In France, Satire Survives Firebombing (Video)

“Love is stronger than hate,” was the response of the French satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo to being firebombed last week. And having its website hacked by Turks.

The magazine had published cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad and their reaction in this week’s edition was a cover cartoon with that slogan over a picture of a Muslim man greedily embracing a journalist with the satirical weekly.

At the bottom of the kiss are the ruins of the magazine’s offices. It was set alight after publicizing a hilarious caricature of Muhammad as the “Weekly Sharia.” The edition was a mock “celebration” of the victory of the moderate Islamist party An-Nahda in the Tunisian elections and the Libyan transitional executive’s statement that Islamic sharia law would be the country’s main source of law.

The Socialist-run Paris City Hall said it would help Charlie Hebdo find a new office, but they quickly moved into the left-wing daily Libération.

Luz, the front cover cartoonist pictured being kissed, has refused to condemn extremists for the attack.

“Let’s be cautious. There’s every reason to believe it’s the work of fundamentalists, but it could just as well be the work of two drunks,” he wrote afterwards.

French Muslim groups who had been highly critical of Charlie Hebdo condemned the destruction of its offices. Dalil Boubakeur, head of the Paris Mosque, told journalists:

“I am extremely attached to the freedom of the press, even if the press is not always tender with Muslims, Islam or the Paris Mosque.”

The magazine is part of a tradition of outrageous scandal sheets going back to the French revolution.

Charlie Hebdo’s origins lie in another satirical publication called Hara-Kiri, born of  the 60s.

In 1970, following the same day news of a terrible fire at a discotheque which killed more than 100 people and the death of former President Gen Charles de Gaulle, Hara-Kiri’s headline was “Bal tragique a Colombey – un mort,” meaning “Tragic dance at Colombey [de Gaulle's home] – one dead.”

Then got it banned, which led to Charlie Hebdo and there’s been no letting up on the provocative satire ever since. In 2007, it survived reprinting the Danish cartoons of Muhammad. And cartoons of Muhammad are hardly the most outrageous thing it has ever published, given it has published cartoons of masturbating nuns, popes wearing condoms and police holding up beheaded immigrants.

Via sepia64: Quelques couvertures de Hara-Kiri et de Charlie Hebdo sous Cavanna et Choron, avec “It’s a long way to the top”;) d’AC/DC.

Related stories:

Tunisian Islamists Offer Reassurance to Gays, Women, Drinkers

Black Libyans Fear for Their Lives (VIDEO)

Jon Stewart’s Persian Counterpart

Image: cover of Charlie Hebdo


colleen p.
colleen p6 years ago

I didn't read it. but has someone who wrote a JesusXMuhammad porn story.

Tom B.
Tom B.6 years ago

Is it not the same trend everywhere?

Tom B.
Tom B.6 years ago

The laws are now strong enough to protect the weak
My IT Site

Gloria H.
Gloria H6 years ago

A person who can't laugh at their foibles is in serious trouble. That's what the fortune cookie said.

Tommy S.
Tommy S6 years ago

Quote....Love is stronger than hate....Unquote
Love is a stranger to hate

timothy m.
timothy m6 years ago

Ah, Islam, the religion of peace...

Beth S.
Beth S6 years ago

Humor is a wonderful vehicle for delivering many a painful message.

If other people don't have the right to mock people, do we do ourselves any favors by not exercising the right that we do have. I'm not sure how that helps the people that don't have the right or helps us.

Charlie Chaplain made a movie(s) mocking Adolph Hitler, and this gave comic and psychic relief to many who had to confront his armies in Europe and worry about Nazi Germany defeating the Allies and coming to the U.S.. Hitler was altogether deserving of mockery. Being able to laugh at oppressive, evil figures is sometimes the best defense.

Islam is an oppressive and destructive force everywhere it goes. As we see country after country submit to cultural suicide, throwing themselves under the Juggernot of multiculturalism, humor is an excellent vehicle for dealing with this phenomenon.

And I do mean that quite seriously. :)

Interestingly, one thing I have found consistently in the comments of the Muslims on Care2 and in general is that their comments are totally devoid of any sense of humor. I think that's a bad sign, and we ought to find out why that is.

Any psychologists on Care2?

Penny C.
penny C6 years ago


Gillian Miller
Gillian M6 years ago

There are far too many fundamentalists who are using our laws to slap us in the face. It is time we started deporting criminals and their entire family as unwanted.

Charlie Parkinson

Makes Monty Python look rather tame :)