5 Alternative Vegetable Jack-o’-Lanterns

The tradition of the Jack-o’-Lantern stems from England, Ireland and Scotland, where ghostly flickering lights, a natural phenomenon known as “ignis fatuus” or “fool’s fire” that might be seen in the distance over bogs, swamps or marshes and would disappear upon approach. It was thought to be trying to lure nighttime travelers off the safe roads. In Ireland, the story goes that an unsavory character named Stingy Jack kept tricking the devil into not claiming his soul upon death. When he got to heaven, he found that God didn’t want him because of his misdeeds, so he was condemned to roam the earth with nothing but a burning coal to light his way. He carved a turnip into a lantern and became known as “Jack o’ the Lantern.” People were so afraid he was coming to get them that they would carve their own pumpkins to scare him off.

Across Britain and the continent, people started making their own spooky lights from various indigenous hard vegetables that were carved out and lit from within with candles. Immigrants to America brought the tradition with them and began using locally grown pumpkins, which were larger and easier to carve.

If you’re looking to shake things up this Halloween, why not bring back a little of the old country?:

  • Winter Squash: Thick-skinned winter squashes such as Hubbard and Kabocha make for great alternatives to the traditional orange pumpkin. Mix them up for a variety of ghoulish options.
  • Gourds: Hard-shell gourds are one of the earliest domesticated crops, although they are not very edible. Their hard shell surrounds relatively little soft flesh, which quickly dries out within the shell. For this reason, they have more often been used as percussion instruments and utensils. Hollowed-out gourds also make for long-lasting candle lanterns, and very artistic patterns can be carved into the exterior shell.
  • Rutabaga: This root vegetable, also known as a yellow turnip, features a bulbous shape with a thick skin. There is a carved Irish Halloween turnip lantern on display at the Museum of Country Life in Ireland that would be certain to frighten anyone in the dark. Although smaller, rutabagas can be carved in a similar fashion to pumpkins, and their gnarly skin makes them all the more frightening. Martha Stewart, who is well known for her love of Halloween, has instructions for carving and hanging these ghoulish little heads in trees so they appear to be floating.
  • Avocados: While certainly not traditional, a very ghoulish visage can be carved into the dark green skin of an avocado which reveals the lighter green flesh and the red brown nut at its core.
  • Pineapple: How about a tropical and prickly Pineapple Jack-o’-Lantern? Its hard exterior and soft, fleshy interior will carve as easily as a pumpkin, and its leafy “hat” will cast a crazy shadow.

Pumpkin Nook
/ Wikipedia / History.com / About.com

Linda Merrill is an interior designer who works with Boston-area tile contractors and painters.



Your Halloween Pumpkin Pics!
10 Recycled DIY Halloween Decorations
Floating Pumpkin Candles

By Linda Merrill, Networx


Winn Adams
Winn A5 years ago


Manuela C.
Manuela C5 years ago


Jennifer C.
Past Member 5 years ago


J.L. A.
j A5 years ago

good to know

Sam M.
Sam E M5 years ago

Some good ideas. I think we'll stick with traditional, though these suggestions would make wonderful extras in addition to the pumpkin.

Sue H.
Sue H5 years ago

Thanks for the ideas.

Nimue Pendragon

I learned something today, I never knew what a rutabaga was, now I know it's what we in Australia call a swede (the vegetable, not a person from Sweden who is also called a Swede :)

a             y m.
g d c5 years ago


natalie n.
natalie n5 years ago

we could all appreciate the "health benefits" of these alternative vegs too ;)

John B.
John B5 years ago

Thanks Chaya for providing these great alternatives to pumpkins and the link to the Martha Stewart site.