San Jose Votes to Remove Christopher Columbus Statue From City Hall

Someone’s getting evicted from San Jose City Hall in California after 60 years of residence: Christopher Columbus, who had previously occupied a place of pride in the building’s lobby.

Evidently recognizing that celebrating a figure known for racism, genocide and colonialism wasn’t a great look for a forward-thinking, progressive city, the City Council announced that the statue will be removed i has six weeks to find a new place.

The move was a response to an organizing campaign by the San Jose Brown Berets, a Chicano service and activist organization. It’s part of their Decolonize San Jose program, which also aims to remove other monuments to colonialism and oppression in the city.

Over the course of 2017, a growing wave of civic statue removals in response to outcry swept across the United States. Most of these statues were affiliated with icons of the Confederacy, with civil rights advocates arguing that celebrating white supremacist heroes wasn’t consistent with the values of many communities. Some of the statues came down in the dead of night, quietly carted off by public works employees. Others were actually torn down by crowds tired of waiting. Some places are renaming their buildings, too.

But Native American and indigenous groups have also been fighting a long and bitter battle over altars to colonialism found in cities and towns across the United States. Aside from the numerous place names associated with Columbus and his ilk, a number of cities still have statues of the historic figure. Advocates argue that, much like Confederate statues, these monuments should be relegated to history, not kept on display in buildings dedicated to public functions.

San Jose’s decision to remove this particular statue represents a big victory, and it also sends a message to the rest of the United States: You, too can get rid of your Columbus statues — and circles, parks, streets and other place names — and strip Columbus Day from your list of holidays.

San Francisco has already taken action, and the city will celebrate Indigenous People’s Day in October — not Columbus Day.

In San Jose, the Columbus statue will go into storage if it can’t be relocated. The Italian-American community is exploring possibilities, so it may end up on public display elsewhere. That said, local museums have yet to express an interest, since the statue itself is not artistically notable, just of historic interest. Moreover, it’s been creatively modified by protesters several times — even in the safety of city hall — so it’s highly probable that a public display would be subjected to editorial commentary via local activists.

The question of what to do with statues like this one can be tricky. While they do have some historical value — and preserving them can be an important part of recognizing the shared heritage of the United States — it’s important to store and display them in ways that appropriately contextualize them.

In case you’re curious, the statue came to San Jose as a gift from the Italian-American community, and the city’s own mayor, also Italian-American, was one of those who voted in favor of removal. Mayor Sam Liccardo told ABC News: “I think our understanding of history evolves as we learn more.”

Up next? Well, some organizations are likely hoping that San Francisco’s Columbus statue will also be consigned to the dustbin.

Photo Credit: HarshLight/Flickr

58 comments

Chad A
Chad Anderson16 days ago

Nice.

SEND
Johan Maltesson
Johan Maltesson18 days ago

All land in the Americas owned by whites is stolen from the natives through hundreds of years of more or less organised genocide. In light of that, removing a statue of one explorer just seems a little bit futile.

SEND
Winn Adams
Winn A18 days ago

Good

SEND
Winn Adams
Winn A18 days ago

Petition Signed

SEND
Bill Eagle
Bill Eagle19 days ago

A good move, when you consider the horrible things that Columbus did.

SEND
Annabel Bedini
Annabel Bedini19 days ago

The irony is that Columbus never set foot on the continent of what is now called America. He never got closer than the Caribbean. It was the people who came after him who did all the damage but history has first put him (unfairly) on a pedestal and is now (unfairly) taking hime down again. So much for 'history'!

SEND
Karen H
Karen H19 days ago

Aside from the fact that Columbus was a genocidal slaver, epic poems written roughly between 1190 and 1320 prove Vikings reached the Americas before Chris was a gleam in his daddy's eye.

SEND
Julie W
Julie W19 days ago

I'm all for removing the statue, but a small plaque should be put in its place explaining Columbus and his actions. You can't remove history, but certain aspects should not be glorified either. That's the point.
Germany no longer has statues of Nazis, but there are small reminders all over the place regarding what took place. History has not been erased.

SEND
Kay B
Kay B19 days ago

We've certainly made a polluted mess of the land. Maybe we should give back everything that we stole from the Indians and start living in harmony with nature again the way they did.

SEND
Carol C
Carol C19 days ago

Kudos to the city of San Jose - and to Mayor Liccardo!

SEND