Should We Care If Politicians Might Commit Suicide?

An Australian MP under investigation for misuse of union resources has asked the media if it’s trying to “push him to the brink” of suicide.

Labor MP Craig Thomson is under multiple investigations over claims he misused a union-issued corporate MasterCard. This includes allegations he used it to pay for prostitutes.

A tabloid television news show has confirmed that it has agreed to pay a Sydney prostitute who claimed to identify the federal MP in the range of US $60,000 if the interview went to air.

Last week, Thomson gave a rambling, hour-long declaration of innocence to parliament in which he broke down several times (pictured).

The Australian governing party relies on Independent MPs for a majority, so Thomson’s fate has become a highly politicized matter. However, Opposition leader Tony Abbott has come under pressure to ease off not just because of fears about Thomson’s obvious emotional condition, but because of a history of Australian politicians attempting or succeeding at suicide.

In 1997, Senator Nick Sherry was found on the floor of his Canberra flat in a pool of blood, having tried to take his own life after a scandal over travel allowances.

In 2000, Labor MP Greg Wilton was found by police distressed in his car with his two young children. His marriage had only recently ended.

There was never any evidence that Wilton planned to harm his children, but the tabloids nevertheless reported the incident as an attempted “murder-suicide.” They “subjected this young man to national humiliation,” said Liberal Victorian premier Jeff Kennett.

Some weeks later, Wilton did kill himself. An entire parliamentary day was set aside for condolence speeches. Members of Parliament wept openly in the House chamber.

In 2005, Liberal MP John Brogden made a suicide attempt after tabloid media reported on him “jokingly” suggesting a threesome to two women at a Christmas party.

In 2008, Tasmanian politician Paula Wriedt tried to kill herself after tabloid coverage of her marriage breakdown and alleged affair led to sexist slurs against her on a top-rated sports show.

In a sign that both sides of Australian politics may have actually learned from past events, there are reports that Thomson may be allowed by parliament to take stress-related leave.

An opposition MP who is a doctor has expressed his concern for Thomson’s mental state. Mal Washer said that other MPs owed Thomson a “duty of care.” He said:

He’s under tremendous pressure. He’s got a young child and a wife so we’ve got to take all those things into consideration.

Our party sees this as an opportunity to give the Labor Party some grief, but it’s a very unfortunate, I think, thing to witness from my point of view.

There is little sympathy in the media, with conservative commentator Andrew Bolt saying, “a politician too fragile to be held to account should quit,” and The Australian (a Murdoch-owned national newspaper) ran with the headline: “Craig Thomson is the suicide bomber’s vest, wrapped tightly around the Prime Minister and the Labor Party.”

Writing for the non-Murdoch owned Sydney Morning Herald, Katharine Murphy also defends the media, writing:

Holding Thomson accountable isn’t being a lynch mob, provided the reporting is straight and fair, acknowledges his denials, and is proportionate to the facts.

I don’t know if Thomson did these things or not. But I do know that it’s my job to ask the question.

Seasoned ABC News political reporter Barrie Cassidy is cynical, warning:

The alarm bells are ringing again. They can all hear them, in the Parliament and in the media. But as we have seen so often in the past, precious few are heeding them.

Are politicians owed a “duty of care”? Should the media pay heed to warning signs for suicide? What do you think?

Related stories:

Indigenous Australians Celebrate: “Great Injustice” Righted

No Plans To Sell UK Newspapers, Murdoch Insists

Lesbian Senator: “I Know What My Family is Worth” (Video)

Picture: ABC TV screengrab


Grover S.
Grover S5 years ago

We should encourage them to do so, paticularly the ones on the far right.

Olivia Lim
Olivia Lim5 years ago

If it is a concern, if they cannot handle the emotional or mental strain of being a politician, put them in a hospital, but they should not be in politics in the first place where it is very rough and cutthroat.

Juliet Defarge
judith sanders5 years ago

The worst have no conscience, and sadly, never consider seppuku.

Vernon W.
Vernon W5 years ago

Did the investigation into the allegations confirm the accuracy of the charges against Thomson? Isn't there a judicial procedure to handle graft or corruption? Or is the press the judge and executioner? As much as Fox News lie and distort, I would not trust the reportings of any Murdoch owned news outlet. Just to sell papers, paparazzi and tabloid reporters hound and torment any public figure, even those who were loved by the public. If not for the paparazzi hounding them for pictures to publish in the tabloids, Princess Diana might still be alive.

Frank B.
Frank B.5 years ago

Doug G, your absolutely right, I'd send you a star if I could.

Doug Gledhill
Doug G5 years ago

They can take the bankers with 'em.

Phil Hanson
Phil H5 years ago

Hell yeah, we should care; what assurances do we have that the suicide's replacement won't be worse?

Frank B.
Frank B.5 years ago

Megan M:Holly L; There is such a thing as 'Idiot Compassion' when people are patently never going to learn how to behave, then leave then alone, in the case of politicians, well we obviously have too many of them in the first place.

MEGAN N5 years ago

Yes. Everyone should be valued even if we disagree with them or they have done wrong. Everyone can change and every life is valuable. I am once again disapointed by some of the comments here. Progressive my a*s.

s. r.
p. q5 years ago

looks like emotional blackmail to me. but if he starts talking about suicide, then put him in a hospital. pretty straightforward.