3 Studies Link Common Pesticides to Bee Decline (Slideshow)

Care2 Earth Month: Back to Basics

This year, Care2 decided to expand Earth Day into Earth Month, since there is so much to explore when it comes to the environment. Every day in April, we’ll have a post about some of the most important topics for the environment, exploring and explaining the basics. It’s a great tool to help you get started with helping the environment — or help explain it to others. See the whole series here.

Where have all the bees gone?

What is causing colony collapse disorder, when hives suddenly lose most of their worker bee population, with very few dead bees found nearby and only the queen and brood remaining?

Bees are worth about 1.8 billion pounds (about $2.9 billion) a year in the U.K., according to new research about the cost of hand-pollinating the many crops that bees do so for free. As Damian Carrington writes in the Guardian, hand-pollination is already a necessity in places like China’s pear orchards while in the U.S. bees are “routinely trucked around… to compensate for the loss of their wild cousins.” In the U.K., Carrington describes a virtual “bee-calypse”: “Half the UK’s honey bees kept in managed hives have gone, wild honey bees are close to extinction and solitary bees are declining in more than half the place they have been studied.”

Carrington cites the loss of meadows full of flowers and parasites and diseases. But pesticides are routinely cited as a factor and three recent scientific studies offer compelling evidence linking pesticides to global declines in bee populations.

BEES 29-01-2007 005

Related Care2 Coverage

Parasite Drives Honey Bees to Doomed Zombie Flight?

Study Links Honey Bee Deaths to Corn Insecticide

Mild Winter, Early Spring: Bad News for Butterflies and Bees

Photo by expom2uk

(1) Pesticides Fog Honeybees’ Brains


In a study in the March issue of the journal Science, researchers at the National Institute for Agricultural Research in France fed bees sugar water laced with neonicotinoids. These insecticides are used as seed dressings, so they permeate all parts of the crops including pollen and nectar. The bees had miniature radio tags and were moved more than a half a mile from their hive.

In familiar territory, bees exposed to pesticides were 10 percent less likely to return home and only 31 percent less likely to do so in unfamiliar places. The chemicals cause “homing failure” in bees, so they are unable to find their way back to their hives. Using a computer model, the French scientists estimated that the hive’s population would then drop by two-thirds or more, depending on the number of worker bees exposed.

Some including a scientist for Bayer CropScience, the leading maker of neonicotinoids, and James Cresswell, an ecotoxicologist at the University of Exeter in England, have been critical of the study because it used a computer model. But May Berenbaum, an entomologist at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, said in the New York Times that she felt the study was “very well-designed.”

Photo by loco’s photos via Flickr

(2) Neonicotinoids Reduce the Growth of Bumblebee Colonies and the Production of Queens


In another study in Science, British researchers fed sugar water laced with a neonicotinoid to 50 bumblebee colonies. They moved the bee colonies to a farm beside 25 colonies that had been fed ordinary sugar water.

Colonies exposed to the pesticides produced 85 percent fewer queens. Such a decline would translate into 85 fewer colonies.

All the bees in a colony die at the of a year except for a few new queens, which go on to produce new hives. But if far fewer queens are produced, there will be far fewer bees colonies, period.

Photo by Todd Huffman via Flickr

(3) Widely-used Pesticide Imidacloprid Linked to Colony Collapse Disorder


In an study published in the April issue of the Bulletin of Insectology, Alex Lu, associate professor of environmental exposure biology in the Department of Environmental Health at Harvard University, focused on one neonicotinoid that was introduced in the 1990s, imidacloprid.  Bees can be exposed to this chemical either through nectar from plants or from high-fructose corn syrup that beekeepers use to feed their bees. Most corn in the U.S.  is treated with imidacloprid, so it is found in corn syrup.

For 23 weeks, the scientists monitored bees in four different bee yards, each of which had been treated with different levels of imidacloprid, and one control hive. All the bees were alive after 12 weeks of imidacloprid dosing. After 23 weeks, 15 of the 16 imidacloprid-treated hives had perished and those exposed to the highest levels of the pesticide were the first to die.

The dead hives showed the characteristics of colony collapse: empty hives with food stores, some pollen and young bees, and only a few dead bees nearby. Had a virus or pest caused hive collapse, there would have been many dead bees inside the hive.

Lu says that his study offers “convincing evidence” connecting imidacloprid to colony collapse disorder. He suggests removing all neonicotinoids from use across the globe for a period of five to six years; if the bee population increases afterwards, neonicotinoids can be clearly pointed to as a culprit.

As Carrington writes, there is no need for testing to see if pesticides harm bees. Even “sub-lethal doses” cause them “serious harm,” and the significance of bees to agriculture and to the global ecosytem is inestimable. What we need is a global ban on imidacloprid, before it is too late.

Photo by weegeebored via Flickr

Photo by No Minds Vision via Flickr


Duane B.
.5 years ago

Thank you for sharing.

C. R.
Carole R6 years ago


tiffany t.
tiffany t6 years ago

wow took a genius to figure that out eh. Look at the back of any pesticides and it says harmful to bees.

Chad A.
Chad A6 years ago

Unless we want to view our food supply as a pest, maybe we should start rethinking non-organic pesticide procedures...

Lynda Duke
Lynda Duke6 years ago

WHAT are GMOs doing to the bees?

Barbara V.
Barbara V6 years ago

Tell the students this is already known. So what is going to be done about it? You kill off the bees and you're as good as dead yourself. I tell you, wherever man goes, death and destruction follow.

Katherine Wright
Katherine Wright6 years ago

This should scare the hell out of every living being. I scares me. Their fate is our fate folks.
No bees = no life. It's as simple and as complicated as that.

Are YOU scared? You SHOULD be................................

Colleen L.
Colleen L6 years ago

Why is it that in today's world we have all of this crap? We/ve gone centuries without these life destroying chemicals, It makes me sick to go and buy fresh vegetables and fruits wondering what has been sprayed or added to their soil. In my own garden, I have seen less bees coming around for the past three years. It sadden me. I try to grow lots of flowers to bring them around to help pollen my vegetables and fruit plants. I have been signing all sorts of petitions to put a stop it it. I hope they do, before they kill us all. Thanks Kristina

Ann Fuller
Ann Fuller6 years ago

We have known for years that pesticides kill the bees. Lets have more ACTION......ban pesticides!! What effect are pesticides having on birds and even us humanes??

Robert Fitzgerald

There is the potential for a huge worldwide famine in the next few decades that promises to affect America as well as every other country. And human activity is central to this possibility. Climate change is negatively altering the growing cycles of agriculture around the world. Super fires, floods, and other disasters destroy crops. Farm land is becoming more and more salty dues to irrigation practices. Genetic modification of crops promise the creation of foods that have increasingly toxic effects on consumers. We are over fishing our oceans and many species are on the verge of extinction. The oceans are becoming more acidic during this same time. Population numbers are now over 7 billion people and climbing. Add to this colony collapse syndrome, and we have all the elements for a huge decline in food production leading very quickly to worldwide famine. We simply do NOT have the luxury of waiting for further research on the devastating effects of these types of insecticides.