Record Settlement Reached in Slaughterhouse Abuse Case

Westland Hallmark Meat Co. came under fire in 2008 after undercover footage of horrific abuse was brought to light by the media, which resulted in one of the largest meat recalls in U.S. history and now the largest settlement ever for a case involving animal abuse.

The footage was obtained by the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) at a slaughterhouse in Chino, California, and showed workers torturing downed cows — those to weak or sick to stand or walk on their own — by kicking them, ramming them with a forklift, dragging them with chains, hosing them and shocking them, among other violent acts, in an attempt to get them up to walk to their deaths.

Westland Hallmark was a supplier to the National School Lunch Program and as such was required to follow strict animal welfare standards. The lawsuit was brought under the False Claims Act as a result of the company’s failure to live up to its contract, in addition to potentially allow contaminated meat into the food supply.

On Friday, a partial settlement was reached between two of the nine defendants in the case with the federal government entering a final judgement against Westland Hallmark for $497 million — a record setting judgment for a case involving animal abuse.

Donald Hallmark Sr. and Donald Hallmark Jr. agreed to pay $316, 802 over the next five years to the Department of Justice, which joined the case with the intention of recovering $150 million in taxpayer money wasted on the recall, while the HSUS will receive a “small portion of the settlement proceeds for its role in successfully prosecuting the case.”

The Hallmarks also agreed to work with the government and the HSUS in litigation against the remaining defendants.

Unfortunately, since Westland Hallmark is bankrupt, the full judgment won’t be collected, but the HSUS is calling it a deterrence judgment, which will hopefully set a precedent and deter future occurrences of abuse.

“The meat industry should take notice that if they defraud federal agencies and the American taxpayers by abusing animals, there will be serious consequences for their inhumane and reckless actions,” said Jonathan R. Lovvorn, senior vice president and chief counsel for animal protection litigation at the HSUS. “We commend the U.S. Department of Justice for joining The Humane Society of the United States in seeking to hold federal meat suppliers accountable.”


Related Stories:

Second State Silences Whistleblowers

How Easy Is It To Become an Animal Terrorist?

Animal Rights Activist Gets $15,000 Settlement


Photo credit: Thinkstock


Julie Cordner
Julie Cordner5 years ago

Abuse will continue to happen as long as the DEMAND for meat continues. Moving towards a Vegetarian/Vegan path is the only way to completely alter this practice. It is the fast food industries which drive the demand; take a look at "Food, Inc" to see the background to the food industry (in the US).

Annmari Lundin
Annmari Lundin5 years ago

Wonder where the Hallmark's, Sr and Jr, stashed their goodies before going belly-up? Because I don't believe they are destitute!
I hope this verdict scares the meat industry into following the rules, but I doubt it. No criminal ever thinks they will get caught!

Sheri D.
Sheri D5 years ago

Thank you, Humane Society, for being on the side of the animals. Shame on Westland Hallmark Meat Co., its employees, and its management.

Carrie Anne Brown

thanks for sharing

Nadine H.
Nadine H5 years ago

A step in the right direction, but not a win completely.

tanny k.
tanny taylor5 years ago

Does anyone know who is supplying meat for In & Out Burgers now?

ryan burger
Ryan B5 years ago

I'll do the punishing, free of charge.......

Katherine Wright
Katherine Wright5 years ago

This is not truly a win for the animals since this company is bankrupt and won't help those poor animals who've already suffered. Nothing, no monetary payment, will help them. And god forbid that these monsters find another way to make a comeback just like those at the Butterball Turkey Farms who've come back to continue their torturing ways against these poor turkeys. The abusers never seem to go completely away....they just play the system until they can resume their murderous ways.

This is a victory in name only....

Claudia Cavallo
Claudia Cavallo5 years ago

This is sure a big step towards justice in case of animal abuse. I hope this will warn other jerks to handle these poor animals better

Laura Collins
Laura collins5 years ago

Thank you HSUS for your work and care to support the rights of animals!