Victory! Margaret “Jenny” Hatch Wins Her Guardianship Fight

Margaret “Jenny” Hatch wanted to live with her friends Jim Talbert and Kelly Morris; a pretty routine activity for adults with free will on most days once the details of rent and who’s going to be responsible for the dishes have been worked out. But her case was complicated by the fact that the 29-year-old woman had Down syndrome and had been placed under the guardianship of her mother and stepfather, giving them the right to make medical decisions, decide where she lived, and essentially govern all aspects of her life. She took the matter to court, and after a long and closely-watched battle, she won.

Under the terms set out by the judge, she’ll be living with Talbert and Morris for the next year while they help her achieve more independence, and advocates hope the judge may determine she doesn’t need a guardian at all after she demonstrates the life skills she’ll learn by living with them. Independent living, sometimes involving support from aides and assistants, is the goal of many disabled people, including self-advocates fighting to keep people out of institutions and to give disabled people more choice in their lives. In this case, the judge’s ruling affirms that independent living should be a priority. Hatch is delighted to be able to live with her friends and pleased by the outcome of the case, which affirmed her rights as an adult to make decisions about her life.

This case has been followed by the disability community because it touches on a number of issues important to self-advocates, anti-institutionalization organizations, and other groups concerned about the autonomy and wellbeing of disabled people. In Hatch’s case, the hope for Hatch, her attorney and many disabled people was that the judge would rule she didn’t need a guardian at all and could choose to live independently; the judge’s ultimate ruling was that there were enough concerns about her ability to care for herself that she did in fact need a guardian, but she had the right as an adult to weigh in on who that guardian should be.

Thus, the ultimate ruling was slightly mixed for Hatch; she lost the larger battle over whether she needed a guardian at all, but she struck a powerful blow for autonomy and independence by being granted the right to play a role in the key decision of who would be charged with her care and wellbeing. Her case sends a message and sets a precedent for other situations involving guardianship disputes.

Prior to the case, Hatch had been held in a series of group homes, and her life had been severely restricted. She complained about not being able to see friends and engage in other activities of daily life, echoing the refrain of an all-too-common story for developmentally-disabled adults, who are often treated like they have no autonomy, self-determination or right to dignity and respect. Forcible institutionalization is an ongoing problem in the United States, as are decisions “made in the best interest” of disabled people without actually involving them, in direct contrast to the famous “nothing about us without us” saying that disability activists have made a cornerstone of their advocacy.

As Jenny’s attorney put it in his closing statements, ”Justice for Jenny is not THEY get Jenny, or THEY get Jenny [referring to the couples vying for guardianship]. Justice for Jenny is JENNY gets Jenny.”

In this particular case, justice has been achieved, but the larger battle for disability rights is far from over. Organizations like the ACLU and various state-level disability rights groups are working on a daily basis to free more people like Jenny.

Screenshot of WAVY Newscast


Suz F.
Suz F4 years ago

posted Aug and just read in Oct...May you continue to move forward with your independency Jenny--Best of luck!...s.e.smith please keep an up date as this young lady becomes/learns to live her life...

Anne F.
Anne F4 years ago

Thanks for the followup. Glad to hear that the judge has provided for more independence.

Maria Cristina A.
Maria Cristina A4 years ago

WTG! :)

Koty Lapid
Koty Lapid4 years ago

thank you for posting

Manuela C.
Manuela C4 years ago

Wow, good for her! =)

Lynn Squance
Lynn S4 years ago

Great news!

I have cared for my mother and my paternal grandfather. I supported them living on their own, making their own decisions for as long as possible, and for as long as they were safe.

My grandfather made the decision to go into nursing care at age 96 (he died at age 99.5 years). My mother was diagnosed with dementia at age 79 and I took over making her decisions. However, I ALWAYS asked her first for the first few years. After all, it is her life. Now I do it all because she is no longer capable of understanding much less articulating her wishes. For me my approach has always been about DIGNITY.

Allowing the person to be self reliant is about their dignity, about their self determination. Some may need more help than others, but when it comes to DIGNITY, it must come first.

Alexandra Gundelfingen
Alexandra G4 years ago

Great news. Good luck, Jenny

Lady Kaira
None None4 years ago

All the best to her!

Maureen Leibich
Maureen Leibich4 years ago

This is wonderful. I have worked with children with Down Syndrome, and they are delightful to be around. If they are properly taught, within their abilities, they are perfectly capable of living independent lives. Good luck to you, Jenny.

Mary L.
Mary L4 years ago

Wonderful news!