When Schools Tolerate Violence, For Money


Written by Matt Amaral, New America Media

If there was ever any doubt about who is running my high school, it was put to rest this week. The students now know punching a teacher will get you a week off while simultaneously making you campus hero on Facebook.

Come to think of it, it might be the best way to get out of a class you donít like. Having a hard time with your geometry teacher? Bash his face a few times, and when you are quickly allowed to come back to school, youíll be in another class with another teacher you wonít like.

This has been a problem at my high school for as long as Iíve been here. Students bring knives to school and are on campus the next day. A student throws a desk at a teacher and is back in class the same period. No, I did not make those two examples up.

Or how about last year when a kid tackled a police officer on our campus. Yes, assaulted a man in uniform as his boys cheered him on. That kid was back on campus in less than a week.

Evidently my high school, which is the largest high school in the city, is where the district makes all its money. Each school gets money for how many kids are present each day. My school is what they call a ďButt in SeatĒ school. Those higher up make sure we have as many butts in seats as possible so that they get as much money as possible. So when we request suspensions and expulsions, the paperwork is thrown right back in our faces, and the students are back at school before you know it.

Because their eyes are focused on the so-called larger picture, our district officials donít see what such a strategy has on the culture of a school. Iíll tell you what it does to the school in question.

It creates a culture of fear where the students are in charge.

Even before one of my colleagues was recently assaulted by a student, it was a mad-house around here. Of course, working at a low-income public high school, it is what you sign up for. But this year I have been at the point where I canít even open my classroom door. For real.

The last three times I had my classroom door open during class time, I had to write four referralsóbut not for my own students! I am writing referrals for students walking by my doorway and doing things like yelling swear words into my room, expressions too vulgar for me to reprint here.

These kids walk by and see a room full of silent students writing, and they feel they need to make themselves heard. So if my door is open while Iím teaching one of my classes, I alternately have kids throwing things inside, kicking the door, banging on my windows, and screaming profanity. I am truly at the point where I cannot have my door openóever!

Not that this year is much different from others. This culture of anarchy has been brewing for a long, long time. It comes from the knowledge there are no consequences for bad behavior. I donít even know what you have to do at my school to get expelled.

Every year I suspend three to four students every other day (when they show up) over the course of the entire year for what must add up to 30 days of school. As a teacher, the only thing I can do is suspend a student from my classroom for two days. There don’t seem to be other consequences aside from that.

For example, a student tells me last week, ďF**k youÖ you ugly ass b**h, I hate you, f**k you…Ē I suspend him from my class for two days, but he isnít even suspended from school. He still shows up to all his other classes, just not mine. Then two days later heís back.

Thatís how I get to a point where over the course of a year I suspend a kid 30 times. I give him two days, he comes back, two more days, comes right back, two days again, heís back cursing at me, and so on and so forth. Aside from the two days from me, nothing else ever happens to them.

I think back to when I was in high school. I remember getting suspended for throwing balled up paper at a girl I had a crush on during passing period. I canít even imagine what would have happened if I called a teacher the things I now get called once a week.

Yet I fear this latest development is going to be the one that breaks our backs.

Needing to fill our limited coffers by cramming our classrooms full of students who couldnít be expelled even if they wanted to is inexcusable. It is something the faculty has argued bitterly about for as long as Iíve been at this school. But when a teacher is battered, punched three times, and the perpetrator who committed what the rest of the adult world calls a felony comes right back to school, it makes me wonder what kind of insane world I teach in.

Do you want to know why people leave this profession in droves? It is very simple. It is the very reason one of our teachers quit last year after a decade of educating: We donít feel safe in classrooms.

And why would we? You can literally get sent to the hospital by the kids you teach, and itís still all good.

And if the adults donít feel safe, imagine how the students feel.

Matt Amaral is a writer and high school English teacher from the San Francisco Bay Area. He is a featured blogger at EducationNews.org, a leading international website for education issues. You can also follow his work on the blogsite, Teach4Real.com.

This post was originally published by New America Media.


Related Stories:

Murdered Within Earshot: Why Don’t We Respond?

Michigan Republicans Allow Bullying If ‘Religiously or Morally Motivated’

Another Virginia Tech Shooting


Photo from ThinkStock


Denise L.
Denise L5 years ago

someone who commits an assault should be charged by police

it is so unfair not only to the teachers but to the good hard-working students that they should be forced into such an environment

I believe a quality education is a right that everyone should have access to however if one cannot conduct themselves in a civilized manner than they forfeit that right

janet T.
janet t5 years ago

when I went to school, troublemakers were in a separate class, and someone who committed assault on another person would be expelled. In school, you were expected to behave or your parents would have to find somewhere that would take you, probably in another state. That was enough to make people behave, with no consequences, what do you expect but violence?

Martha Eberle
Martha Eberle6 years ago

This is beyond description, and I believe every word the teacher says. It shouldn't be allowed -- no reason, for money or anything else. No cursing, no hitting, of teachers or students. It's too horrendous for words, and this report should start the ball rolling.

Isabel Ramirez
Isabel Ramirez6 years ago


Patrick F.
Patrick f6 years ago

Should be first offence....expulsion.....next school, second offence....jail.

Kelley L.
Eileen Ley6 years ago

Umm, excuse me, Tracy F., your comment about "idiot lawyers" writing "crazy checks" for parents of children with behavior issues seems just a tad inappropriate to me. In primary school, I was one of the Floridian kids with behavior issues. It was revealed later that these issues were caused by sensory overload due to a mild form of Aspberger's Syndrome. The money my parents got from what you call "idiots" allowed me to get testing done that helped diagnose my disability. I'm not trying to say that all children who act "vulgar" have disabilities like I do. The kids in the above article definitely seemed out of line and "vulgar", and probably had no such issues. However, because there are kids like me whose behavior is an indicator of deeper problems, the laws you call idiotic exist in order to get kids help. Protecting kids who act out isn't always a bad thing like it is in this article.

Tracy F.
Tracy F6 years ago

Matt is correct about the situation as far as he went. I don't know if he's heard of "crazy checks" in San Fran. where he is from but the parents also get paid here in Florida for children that have behavioral issues. Also I think the schools get extra funding for these types of students not just for butts in seats. Some brilliant (short sighted) lawyer got our brilliant (stupid) court system to rule that a child with behavioral issues has a disability so the parents get paid. I assume this is a national thing. So now the parents get rewarded for the children being violent and vulgar. There are also caps on the number of days this type of student can be suspended because of their "disability" Of course we all know this is just hurting the student because they don't learn consequences but you know those brilliant (idiot) lawmakers. On the other hand a teacher does have the right to press charges against any student who assaults them (personal experience)

Juli Kring
Juli K6 years ago

Am I the only one wondering where the hell are the damn parents in all this ?

Mark Stevenson
Mark S6 years ago

Violent people need to be isolated from the rest of the community.

Dolly B.
Dolly Bisala6 years ago

Excellent post. When I was in school the troublemakers were paid by the government to finish school whereas those of us who behaved and studied by default just got on with it. Also bullies got away with bullying and driving students to other schools, and if the victim made an official complaint after a certain time period nothing could be done, and as always the onus is put on the victims i.e. 'don't let it get to you, be stronger than them, ignore them and they'll stop of pick on someone else'. What kind of useless and worrying advice is that?