preserves in their native habitats, though they could be subject to killing by poachers? Should there only be zoos with small and preferably local animals, as Patrick Burnham recently†wrote in The Guardian?

For animals who are injured and in need of rehabilitation, and who wouldn’t be able to survive in the wild, zoos can provide much needed care.

In recent years, many zoos around the world have seemed to be throwing most of their attention, and resources, in acquiring, caring for and promoting endangered animals such as tigers, elephants and pandas. The London Zoo had just unveiled its £3.6m Tiger Territory, specifically designed to foster breeding in a critically endangered species, in March 2013. Tian Tian and a male panda, Yang Guang, were flown from China to Edinburgh and cost around £600,000 a year to rent.†Keeping the pandas is costing the Edinburgh Zoo plenty: pandas are picky eaters and their staple food, fresh bamboo, must be imported in vast quantities as it isn’t exactly native to Scotland.

After the two pandas arrived, the Edinburgh Zoo indeed saw the numbers of visitors go up by 50 percent following “several difficult years.” Visitor numbers also rose in August after the zoo announced that Tian Tian had likely conceived. But then, as it turned out, Tian Tian miscarried and is now “in such a bad way that her exhibit has been temporarily closed to the public,” writes Burnham.

Henry Nicholls, author of a study of captive pandas,†Way of the Panda,†suggests that the Edinburgh Zoo, too eager to be the site of the first panda birth in the U.K.,†”issued little detailed information [about Tian Tian's possible pregnancy] but stoked the story by drip-feeding the media and raising expectations among zoo visitors and the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland’s members.”

Whether or not the zoo “hyped up the pregnancy for commercial and prestige reasons,”†Burnham†argues that “there is no place in a modern zoo for large mammals, or birds, who naturally live in large territories.” Captive breeding programs, he points out, work best with animals in the countries that are “close to where the species naturally live” as do (for reasons that are all too obvious) wild release programs.

That is, zoos can say they are keeping pandas and other endangered animals to help breed them for conservation purposes and to serve as “ambassadors,” but the reality is that they “are in the entertainment business, these beasts are box office gold, and they guarantee a flow of visitors into their cafes and gift shops.” Burnham contends that zoos would be best off not offering up the equivalent of yesterday’s dancing bears and instead

“…devoted their talents and energy to enabling young people to directly encounter small creatures, and made the most of the smaller mammals, reptiles, insects and birds that exist more happily in a confined space.”

Such places already exist in the form of wildlife centers, where visitors, and children in particular, can have “up close and personal” interactions with animals.

I do remember that, on visits years ago to the Oakland Zoo, my strongest, and fondest, memories are of the baby goats in the petting zoo, my sister and I marveling at how high they could stand on two legs to get at the goat food we had bought. In contrast, the monkey house (a huge cage around a tree-like structure and a concrete floor) at the zoo’s front entrance was sinister and unnerving.

In our age, in which modern transportation and science have made it possible to transport animals anywhere, it seems unlikely that zoos will cease to import exotic and rare animals. Are all the billions spent on creating naturalistic “territories,” “enclosures,” etc. — †fancier cages †for captive animals — really worth it?

As for the business of zoos, would you go to a zoo to see an animal that visits your backyard?

Read more: , , , , , , , ,

Photo from Thinkstock

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

182 comments

+ add your own
3:41AM PDT on Jun 22, 2014

thanks for sharing

9:34AM PST on Nov 16, 2013

i live 20 mins from the largest walk through zoo in the world.. the NC ZOO.. they do great things. changes could be made (and are being made) but over all good zoos are a good thing, esp with their breeding co ops and programs

12:17PM PST on Nov 6, 2013

The key in this debate is SAFETY...Free is great, but very dangerous right now.

8:05AM PST on Nov 3, 2013

thank you

9:13AM PDT on Nov 1, 2013

no and i don't agree with a zoo either. animals should not be locked up in a cage.

11:10AM PDT on Oct 29, 2013

thanks for sharing

10:23AM PDT on Oct 29, 2013

No. Off and on, I see one in the garden.

4:09AM PDT on Oct 29, 2013

Nope.

2:34AM PDT on Oct 29, 2013

Thanks for sharing

11:18AM PDT on Oct 28, 2013

Close down zoos and circuses, and provide SAFE sanctuaries for wild animals in their natural habitat. Problem is the poachers, how can we protect wild animals from them.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

I'm really glad she's been able to hang on and be vocal about this horrible issue. Too many people have…

And he is trying to cast the blame away from himself.

Living in the woods and off the land is WONDERFUL- but WHOSE land will you live off of without "poaching"…

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches ancient Greek, Latin and Classics at Saint Peter's University in New Jersey.... more
Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.