Is Geothermal Energy a Good Option for My House?

Geothermal energy is pretty amazing: by circulating water through a series of pipes under your house, you bring the warmth of the earth up in the winter, and force heat and humidity down during the summer. As the geothermal system (also known as a ground source heat pump — which is technically more accurate, because this form of heating and cooling captures solar heat trapped in the earth’s surface rather than tapping geologically active areas deep beneath the Earth’s crust for heat) constantly counterbalances in sync with the seasons, you save a ton of money on energy costs, and you’re not using very much energy beyond that needed to handle the pumping system. For those two reasons, you might be considering a geothermal installation in your new home or during a remodel.

Alternative energy is fantastic, but smart applications of alternative energy are critical. While geothermal heating and cooling might be just what the environment ordered for your house, that’s not always the case. We’re going to step you through the decisionmaking process you should use to decide whether this is the best option. If it’s not, don’t worry: a San Francisco HVAC contractor will have plenty of other environmentally-friendly ideas for you!

The first question is how much land you have. You need enough land to have a serious geothermal trenching system, and it needs to be easy to access and work with a backhoe. If you live on a tiny lot, geothermal systems aren’t for you. If your acreage is steep, rocky, or otherwise hard to work, putting in a geothermal system might be more than it’s worth. And remember: the bigger the space you’re heating and cooling, the more trenching you will need.

Cost is another consideration. You should expect to pay for the trenches and pipes, the heat pump (around $10,000), and other sundry components. You may find yourself spending between $20,000 and $50,000, depending on the location and specifics of the system — and it’s worth talking to several contractors to get competing bids and enhance your understanding of what’s available. With those numbers available, sit down and do the math.

How much do you spend on heating and cooling annually? How long will it take for the geothermal system to pay for itself? Are there rebates and other incentives available to cut the cost? Do you need to replace a failing heating and cooling system, in which case you’d be spending money either way, or do you just want to retrofit to be more efficient? Where is the electricity to run the pump coming from?

Make sure your system will pay for itself economically. If it doesn’t, geothermal heating isn’t right for you at the moment. That doesn’t mean this won’t change: when you do need to replace your existing system, or when prices change, it could be the far superior choice.

Remember that installing a geothermal system will involve: ripping up part of the landscaping, installing a pump that runs on electricity, and possibly replacing your existing heating system with forced air, assuming you don’t have it already. These can be costly and/or undesirable endeavors that might prove to be barriers to making the jump to geothermal…so it’s a good thing there are many other options out there.

Katie Marks writes for Networx.com. This article originally appeared here.

79 comments

Carrie-Anne Brown
Carrie-Anne Brownabout a year ago

thanks for sharing :)

Kamia T.
Kamia T.2 years ago

My friend who had only a heat pump in her house in Oregon hated it. It worked find when the temperature wasn't extremely cold or extremely hot, but it certainly had its limits, and once the outside temp exceeded those, it was like having nothing at all. In this winter's below 0 chills we've been having, I'll keep my wood-burning stove any time.

PJ Chartrand
PJ C.2 years ago

One of our neighbours when I lived in the country had a heat pump, seemed to work well except the house and their clothes always smelled musty. I suspect that was because they never opened the windows even during mild weather. Not that useful during weather events like an ice storm but luckily they had a neighbour with a cook stove etc.

Eva H.
Eva H.2 years ago

We have a ground source heat pump - it seems a miracle but it keeps us warm all through our long, cold winters.

Alexandra Ekdahl
Alexandra Ekdahl2 years ago

Thank you

John chapman
John chapman2 years ago

Not a viable poption for either of our houses.

At the lake, we hit solid rock at about 18".

At the beach, we have almost the perfect climate for a regular heat pump.

Spring Green
.2 years ago

Certainly something to consider. Maybe the costs will come down soon. I hope.

Sue H.
Sue H.2 years ago

Thanks for this information.

Brad Hunter
Brad H.2 years ago

thanks

Val M.
Val M.2 years ago

Noted