What do Big Bird and Hurricane Sandy Have in Common?

I know I need to get over it, but I can’t. When Mitt Romney said he would defund PBS in the second debate, it gave me a wicked case of the epic eye rolls. Seriously. Supposed fiscal conservatives always trot out PBS and NPR when asked for a program they would cut to balance the budget, even though the Corporation of Public Broadcasting only accounts for 1/100th of a percent of the federal budget. (And forget the fact that much of PBS and NPR’s budget doesn’t come from the federal government at all.)

In the past I’ve just let threats to defund the CPB roll off me. But I can’t anymore, because I know what they are saying. People who want to defund public broadcasting see it as a worthless expenditure; something the government should have no part in. But as anyone who grew up on PBS programming knows, this is a bunch of malarkey.

I don’t remember a time when I wasn’t completely hooked on PBS (which recently celebrated its 43rd birthday). Sesame Street was my personal favorite, Mr. Roger’s Neighborhood was my brother’s. When I was a kid, PBS was on all day at my house. We watched Barney, Square One, Lambchop’s Play-A-Long, and Thomas the Tank Engine. We learned about math and science and history and culture via puppets and and trains and cartoons.

Perhaps it’s silly, but I take attacks on Sesame Street particularly hard. Not only did those Muppets teach me how to count in Spanish, but also how to be friends with people different from me. Not only did they teach me the alphabet, but also that silly, awkward kids can be heroes. Not only did they teach me that learning can be fun, but also that learning isn’t something that starts and stops in school.

This is a lesson I act on every day, and public broadcasting plays an important role. The only reason I know anything about string theory is because of Nova. Do you think network television – or cable television, for that matter – would have aired all 14 hours of Wagner’s The Ring Cycle? No.

But it’s not just childhood nostalgia or educational idealism that makes me bristle. It’s the fact that it fits so well into the Romney policy pastiche. Hurricane Sandy has reminded us that, if Romney had his way, he would defund FEMA and put emergency relief in the hands of the state. As if we needed reminding, he also wants to repeal Obamacare, which will make it possible for millions of Americans to get health insurance.

I know that this is, to some extent, is a philosophical disagreement between the political right and the political left. However, in the past several days we’ve seen what we can be when we put aside partisan bickering. People are helped. Subways are pumped. Lives are saved. We live in a society. Part of that compact is that we come together to help each other, to pull each other up. I can’t do much from my couch in middle America, but it’s my government and my taxes that are going to help those in need half a continent away. I’m glad I could help fund that. It almost makes up for unfunded wars and tax cuts for the rich. Almost.

You see, this is all part of the right wing modus operandi. Cut services designed to help the most vulnerable among us pick themselves up and make their lives better. It would be great if private enterprise or nonprofits could fix all of society’s ills, but it can’t. America’s health care crisis is a perfect example of that. What are we supposed to do? Stand aside and hope? Most people don’t have that luxury.

Big Bird is only a symbol. It’s a symbol of what good we can do when we band together. That good might be helping people get back on their feet after a natural disaster, or it might be teaching kids to use their brains to solve problems. No one is asking for the government to solve everyone’s problem. But if you recognize that government can be a force for good in the world, the choice this election is clear.


Related Posts:

7 Ways Romney’s Education Plan Would Destroy America’s Public Schools

Obama Wins by a Landslide (If the World Could Vote)

Obama Visits a Storm-Ravaged New Jersey


Image credit: seeingimonkey


Jane H.
Jane H5 years ago

Thanks to all the people who voted for Obama and saved public funding of PBS!

Jc Honeycutt
Jc Honeycutt5 years ago

For people (such as myself) who live in relatively remote or low-population areas, PBS and NPR often provide the only reliable and relevant news coverage we receive, not to mention cultural programming. One of my "must-haves" for moving to my current home was the availability of public radio: otherwise, programming in rural areas tends to be what I call "all Jesus, all the time" or, worse yet, Fox and right-wing talking heads. When I make the 600-mile-plus round trip to visit friends & family in Charlotte, NC, I'm extremely happy and grateful that I can listen to NPR all the way (except for occasional brief problems around Raleigh). Needless to say, I voted for Big Bird on Tuesday!

Robert Pavlick
Robert Pavlick5 years ago

Gina W says: "The U.S. Government spends almost 50% more on corporate subsidies than on social welfare programs."

I am sure that is true, Gina, but that is to keep corporations that EMPLOY AMERICANS solvent and in THIS country. The Democrats want to tax corporations to death and place impossible requirements on them and then they wonder why most US corporations have either left the country or are in the process of leaving.

Hey, when was the last time you secured a job from a welfare Mom or from an Attention Deficit Disorder person on Disability?

Lynn D.
Lynn D5 years ago

Thanks for article!

Robert H.
Robert Hamm5 years ago

I dunno Mike C why don't you ask Chris CHristie. He doesn't agree with your scenario

Susan Allen
SusanAWAY Allen5 years ago

PBS must be funded.

John B.
John B5 years ago

TJ W., Thank you for the green star. Tried to access your profile to say thank you but Care2 says there is an error and it won't come up.

Joanne Gavin
Joanne Gavin5 years ago

I thought everybody knew: that's WHY the reactionaries want to de-fund (from what little "gumnt" funding they actually get) PBS and NPR

in Houston

Florence Eaise
Florence Eaise5 years ago

yet one more reason to vote for Obama

Tahni W5 years ago

I hope those here who think it's a good idea to cut PBS don't have any offspring to spread their genes of apathy...