How California Is Debunking The GOP’s Obamacare Talking Points

Written by Sy Mukherjee

On Thursday, California officials revealed insurance companies’ opening bids for the state’s Obamacare marketplace in 2014. The numbers are great for consumers — and terrible for right-wing fear mongering over the health law.

Covered California, the agency tasked with constructing and maintaining the Golden State’s insurance marketplace, announced in a press release that rates submitted by 13 insurers for the 2014 individual marketplace were far lower than initially expected, ranging from a stunning 29 percent below the current average premium for small business health plans to only two percent above them.

For Californians who will gain coverage in the marketplace, that means affordable health plans with a minimum base of ten “essential health benefits,” including prescription drug services, mental health care, and maternity services. And the announced rates are even better for consumers considering that they don’t take Obamacare’s federal insurance subsidies into account. Depending on income, the average middle-aged Californian would pay anywhere from $40 to $300 per month for a mid-level “Silver” health plan on the marketplace. Younger, healthier Americans looking to buy bare-bones “Bronze” health plans would end up paying less than $170 per month — or even nothing at all — if they make less money and receive federal Obamacare subsidies.

That stands in stark contrast to heated GOP rhetoric and outlandish insurance company predictions about Obamacare. Last week, the Republican-led House of Representative voted to repeal the Affordable Care Act for the 37th time. During a House Energy and Commerce Committee hearing on Obamacare “rate shock” last week, House Republicans predicted hikes as high as 66 percent for Californians’ premiums based on internal documents from 17 major U.S. insurance companies.

Such claims may make for good politicking — but as the California numbers underscore, they aren’t actually reflected in reality. During last week’s House hearing, Topher Spiro, Vice President for Health Policy at the Center for American Progress (CAP), warned against making hysterical claims about health insurance rates under Obamacare. He noted that independent analyses have shown that an influx of Americans into the insurance pool and marketplaces designed to foster competition would actually end up lowering Americans’ premiums, especially in high-population states like California.

As it turns out, Spiro was right. Although some insurers have used Obamacare as an excuse to gouge profits, many have been actively working with doctors, hospitals, and regulators to offer Americans quality, affordable coverage at competitive rates. Plans on the California marketplace reduced their profit margins down to two or three percent. “It’s a revolutionary improvement to move from a broken market where people are charged by how sick they are, to a competitive market where people pay what they can afford, based on a percentage of their income, on a sliding scale,” Anthony Wright, executive director of the health advocacy group Health Access, told Reuters in an interview.

And California isn’t the only state to release such positive initial numbers for its marketplace. Earlier this month, several Oregon insurers actually requested to lower their opening bids for the state’s insurance marketplace after they realized that their initial offerings weren’t competitive enough. Numbers for marketplaces in Washington and Vermont have also been encouraging.

As more and more of Obamacare is implemented, the gulf between the political talking points about the law and its actual effects has become increasingly evident. With open enrollment for the marketplaces only five months away, the initial verdict on Obamacare is in: so far, so good.

This post was originally published by ThinkProgress.


Photo: Tabitha Kaylee Hawk/flickr


Marianne Good
Past Member 4 years ago


Cindy W.
Cindy W.4 years ago

The Facebook Share link is not working. Had to get the source link to share. Republican sabotage???

Autumn S.
Autumn S4 years ago


Lori Ann Hone
Lori Hone4 years ago

I base my opinions on the facts, not what other people say I should think. So many Republicans have "guessed" what might happen instead of waiting to see how this plays out and so far I think Obamacare will be a good thing.

Lori Ann Hone
Lori Hone4 years ago

Republicans couldn't tell the truth is their lives depended on it. They seriously need to "CLOSE FOR REPAIRS" before they completely destroy the party and it goes by the way just like the Wig Party. Thank you President Obama!!!!!!

Aud Nordby
Aud n4 years ago


JL A4 years ago

No wonder the radio airtime is inundated with so-called book ads for a self published guide to Obamacare with one website with a url that mimics official government (but isn't) with dire warnings of why to buy (that are heavily debunked myths)...

Becca McCoy
Cuppy M4 years ago

That is a lie. Insurance has gone up across the board. At least in Georgia it has...

Kathy Crews
Kathy Crews4 years ago

HA....Snap!!! Take that Republicans!!! Although I doubt that this will have much of an impact on any Republicans thought process though when it comes to Health Care Reform. They are totally blinded to the fact that this is a good (was a lot better before they tore it apart in Congress) plan that has been created to help ALL Americans. Not just the wealthy one's....YES, it means giving medical care even to those that are in the middle and lower income brackets!!

Quanta Kiran
Quanta Kiran4 years ago

good news!