Obama’s Dog vs. Romney’s Dog

If you have been following the news lately you are probably aware both President Obama and Mitt Romney are being hounded by personal dog stories. Most recently it came to light that as a child the President sampled dog meat when he lived in Indonesia. The incident is recorded in his book Dreams From My Father and†apparently happened only once when he was 6-10 years old and was in the presence of an Indonesian adult he trusted.

Does this incident put the President’s love for dogs into question? Currently, the President has a dog named Bo, and there have never been any reports of abuse towards him. (Before any of these dog news stories emerged, my acquaintance visited the White House and happened to see Bo walking around in the halls and he appeared to be nothing less than a normal, healthy dog.) Nevertheless, the President’s childhood dog-eating incident is being played up by his opponents.

The dog-eating news has spread in response to the stories criticizing Mitt Romney for an incident in the early 1980s,† when he placed the family dog Seamus in a dog carrier on the roof of a car for a family vacation. Most of these news stories depicted a fearful Seamus defecating in the carrier and on the car, because he reportedly was so uncomfortable. However, Ann Romney said recently the reason Seamus lost control of his bowels was that he stole a turkey from a kitchen counter before their trip and consequently had diarrhea during the journey.†Her story challenges the claim that Seamus’ upset stomach was a result of being terrified in his carrier and the view Mitt’s behavior was simply cruel.

Many of the news reports criticizing Mitt Romney’s Seamus incident fail to mention that he also saved a dog’s life in 2003, when a wooden boat on Lake Winnipesaukee in New Hampshire which was occupied by a family, started sinking. The Romneys were vacationing in the area and happened to see from the shore the people were in trouble on their sinking vessel, so the governor and his sons hopped on personal watercraft and zipped out to them. This story was reported in the New York Times, “The Romneys also saved the† family’s dog, he said.” More importantly, Governor Romney and his two sons helped save several people who were on board a sinking boat. “Romney brought people to shore while his sons stood by at the scene.” (Source: New York Times) The sinking boat was about 300 yards from the shore of Lake Winnipesaukee, and the people on board had donned life vests and jumped in the water.

There hasnít been much recent press at all describing this boat rescue, an event which took place just nine years ago, as compared to the reams of press dedicated to the car incident that happened 29 years ago.

For both Obamaís and Romneyís dog scenarios, there has been a rush to judgement, and too much finger pointing without complete information. Some of the misjudgments have been magnifying (making mountains out of molehills) and some have been selective filtering (choosing to see only certain details and overlooking others).

Then there is the idea that you can tell a lot about people by the way they treat animals. In this case, we donít know how each candidate has treated all animals throughout their entire lives. We only know about these isolated incidents.

Additionally, both Obama and Romney are meat eaters, as are most Americans. If we used the treatment of animals as a gauge of character, all meat eaters might be considered “bad.” But most people wouldn’t agree with that assessment.

In the end, these dog news stories seem more like a mirror than a window, revealing our own biases. Do you think these incidents were blown out of proportion by the media? Are they irrelevant to the election or do they reveal something significant about Obama and Romney?

Image Credit: tanakawho, Wiki Commons

Related Links
Dogs are Smarter than Cats, Says Study
Eating Less Meat Best for World


rene davis
irene davis5 years ago


Aud Nordby
Aud n5 years ago

You know how people are, see how they treat their animals.Thats how they are against people too!

Kelly A.
Kelly A.5 years ago

For news related to politics, Politics Today News App
This App is top rated on the AppStore and is a great one-stop App for real-time news and analysis on U.S. Politics.
PT pulls breaking news and content articles from publications, journalists, columnists, think tank, and beltway bloggers who publish across the Web. The App continuously monitors and adjusts online source lists to include new analysts and publications as well as opinion leaders of note.The App's user interface is beautiful and makes it easy to read articles and research on the iPad, simple and efficient. This is a great App for collecting and reading all this content into one place. It is the most useful politics related App on the iTunes Store.
This is one of the best Politics related App on the iTunes Store. It’s part of a series, all their Apps are on http://www.algoryt.hm

Christina Robertson
Tina Robertson5 years ago

Forget about how he treats his dog, how about how he treats his wife.....in the kitchen barefoot and pregnant.

Sheila L.
Sheila Swan L5 years ago

Completely blown out of proportion! Let's get real about who is going to do what and Obama is the guy who is going to help people and not be calling corporations people.

Roger M.
Past Member 5 years ago

I don't care about their wives, their children or their dogs.

I care about their politics. All the rest is window dressing and distraction.

Winn Adams
Winn A5 years ago


Mary Beth M.
MaryBeth M5 years ago

To compare the actions of a grown man with that of a child doing what he is told is foolish, naive and a gratuitous attempt by the Romney camp to get even, 'tit for tat'. While I love animals, am appalled by his calloused treatment of Seamus, I would not go so far as to call Romney an 'animal abuser'. I'd save that for his friend Malek (who beat & bbq'd a dog). To focus on this isolated incident misses the point. The Seamus incident represents the cold, calculating problem solver either oblivious or unconcerned with the ramifications of his decisions: seen over & again at prep school, Bain, his policy decisions, statements made regarding the poor, actions as governor, selective memory of his past, along with his pandering to the audience at hand twisting the truth along with outright lies. Deception, power and greed are his motivators. So, yes, his treatment of his dog is representative of his treatment of so many victims who have crossed his path. And, while I'm glad he saved the drowning dog, what else could he do? He had the dog's entire family as witnesses.

Maggie Carmel
Maggie Carmel5 years ago

Horrific! What a heartless man!
I hope they catch him and make him pay, but truly pay not just a small fine and that's it! He deserves more than that for punishment!
I'm sad for that horrible death of those two pups but very happy for the one that survived!

I just wish I could tie HIM to the tracks!

Malti Ragh
Lee ann p5 years ago

Sorry this is not exactly an objective article...in my opinion. How could anyone even compare what a child did to an adult 's willful behavior?? That too Obama didnt abuse an animal out of anger or carelessness..he ate meat thinking that it was a normal thing to do..
As a vegetarian, I feel that what Obama did was an inadvertent act compared to Mitt the Pitts' republican behavior.