4 Rebuttals to the State of the Union

The state of our union is strong, or so President Barack Obama told the world in the 2014 State of the Union address. With new ideas for increasing earnings, especially for low wage earners, focusing more on education, ending the gender pay gap and even coming up with alternative retirement savings plans, you would think he had it all covered.

However, the President wasn’t the only one to weigh in on America’s successes and opportunities. What once was a simple opposing party rebuttal speech has now turned into a free for all of alternative State of the Union retorts. As the right has grown more fractured, multiple wings of the GOP have grabbed the microphone for a follow up. Also vying for more attention? The uterus.

Yes, that’s right, it’s a “State of the Union Rebuttal” roundup!

The Mainstream: The official Republican State of the Union response was provided by Rep. Cathy McMorris Rodgers, a congressperson from Washington state. By having a woman provide the response, the GOP no doubt felt that it would soothe the “war on women” rhetoric that has become a Democratic party talking point, and one that was subtly referenced by the President who said we needed to end “Mad Men era workplace policies.”

Rep. Rodgers does that beautifully, especially when she claims that “Republicans believe health care choices should be yours, not the government’s.” Of course, she was referring to opting out of Obamacare, not reproductive care like abortion or birth control, which the Republican House voted once more to restrict just a few hours before her speech. She reminds the audience that the GOP wants an “America that is every bit as compassionate as it is exceptional,” but doesn’t mention the fight to reduce SNAP benefits or their refusal to extend unemployment insurance for the long term unemployed.

Still, she closes with a prayer and blessing, so, maybe someday the party will live the compassion they give so much lip service to.

The Far Right: The Tea Party began its own State of the Union rebuttal memorably with Rep. Michele Bachmann, a speech remembered more for her literal wide-eyed delivery than any actual policy. This year, Utah Senator Mike Lee received the honors.

In his speech the Senator literally harkens back to the Boston Tea Party, encouraging those frustrated with the government to protest it. He even speaks of income inequity and other issues that were key in the President’s own address. However, despite being a “non-Republican party” speech, every concern he points to, from gay marriage to abortion to school choice and health care, is a straight GOP talking point, and every person he says is working on a solution to it is of course a member the Republican party.

Best line of the night? The Affordable Care Act is allegedly responsible for economic “inequality.” “Obamacare – all by itself – is an inequality Godzilla that has robbed working families of their insurance, their doctors, their wages and their jobs,” said Sen. Lee.

Yes, because nothing creates inequality like no longer potentially being bankrupted by catastrophic medical bills.

The Even More Far Right: So the GOP got to rebut. And the Tea Party got to rebut. But no one asked Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul what he thought, so he did a rebuttal of his own. Most of it involved balanced budgets, a corporate tax that would be cut in half, and, like every other Republican speech, school choice. The most interesting line of the speech? “For the first time in history, men and women were guaranteed a chance to succeed based NOT on who your parents were but on your own initiative and desire to work.” Pretty bold statement from the son of a Congressman.

Surprisingly, there was one place where I think everyone can agree with the senator from Kentucky. “I have seen the inner sanctum of Congress,” said Sen. Paul. “And believe me there is no monopoly on knowledge there.” Those might be the truest words he’s ever spoken.

The…um…Genitalia Speaks: The Republican party obviously feels like its needs were not being addressed by the President’s speech. Neither, it appears, do the, well, uteri. To be fair, they’ve been the center of some pretty major debates lately, with over 200 restrictions on the right to choose leveled at them since 2011. Despite all of this, not once did the President mention reproductive health rights last night.

Now, via Lady Parts Justice, the uterus is responding. Itself. “I am here tonight to assure the uteri of America that the government is back to work and that Republicans and Republicans alike are tirelessly fighting so the uteri of America will have the same rights as the uteri of Saudi Arabia,” it declares. To hear the words from its own “mouth,” click here.

Photo credit: Thinkstock


Jim Ven
Jim V1 years ago

thanks for the article.

Bill Eagle
Bill E4 years ago

These silly people would call Jesus a Marxist. They give lip service to compassion all the while turning their back on people's needs.
Bunch of right wing hypocrites.

Robert Hamm
Robert Hamm4 years ago

HAHAHAHAHAAHAHAAHAHA Is Fox the free presss David??? I can read a LOT of truths about our country without even reading our press. So can the rest of the world. Grow up David. You are too old to be spewing shuch childish and narrow minded drivel. Hating Obama doesnt absolove the Republican party of hardly a thing. Most of their policies have caused the middle class to disappear leaving the haves and the have nots.

Robert Hamm
Robert Hamm4 years ago

LOLOLOL David. Every toime Obamas numbers go down the Republican numbers go right down with them. But nice try at spinning anyway

Jenny Sejansky
Jenny Sejansky4 years ago

David F and all your ilk- a "conman monster" is being put on display for the world to see. He's in NJ and represents your side of the nation. Looks good. Real good. AS for poll numbers, they'll be up again next week. Hold your breath. Women are going to show up to the polls this year. I predict even Sandra Fluke has a chance at Congress. Who else? Where are you, girls? Get up and run for office, ladies. If not you , then somebody you know is worth giving a push...let's take our country back! It's really up to us, ladies! Let's push!

Mary B.
Mary B4 years ago

David F..... How about that Mr.Christie ? if he is the GREAT hope of the GOP it may be from jail.....not looking too good for him David.....then there's Mr.Cruz..your Texas buddy.....after all it was ONLY 24 BILLION and yes, it was the teabags that shut down the government..... then there's the OTHER Bush but his Mommy doesn't want him to run... ....... wait they're all idiots..... President Obama's ratings will go up maybe when the GOP stops the hate ads and the ACA is shown to be good for the people as in Kentucky (Mr.McConnell's home state)

Linda McKellar
Past Member 4 years ago

David, and who do YOU think will get elected in 2016? Maybe Bachmann or Cruz? Palin? Christie? God help you and everyone else. Until the Republicans return to their true roots the likes of Lincoln or even Eisenhower, instead of pandering to fringe elements, they couldn't win a stuff animal at the fair.

Deborah W.
Deborah W4 years ago

Robin Marty get over yourself. Subject was State of the Union.

Have yet to hear the mutterings of the other side, not dared to be spoken beyond a whisper for fear of being picked up, recorded and reported on.

That's just why everything is Democrats vs. Republicans, them vs. us, you vs. me rather than WE THE PEOPLE. See the problem yet?

Charlotte S.
Charlotte S4 years ago

What about a rebuttal from the majority of citizens? Those of us who want to live our lives without so much government interference? Farmers who want to grow organic foods and humanly raise animals? Laws and regulations are being passed every day that destroy these rights.

Women who don't believe in people having the right to control their own bodies are waging war on other women. All citizens deserve to live as they wish as long as they do not infringe on the rights of other citizens. This includes religious beliefs that infringe on MY and other peoples rights. Many forget that birth control and abortion decisions are often made by couples not just women so the rights of these couples is being infringed upon.

The same is true of laws that don't allow people to choose how they want to live. If people want to smoke pot or do drugs if they are of legal age and do not drive while under the influence what's the problem? How much better would things be if we did what Portugal did 13 years ago? http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/evaluating-drug-decriminalization-in-portugal-12-years-later-a-891060.html What if we also made prostitution legal thus giving women and men the right to control how they use their bodies. It would make things safer for both the prostitute and the clients as well as creating more tax dollars.

What if we lived in a country that allowed adults to live as they wish (again as long as they do not infringe on the rights of other citizens).

Nils Anders Lunde
PlsNoMessage se4 years ago

When republic say they try to work with Obama and it does not work, maybe they should look at what they try to work with him with. So far it is almost insane things that majority of the people are against. So no wonder they have problem both with themself and the peoples will........