START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
2,580,040 people care about Environment & Wildlife

Your Phone vs. Your Refrigerator: Which Uses More Electricity?

Your Phone vs. Your Refrigerator: Which Uses More Electricity?

After concluding that I’d dropped my aging smart phone one too many times, I upgraded to a newer model last month. While appreciating how much faster my new phone is, I’ve been, like many others, displeased at how much faster the battery runs out of power. A report purporting to show that your cell phone uses more electricity than your refrigerator got my attention.

As my new phone can do so many more things than the first “slab” cell phone I acquired at the end of the previous century, it seemed to make sense that it would use far more electricity. But a closer examination of the data and methods of the “phone needs more energy than a fridge” report (pdf) suggests that the intriguing claim is just that.

The claims of the report, “The Cloud Begins With Coal,” rest on mismatched comparisons of data, writes Jonathan Koomey of the Lawrence Berkeley National Lab in the ending summary of an extensive analysis on Think Progress:

One way to support the claim that the electricity use associated with an iPhone is as large (or twice as large) as a refrigerator is to combine the high electricity intensity of 2G/3G cell phone networks with the largest plausible data downloads from 4G networks…. Another way is to use 3G electricity intensities and exaggerate data flows by a factor of 12 (as [the report's author, Mark P. Mills of the Digital Power Group] has done). In either case, the electricity intensity and data flow numbers are inconsistent and incomparable, so the results are nonsensical.

Koomey emphasizes that, in comparing criteria like data flow or electricity, you have to keep in mind that there are “large changes over time [even over a year or two] in the efficiency of information technology (IT) equipment, including mobile phones and the supporting systems.”

Newer devices that use 4G are more efficient in their use of energy than older ones using 2G or 3G. The networks that devices run on have also become more energy efficient so that “simple averages of ‘typical cell phones’ will mislead you.”

In addition, Mills underestimates the energy usage of new refrigerators, Koomey points out. Mills says that these use 350 kilowatt hours/year, without referencing the source of that figure. Citing colleagues at the Lawrence Lab who have studied energy efficiency in refrigerators for thirty years, Koomey says that the average new refrigerator in the U.S. in 2011 used 574 kilowatt hours/year.

With statements about how today’s global digital economy uses as much electricity as it took to light up the planet in 1985, Mills’ report does serve to remind us that, in the effort to live a more sustainable lifestyle, we have become more dependent than ever on wireless technology and on devices that we never turn off.

We absolutely still need to push for the use of wind power, solar power and other forms of green energy; for ways to build energy-efficient structures like those of the passive house movement, in which houses are built with unusually thick walls and other features such that they make “efficient use of the sun, internal heat sources and heat recovery” and require very little energy to cool and heat.

As Koomey underscores, we also have to be careful when reviewing reports about technical issues and look beyond an artfully worded notion (phones that use more energy than refrigerators — can that be true?), review the facts and figures and realize that researchers, knowing how central digital devices are to our life, are working to make them more efficient.

Read more: , , , , , , , , ,

Photo from Thinkstock

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

103 comments

+ add your own
9:26PM PST on Feb 18, 2014

Noted

6:04PM PDT on Sep 11, 2013

I pay more attention about electricity.

8:10AM PDT on Sep 6, 2013

ty

6:29AM PDT on Sep 5, 2013

Think about it, folks: if your phone actually used as much energy as a refrigerator you ought to be able to run your refrigerator off a cell phone battery for seveal hours. Does that seem realistic?

7:11AM PDT on Sep 4, 2013

Not an issue Cathleen, because I don't have a disgusting coffee maker in my house. Coffee is a vile, odoriferous product, unhealthy, and causes exploitation of the poor in countries where it is grown, soil depletion, etc. It causes litter, both visual (Stupid Starsucks everywhere) and actual (losers throwing cups on the ground) and has no use in a civilized society...

1:40AM PDT on Sep 4, 2013

I immediately dismissed the notion that a cell phone could use as much energy as a refrigerator, because I know that the makers of digital stuff that stays on all the time are trying to improve efficiency with each new generation. Now here's a real shocker that is absolutely true: what uses more electricity, your fridge or your coffee maker? Your coffee maker only runs for an hour or two a day, or you couldn't afford to pay your electric bill.

5:19PM PDT on Sep 3, 2013

My cell phone is a five-year-old Katana flip phone (so is my husband's), and as long as I can find replacement batteries for it when the one it came with finally dies, I'll still use it. All I do is make calls on it and I also do texting (mostly to my husband) as well as receive texts from friends and also whenever my firehouse gets a call (VERY useful, especially when I'm out of the house and don't have the scanner on!). I don't have a smart phone, and I definitely don't need one.

Oh, and we still have a landline phone. Not only does this come in handy during power failures or storms that knock out the cell tower on the ridge, it's also the phone our kids make and receive calls from, so there's less of their bugging us for a cell phone (which they DEFINITELY don't need at ages 6 and 11 anyway!).

Our fridge was replaced three years ago with an Energy Star model (along with our stove and dishwasher, the latter of which is also Energy Star-rated), but our cell phones still use less electricity than the fridge!

5:05PM PDT on Sep 3, 2013

I had a cell phone when my Mom was sick.When she passed away I gave my cell phone to my son since I had no more use for it. I have a land line and that's enough for me. At 66 I don't need any i phone or i pods. I want to be free of high tech. My internet is good enough.

12:34PM PDT on Sep 3, 2013

As the proud owner of absolutely NO cellphones ever I am 100% sure that my fridge uses more energy than my phones.
Now if the fridge didn't have to work so hard to combat the high temps caused by climate change, I'd be happier!

10:46AM PDT on Sep 3, 2013

TY

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

Thanks Judy for providing the update on this. Lethal intervention is not the way to go and other choices…

Oh gee, if only there might be some way of designing him a prosthesis....Meanwhile, blessings to the…

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches and writes about ancient Greek and Latin and is Online Advocacy and Marketing... more
ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.