School Sees Segregation as Key to Success

Administrators at McCaskey East High School believe that segregation may be a good thing.


The Pennsylvania high school is raising a huge, justified controversy by claiming that separating black students from the rest of their students, and black females from black males will lead to better results.

According to Angela Tilghman, an instructional coach at McCaskey East, about a third of McCaskey’s African American students scored proficient or advanced in reading on last year’s Pennsylvania System of School Assessment tests, compared with 60% of white students.  In mathematics, 27% of black students scored proficient or advanced.


To address this gap, East McCaskey has segregated its homeroom classes. For six minutes each day and 20 minutes twice a month, African American students are placed in homerooms with African American teachers, or mentors, to start the school day.


Despite much criticism, Principal Bill Jimenez defends his experimental policy. Jimenez said that research has shown that same-race classes with strong same-race role models lead to better academic results.


Interestingly, ONLY African American students are divided by race at the school. Jimenez claims this is because the academic data dictated the school needed a different approach with its black students.


Lancaster Online quotes several students who have found this “program” helpful. Junior Dominique Miller said that his new homeroom has helped address common stereotypes about black males. “Now…other people can see my brothers, the people I’m associated with in this homeroom, are hoping to better themselves, and the teachers are hoping to better themselves,” he said. “It’s about empowering who you really are.”


But is this really the best and only way to empower young people of all races and backgrounds? Promoting segregation is a dangerous way to reduce the achievement gap, and can be a slippery slope.


In Wake County, North Carolina, segregation is occurring for more than just six minutes a day. With the backing of their conservative school board and the Tea Party, the school system’s decade long diversity policy is ending. In the past, Wake County used the number of students receiving free or reduced-price lunches to assign students to schools. This meant that some of its best schools existed in low income neighborhoods of Raleigh and the suburban districts included low-income families who couldn’t afford to live in the neighborhood.

The new plan to employ a “neighborhood schools system” will concentrate poor children into just a few schools by only allowing them to attend their neighborhood school. So far, this has resulted in 700 initial student transfers which has already increased racial segregation.


“School boards across this country are rolling the clock back to the time before Brown vs. the Board of Education,” NAACP President Benjamin Todd Jealous said in a statement.

It appears that we are forgetting why we did away with segregation to begin with. What happened to the idea that diversity and equality are essential to education? That separate educational facilities are inherently unequal?


Segregation is not a new, innovative concept, but an approach that has proved detrimental to our school system, to low-income families, to African Americans, and to society at large.


Creative Commons
Fiona O'Sullivan


Sarah clevenger
Sarah clevenger3 years ago

And they can't just hire more black role models, I think its wrong to segregate any race.

And its things like this that allow racism and stereotype to continue .
We are all equal. None of my schools had his problem with one race not getting as high of scores.If anything this sounds like a teaching problem , schools should make sure everybody is learning.

Dave C.
David C3 years ago

interesting, but why can't more black role models be brought into all classes....with all students......all students deserve respect, compassion, caring, and good teaching in schools........

Fi T.
Past Member 3 years ago

The key should be teaching with love

Jonathan Harper
Jonathan H3 years ago


criss S.
criss s6 years ago

The "Public School System", gets a big fat "F" in my book.
Get rid of the "one size fits all" teaching methods. Change the way "Public" schools are funded....not from property taxes and/or fundraisers. Cut the Military Industrial Complex spending!
I feel school should encourage culturally diversity. Cultures vary not just by race (race is made up anyway), but also from region to region of the United States. The United States is also becoming more multiracial and mobile. You can't put everyone in a perfect little box...why would you want to?

Cynthia M.
Cynthia Morrison6 years ago

Oh heavens what a racist step in this century. I cannot believe that this type of behaviour is happening in the USA. Forward is the way to go not backward.

Penelope P.
Penelope P6 years ago

Negroes are on average ten percent down fron the average European in IQ
However Chinese are ten percent up on Europeans- Perhaps there should be preferential schools and selective schools for the Chinese

Martha Eberle
Martha Eberle6 years ago

There MUST be another way to inspire young black kids -- it's a very slippery slope this is starting. And look what they've done in N.C.! That truly is segregation all over again.

Scott Vonwolf
Scott haakon7 years ago

Not so fast. For many this is an eye opener. I understand that wealthy neighborhoods are going to do better. The wealthy parents have equally high status friends so the children grow up in a "can be,can do" atmosphere. Children of the poor get can't.

Norma V.
Norma Villarreal7 years ago

Gender specific classes is one thought in education, but if you plan to separate black males and females, Principal Jimenez, you might apply this experiment to Hispanics as well.