START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good

Study: Instinctively, People Are Generous

  • 1 of 2
Study: Instinctively, People Are Generous

By Emily Sohn, Discovery Channel

Without thinking, people act with more generosity than if they take some time to weigh the logic of their behavior.

Contrary to popular and pessimistic thought, the discovery suggests that, by default, our gut instincts lead us to be more helpful than selfish. That may explain why door-knocking and phone solicitations, which demand immediate responses, tend to bring in bigger donations than statistics-laden e-mail messages or direct mail, which puts people in a rational frame of mind and allows them to think for a while before deciding whether to give.

Likewise, people who commit heroic acts — like the man who jumped onto New York City subway tracks in front of an oncoming train to save a young man having a seizure five years ago — often make split-second decisions to do the altruistic thing.

PHOTOS: Faces of Our Ancestors

“If you look at testimony of a lot of people like that describing their decisions, you can see they are heavily weighted towards intuitive thinking,” said David Rand, a behavior scientist at Yale who conducted the new study while at Harvard. “People say, ‘I didn’t think about it. I just did it.’”

In a 2011 best-selling book called “Thinking, Fast and Slow,” Nobel-Prize winning economist Daniel Kahneman argued that a lot of decision-making comes out of a tension between two types of brain processes. On the one hand, we have quick and intuitive thoughts, which are often emotional. The other mode is slower, allowing for more controlled and calculated thinking.

Until now, Rand said, researchers had yet to combine the two kinds of thought processes in a way that explained how people actually behaved.

“You could imagine either that people are intuitively selfish, that our default is to be nasty and that the way to get ourselves to do the right thing is through willpower and restraining selfish impulses,” Rand said. “On the other hand, our automatic response might be to be predisposed toward cooperation, then to stop and think and realize that it’s in my selfish interest to be a jerk.”

To find out which scenario best explains how our minds work, Rand and colleagues conducted a series of 10 experiments that compared how people behaved when they made decisions either instantly or after a pause.

In the first experiment, people were put into groups of four and given 40 cents. Participants could choose how much of it they wanted to contribute to a common pot, which would be doubled and divided evenly among all four people. No one learned how much the others gave until the donations were completed.

In this scenario, the most lucrative strategy is to be as selfish as possible. But if everyone is generous, the group as a whole can do better.

People who made the quickest decisions about how much to give, the team reports today in the journal Nature, contributed the most cash to the common good. Those who acted in less than 10 seconds gave nearly 70 percent of their money, while those who took longer put in just over half of their original sum.

In follow-up experiments, people who were asked to recall memories that put them in an intuitive frame of mind contributed more than people who were primed to think reflectively.

NEWS: Chimpanzees Not As Selfish As We Thought

And people who were randomly assigned to make their decisions more quickly gave more than people who were told to wait 10 seconds before putting in their money.


Next: what are the implications?

  • 1 of 2

Read more: Community, Do Good, Life, News & Issues, , , , , ,

have you shared this story yet?

go ahead, give it a little love


+ add your own
3:57PM PDT on Sep 26, 2012


2:26PM PDT on Sep 24, 2012


on the generosity topic from Paramhansa Yogananda:

"It is a popular error to think that unselfishness involves tormenting sacrifice and loss. Unselfishness is the only lasting way to secure individual prosperity."

"Make service your goal
People must also realize that all work and business activities are for the sole purpose of serving others. Without this understanding, strenuous work and business activity produces nervousness and greed for money. Make service to mankind, rather than money, the goal of all your activities and you will see your life change for the better."

10:02AM PDT on Sep 21, 2012

Hmm. My sandbox experience doesn't support this. Kiddos were always bickering over stuff or toys.

2:53AM PDT on Sep 21, 2012

I don't see how the 40 cent experiment can be conclusive since the participants were given the 40 cents, it didn't come out of their own pocket, but I do wonder why they all didn't put in the whole 40 cents.

12:38AM PDT on Sep 21, 2012

Thank you.

11:00AM PDT on Sep 20, 2012


8:28AM PDT on Sep 20, 2012



7:45AM PDT on Sep 20, 2012

to bad a lot of animals do not act like this. do zebras?

7:09AM PDT on Sep 20, 2012

Thank you.

7:06AM PDT on Sep 20, 2012

good post, thanks.... true

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

people are talking

This was an awesome read! Way to go, David :-) Veganism is the best way to reduce the demand for ani…

Worthwhile. TY.

Thanks for the article, biking is also great.

C'mon....really? GTFOH!!!!


Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.

site feedback


Problem on this page? Briefly let us know what isn't working for you and we'll try to make it right!