Is Inbreeding the Only Way to Save the Sumatran Rhino?

There are fewer than 100 Sumatran rhinoceroses left, making them the most endangered animal on the planet. This smallest member of the rhino species has two horns (coveted for use in traditional Asian medicine) and brown fur and is closely related to the wooly rhinoceros that went extinct thousands of years ago.

The Sumatran rhino could soon face the same fate. For this reason, the Cincinnati Zoo is planning to take the drastic step of mating Suci, a 9-year-old rhino, with her brother, 6-year-old Harapan.

Dr. Terri Roth, the director of the zoo’s Linder Center for Conservation & Research of Endangered Wildlife (CREW), acknowledges that mating sibling rhinos poses numerous risks. But there are simply not enough Sumatran rhinos left. “We are down to the last male and female Sumatran rhino on the continent, and I am not willing to sit idle and watch the last of a species go extinct,” says Roth in US News.

Suci and Harapan were both born at the Cincinnati Zoo as was their older brother, Andalas, the first Sumatran rhino calf born in captivity. Their parents, Emi and Ipuh, had been rescued from southwest Sumatra.

Andalas was born in 2001 and moved to the Los Angeles Zoo when he was two, as his mother, Emi, had conceived again. He was then shipped to Indonesia’s Sumatra Rhino Sanctuary in 2007. After a period of adjustment — Andalas was initially scared of the other rhinos and did not know how to wallow in mud holes, one of wild Sumatran rhinos’ favorite things to do — he became the father to a son, Andatu, last summer.

Harapan also has had a bit of an odyssey since he was born in Cincinnati in 2007. He  has been spent the past few years elsewhere in the U.S., at the White Oak Conservation Center in Florida and then at the Los Angeles Zoo, all organizations that have joined together to try to save the Sumatran rhino.

Noting that inbreeding rhinos is hardly ideal, Jeff Holland, a mammal curator at the Los Angeles Zoo, also says that there is ”resistance from the Indonesian government in helping capture the rhinos” to diversify the gene pool of captive rhinos. Unless this is varied, the U.S.’s captive breeding program could, despite the many efforts of conservationists, be in trouble.

The Cincinnati Zoo’s plan to try to mate Suci and Harapan is not the first time that scientists have resorted to inbreeding to save species whose numbers are greatly threatened. Conservationists have also resorted to inbreeding white and black rhinoceroses. As one 2007 study reports, inbreeding raises the chance of animals dying when they are young as well as the chance of birth defects, as shown by one black rhinoceros who was reportedly born without one ear.

Even in the wild, the population of Sumatran rhinos may be so small that sibling rhinos may be breeding in forests, as Roth also points out in Scientific American.

The rhinos’ native forests are being rapidly cleared for the sake of economic development. While the Indonesias government has instituted policies regulating the clearing of the forests, illegal logging and mismanagement have meant that the Sumatran rhino’s habitat — and that of thousands of other species of wildlife and plants — is on track to disappear entirely. We must put a halt to the rampant deforestation and development in fragile ecosystems like Indonesia’s, even as scientists do all they can to save the Sumatran rhino, an animal that links us to the earth’s prehistoric past.


Photo from Thinkstock


Jim Ven
Jim V2 years ago

thanks for the article.

Mark D.
Mark D.4 years ago

When the forests go, they don't come back, and there goes the planet. Indonesia's government is as rotten, corrupt and criminal as they come

Rebecca G.
Rebecca G4 years ago

I still find it hard to believe that in the 21st century, some people are still stupid enough to believe that animals horns, bones, etc. can be used as medicine, sexual stimulants and other bizarre reasons. People's greed is destroying our planet and all the magnificent animals, many of whom were here long before us. There has to be a better way that inbreeding, it causes so many problems that only hurt the breed. I also agree with David V.: Poachers should be shot on sight, don't waste time trying them and supporting them, IF they are even convicted. WAKE UP PEOPLE, we do not own this planet, we are only renting it, we should leave it in better shape than the way we found it!!!

Carrie-Anne Brown

sad news but thanks for sharing

Melania Padilla
Melania P4 years ago

Animals should not face extinction in the first place!!!

GGma Sheila D.
GGmaSheila D4 years ago

So sad, thank you for sharing.

Jessica Larsen
Janne O4 years ago

So very sad.

Soldiers should be set to guard endangered animals.

Gayle J.
Gayle, J4 years ago

As long as there's a market for their horns, they are doomed. Animals are no match for human greed and ignorance. It's just so damn sad that the greedy seem hell bent on destroying the environment and the animals for their own gain. This is gonna be a very desolate planet by the time they're done with it.

Marilyn M.
Marilyn M4 years ago

Thank you.

David V.
David V4 years ago

I think inbreeding will just compromise their health. There has to be other solutions, first being-eliminate all poaching. the only good poacher is a DEAD poacher.