my care2
make a difference
healthy & green living: more than 5,000 ways to enhance your life

customize your free newsletter

Customize your Healthy & Green Living newsletter now


Clutter and Depression

posted by Melissa Breyer Apr 9, 2009 4:42 pm

The Link Between Clutter and Depression?
No formal studies have been done on the link between clutter and depression, but when I look at the symptoms of depression–this list from the National Institute of Mental Health–I see direct cause and affect relationships, which I have added following the symptom.

• Difficulty concentrating, remembering details, and making decisions: Causes difficulty in sorting, organizing and prioritizing.
• Fatigue and decreased energy: Maintaining order takes energy, it’s as simple as that.
• Feelings of guilt, worthlessness, and/or helplessness: Hard to find the desire or wherewithal to conquer a mess when feeling helpless.
• Insomnia, early-morning wakefulness, or excessive sleeping: Again, maintaining order takes energy.
• Irritability, restlessness: It’s nearly impossible to tackle a tedious sorting project when irritable and restless.
• Overeating or appetite loss: Both weight gain or hunger-induced lethargy are not conducive to cleaning.
• Persistent aches or pains, headaches, cramps, or digestive problems that do not ease even with treatment: Pain makes you want to lay down, not sit at a desk and go through a mountain of paper.
• Persistent sad, anxious, or “empty” feelings: The bottom line, it takes enthusiasm and determination to battle clutter.

I’m not suggesting that clutter be officially added to the list of symptoms for depression (I also understand that there is a broad range of types of depression)–but looking at the ways in which symptoms of depression can impact the potential to clutter, I don’t know how people suffering from depression can avoid disorganization.

Next: Clutter and Your Health

More on Feng Shui & Organizing (80 articles available)
More from Melissa Breyer (495 articles available)

42 comments

42 comments

add your comment »
42 comments add your comment
Lynn Miller

Is there anyone out there who has to have things neat and organizaned in order to have a clear mind and be at peace? I don't have OCD but find I have to routinely clean or purge things to keep from feeling I am being covered up or my living space 'threatened.' Not a clean freak but I do like my house to look nice and be neat.

Shelley Cattral

I too can relate....when my ex-husband left me and my daughter was taken away from me I was left with everything...I was overwhelmed by it all. I was in a two bedroom house and had to move to a bachelor. I had to downsize and move at the same time which was devistating for me. Whatever was left that I couldn't sale went to charity. What I kept what I thought I would need and I put into storage. However the rest I had brought with me to where I live. I still have too much clutter here with me to deal with and this has effected my depression. That has effect my ability to deal with my clutter. However, I am slowly dealing with this by forcing myself to get rid of stuff I no longer need, which seems to help. So I do believe that the two are so interlink with each other that you have to break the cycle somehow.

Christine S.

For step by step instructions on how to start to clear the clutter... even when it seems overwhelming... try this: http:/www.organize-more-stress-less.com/De-clutter-One-Room-at-a-Time.html

Julia Harrington

to elaborate further...i don't know about clutter contributing to depression or a symptom of depression..but i DO know..as someone who has suffered from depression..that if you have been landed on your butt for days at a time with depression..staring at piles of newspapers, and laundry etc, all over the house, does not help..it just you feel more helpless and overwhelmed. I am finding that a well run and organized envoirnment, is just better for my state of mind..and if i have several days where i cannot make myself get up and do something..i simply do'nt have a mountain of work to do afterwards.

Julia Harrington

i love this article.i absolutely agree that clutter will contribute to feelings of stress and being overwhelmed. Two years ago, i moved from a tiny 2 bedroom one-level bungalow, to a huge 4 bedroom 3 level house.i thought i was cluttered back then and my problems were due to lack of storage space. Now in my house that is 4 times as large i still have stuff spilling out of every closet and drawer and every flat surface has clutter.I was spending every weekend trying to tidy up.It was exhausting.I have now come to the realization that i have way more stuff than i need.I have started going through one room at a time,keeping only what i need and giving away the rest.The problem was not my house , it was me.I have "adopted" furniture and dishes when my mother-in-law passed away, and also stuff from another friend who died..and i have not been able to let go of this stuff for sentimental reasons..but i finally have realized that if my friends things are a burden for me ..and i'm spending all my free time taking care of them..i am sure this is not what they would want for my life..much better to pass them on to those who really do need them and give the stuff good homes.

Vural K.

thanks...you...
Kabin
Konteyner

Beth Hartford-DeRoos

Dorothy you asked what about about the clutter being a symptom of depression, not the cause? Yes, that could be the case. Often one gets situational depression based on their physical situation. Be it a death or illness which then results in a person not being able to do as much and things pile up. Literally. Then they feel overwhelmed and even more depressed. It almost becomes a viscous circle for some. This is where biting the bullet has helped me. Just dig in and clean is what I do. But for someone that would be horrid!!

One book by Mike Nelson titled Stop Clutter From Stealing Your Life is the ONLY book out of all the books I have on the subject of clutter that understands how hiring someone to come in and deal with the clutter, is as helpful as someone (as Kristy Alley noted) coming in to make the food, hire the fitness trainer etc, and then after you have met the goal they ::::::::poof:::::::::: and you go back to where you began and often worse. People have to find what works for them.


~Beth~

Lisa Dickison

It goes both ways. It's a downward spiral.

Dorothy D.

How about the clutter being a symptom of depression, not the cause?

Beth Hartford-DeRoos

Clutter can indeed acerbate depression. Ten years ago I really got serious about clutter and aside from finding what I needed when I needed the item I also saved big $$$$$$. Simply because I was no longer buying replacements for things I knew I had but could not find. When I decluttered I actually found a half dozen sets of measuring spoons and cups, knives I forgot I had, can openers, and lord knows how many sets of silverware.

~Beth~

Please enter your comment.
Or, log in with your
Facebook account:
1500 characters remaining

who's talking about this story?

Disclaimer: Care2.com does not warrant and shall have no liability for information provided in this newsletter or on Care2.com. Each individual person, fabric, or material may react differently to a particular suggested use. It is recommended that before you begin to use any formula, you read the directions carefully and test it first. Should you have any health care-related questions or concerns, please call or see your physician or other health care provider.

1012022

Copyright © 2009 Care2.com, inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved