Real Girl Power in Pop Culture

Last night, my fiancÚ and I had a conversation about the relative lack of female superheroes. Yes, we have Wonder Woman and Bat Girl, but they are just cheap knock-offs of Superman and Batman. There are many intriguing female action heroes – like Storm from X-Men, Lara Croft from Tomb Raider, and Max from Dark Angel. But, while these characters are portrayed as smart and capable, they are also portrayed as sex bombs. And not in a way that affirms the power and significance of female sexuality. No, these characters are scantily clad to appeal to men.

There have been some positive female role models on television and in the movies: for example, Dana Scully from The X-Files, as well as Buffy from Buffy the Vampire Slayer and, when it comes to animated movies, Princess Fiona from Shrek. But these characters are vastly outnumbered by the Storms and the Lara Crofts of the pop culture world.

What we should take away from this observation is that what seems like “girl power” on the surface might just be a marketing ploy that is actually disempowering for women. And it’s not just true in the case of movies and television. Remember the Spice Girls? They sang about girl power while dressed up as sexist stereotypes. And more recently, girls and women have had perhaps even fewer role models than we have in the past. Real girl power is about believing in oneself and loving and appreciating everything it is to be a woman.

 

Related:
Yoga Teacher Barbie: Empowering or Ludicrous?
Hair as a Metaphor for Life
The Meaning of Marriage

25 comments

Laura M.
Past Member 4 years ago

Thank you. I'm glad other people think critically about the messages sent to us via mainstream fiction. Almost all the counter-examples given in the comments are from fiction that, while widely consumed, is either sort of on the fringe, or decidedly NOT gender-neutral in its marketing (Katniss being a notable exception obvs).

Alicia N.
Alicia N.4 years ago

We, women, are the only ones who are disempowering ourselves not tv or men.

Rika S.
Rika S.4 years ago

Great article, thanks

Danuta Watola
Danuta Watola4 years ago

Thanks for the article.

Neil A.
Neil A.4 years ago

I did like Dark Angel But because Max? rode a powerful motorbike & showed great abilities, admittedly she was attractive, but she was succesful in spite of this not because of it.!

Carol M.
Carol Manda4 years ago

There are strong female role models galore in current youth/teen lit. In addition to Katniss in the "Hunger Games" series, check out Maximum Ride in the series by James Patterson, Tris in "Divergent" by Veronica Roth. They are strong girls - Max is the leader of her group, and Tris is not considered "pretty" but she's a force to contend with! Plus, these girls' moms ROCK. Other examples aplenty in the currently popular dystopian genre of fiction. "The City of Ember", "Incarceron", "Matched", and others. We just have to decide to read instead of paying homage to the boob tube. The kids are making these books popular!

Betsy M.
Betsy M.4 years ago

The character options available for females are much narrower than the options for male characters. True for MMORP Game characters as well.

Cheryl B.
Cheryl B.4 years ago

thanks for the info

Cheryl B.
Cheryl B.4 years ago

thanks

Winn Adams
Winn Adams4 years ago

Women have to believe in themselves and that they are not just valuable because they are pretty or sexy. Remember beauty fades and dumb is forever. Get educated, investigate what you're interested in, live on your own for a while after school and always believe in yourself.