EPA: It’s “Acceptable” For 1 in 28 To Get Sick From the Beach

It would be ok for 1 in 28 people to get sick after swimming at the beach according to a new proposal from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). That is, at least one of the people on the beach with you is likely to end up with vomiting, diarrhea with fever and stomachache, or nausea accompanied by a fever, under the EPA’s proposed guidelines for levels of beach pollution.

If that makes you feel less than inclined to go for an ocean swim, it should. As the National Resource Defense Council‘s Switchboard explains, the Beaches Environmental Assessment and Coastal Health Act of 2000 required that, by 2005, the EPA would issue recreational beach criteria that would be “for the purpose of protecting human health” at beaches on the coasts and the Great Lakes. But the EPA failed to meet the deadline, leading the NRDC to sue and gain a court order requiring the EPA to follow the law.

The EPA has devised a proposal but one that leaves much to be desired to protect public health. At the levels of beach contamination that the EPA seeks to allow, 36 out of 1,000 people will end up with diarrhea, vomiting, nausea and stomachache. It is apparently “acceptable” for that many people (1 out of 28) to become ill after swimming at the beach.

Rather than trying to tighten regulations on beach pollution and seeking to ensure that fewer people become ill with some highly unpleasantly illnesses, the EPA is letting the level of allowable contamination stay the same. The only change, says NRDC, is that we know more about such illnesses (that the diarrhea could also come with fever). But such is not enough:

… the EPA must address all known risks to human health. The EPA’s proposal fails to do so as it sweeps the most fundamental and alarming point under the rug: knowingly allowing one in 28 people to get sick is not protecting public health, nor is it legal.

Furthermore, the EPA seems also to be cutting corners in the ways it measures pollution, by allowing “water test results at beaches to be averaged over a period as long as 90 days” and by decreeing that one in every four samples must be beyond safe levels before the EPA will call for a reduction in beach pollution. Such measures do not adequately protect beachgoers. Says NRDC:

This is entirely incompatible with the Clean Water Act’s goal of “fishable/swimmable” waters. Quite simply, no one swims, paddles, or fishes in “average” water. They come into contact with water in whatever condition they find it at that particular time.

Of course one faces risks when swimming in the ocean or in a lake. But the EPA needs to live up to its name and look out for our oceans and lakes and ensure that pollution is not simply at “acceptable” levels, but at ones that are safe and that mean we can expect a sunburn at worst (not some equivalent of Montezuma’s revenge) after a visit to the beach.

Related Care2 Coverage

NRDC Study Finds U.S. Beaches More Polluted Than Ever

Feds Block Public From Investigating Oiled Beaches (Video)

Clean the Ocean, Green the Economy, UN Report Urges

Photo by John Weiss


Cedric Moses
Cedric Moses4 years ago

P.E.T. CSI™ forensic unit at UC Davis’ veterinary genetics lab is the only one accredited by the American Society of Crime Laboratory Directors, and is called upon by police across the country and sometimes the ocean to help in criminal cases. P.E.T. CSI™ assist property managers and city code enforcement by matching un-scooped pooped to the irresponsible pet owner creating a profit center by catching violators. P.E.T. CSI™ also provides pet owners with genetic disease analysis and breed analysis. We do more than just match poop to who didn't scoop. Compare our services, results and accolades to our competitors and see why we are the #1 pet DNA analysis firm in the world. We are the only certified & accredited pet DNA & pet waste management firm. Contact us today for more info 855-693-3927 or info@petcsi.com.

Mark Donners
Mark Donner6 years ago

poor birds.. they can only stand on top of some poles thinking what manner of evil monkeys are these that are trashing our homes.

Amanda Goodwin
Amanda Goodwin6 years ago

I guess its a good thing I prefer rivers...

Debbie Crowe
Debbie Crowe6 years ago

Yikes!! I don't want to go to the beach any more. The way my luck runs, I will be that 1 out of 28 people.

Vicky Pitchford
Vicky P6 years ago

it shouldn't be..that's a pretty high number :/

Christina B.
Christina B6 years ago

This is so disgusting! In Greece, we may no longer have anything, but at least we have some of the cleanest beaches in the world.

Hopefully, they won't be sold so the IMF gets satisfied.

Chelsea Carlson
Chelsea Carlson6 years ago

How can those numbers be acceptable by anyone?

Carole H.
Carole H6 years ago


Mike Barnes
Michael Barnes6 years ago

This is how it's done. Republicans cut funding for federal agencies. The remaining staff is lobbied by business or even replaced with business appointees. ThenRepublicans bash government for not doing its job while business continues to bleat about restrictive regulation. Government is used to do businesses' dirty work and serves as a foil for the activities. Depending on whose side you're on, it's a win-win or a lose-lose.

Tim Cheung
Tim C6 years ago